Major Essay 482
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Athabasca University, Athabasca *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
482
Subject
Philosophy
Date
Dec 6, 2023
Type
docx
Pages
20
Uploaded by MateMole11270
Running head: IMPORTANCE OF CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE IN THE FIGHT FOR CIVIL RIGHTS
1
A Position Paper on the Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr’s Response to the Eight
White Alabama Clergymen
Student name
Athabasca University LGST 482/ PHIL 482: JURISPRUDENCE
Instructor name
June 13th, 2023
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
2
Introduction
Martin Luther King Jr.'s response to the Alabama clergymen, also known as his "Letter from Birmingham Jail," is a potent and significant work of literature that responds to the criticisms and issues brought up by eight white religious leaders who opposed King's nonviolent protests and demonstrations in Birmingham, Alabama. King's letter, which was written in April 1963, beautifully conveys his vision of racial equality and justice while outlining the reasons for and driving forces behind his civil rights movement. The main ideas in Martin Luther King Jr.'s response to the Alabama clergymen will be emphasized in this introduction, which will serve as a
springboard for the remainder of the analysis. Contextual Background
: It's fundamental to give some context in order to fully comprehend King's response. Birmingham, Alabama, was a city that had a history of racial segregation and prejudice at the beginning of the 1960s. King and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC) organized a number of nonviolent demonstrations, such as boycotts and sit-ins, to oppose the discriminatory Jim Crow laws and practices. The white community and government, however, reacted strongly against these protests. Responding to the Charges:
In Martin Luther King Jr.’s letter, written to the Clergymen from Birmingham Prison, he uses the rhetorical appeal of morality to establish his credibility on the subject of racism and injustice. He starts off the letter by addressing the Clergymen as his “Dear Fellows” which places
him as an equal among Men of Collar, transferring the communication that he's no lower than them and they're no better than him. In the letter's opening paragraph, King openly refutes the
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
3
clergymen's charges that his acts were "unwise and untimely." King justifies his choice to take direct action by arguing that it was necessary to tackle injustice immediately and nonviolently due to the urgency of the civil rights movement
(Jr, M. L. K. (2018). Waiting until a more convenient time, he contends, would merely prolong the pain and tyranny experienced by African Americans. Martin Luther King Jr. goes on to say, “I’m here because I've organizational ties then. But
more principally, I'm in Birmingham because injustice is here”. Dr. King is telling them that he has credibility on matters of injustice, not because he's the philanthropist of white honor, but because he's well-delved on the subject. King says, “I have the honor of serving as chairman of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, an association operating in every southern state, with headquarters in Atlanta, Georgia. We've some eighty- five related associations across the South, and one of them is the Alabama Christian Movement for Human Rights. constantly, we partake staff, educational, and fiscal coffers with our cells.” The purpose of the preface is to establish his credibility as a member of the United States of America. He's proving to them that he contains just as important intellect on the subject of injustice and racial discrimination if not more. Martin Luther King Jr. also appeals to pathos by showing the trials his people have gone through. King does this by using lines similar as, “When you have seen vicious mobs lynch your mothers and fathers at will and drown your sisters and sisters at whim,” and “When you have seen hate-filled policemen curse, kick, and even kill your black sisters and sisters.” In these lines,
he's using inflammatory language like “vicious mobs” and parallelism as “lynch your mothers and fathers at will and drown your brothers and sisters at whim”. By using this kind of language and judgment structure King is making you see what he and his family had to go through in those
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
4
tough times. Throughout the whole paragraph using this kind of judgment structure and a lot of imagery, the Clergymen start to feel what it would be like to be in King’s position and feel the pain and troubles he had to go through. It's really an emotional paragraph, and using this emotion
at the beginning of his letter captures the attention of his audience. This is exactly what King wanted in order to make the followership feel the strong emotion and pain he felt and convert them to keep reading the letter to hear what he has to say.
Nonviolent Resistance:
King's unwavering dedication to nonviolent resistance is one of the major themes of his response. He provides an explanation of the moral and tactical justifications for this strategy, bringing examples from historical individuals like Gandhi, Socrates, and Jesus Christ. King places a strong emphasis on the ability of love and nonviolent direct action to arouse the conscience of the oppressor and pave the way for peace and justice. Justice is Threatened by Injustice Throughout the World:
King genuinely thinks that injustice everywhere poses a threat to justice everywhere. King points out that injustice in one area has an impact on justice everywhere. He objects to the clergymen's counsel to seek change through the judicial system, claiming that the African American community has been waiting too long for the legal system to deliver justice and there was a clear lack of representation for Black folks within the judicial system. He stresses the fact that the fight for civil rights goes far beyond Birmingham and claims that his activities are a response to the great moral obligation to oppose injustice wherever it exists.
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
5
Segregation as an Existential Threat
: King argues that segregation has a negative impact on the African American community by skewing their perception of their own worth and sustaining structural injustice. He contends that the struggle against segregation is not just a political or legal matter but also an existential one that aims to uphold equality for all people and restore human dignity. The White Moderate:
Another important aspect of King's answer is his condemnation of the white moderate, whom he regards as impeding development. He criticizes their inaction and challenges them to speak up when order is put above justice. He contends that they allow racial discrimination to continue via their inaction, and he contends that only when justice and equality are present can there be true peace. Direct Action as a Last Resort:
In response to the clergymen's advice that King should wait for change to occur gradually, King emphasizes the urgency of the civil rights movement. He clarifies that after all other options for dialogue and reparation have been tried, direct action is the last alternative. The hardships and humiliations experienced by African Americans are vividly described by him, and he emphasizes the urgency of taking urgent action to improve their situation. Martin Luther King Jr. articulates the moral imperative guiding the civil rights movement in his response to the Alabama clergymen, offering a thorough and convincing defense of his nonviolent direct action. Defending himself against the allegations and issues brought forward by
his detractors.
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
6
Thesis Breakdown
In this essay, I will clearly discuss my reason for supporting Civil Disobedience, guided by the works of Martin Luther King Jr. My position will be discussed in the strengths found within the “Letter from a Birmingham Jail” in King’s response to the eight white clergymen.
Strengths Analysis
1.
Moral and ethical appeal: Even in the context of contemporary civil disturbance movements like the Me-Too movement, Black Lives Matter, and anti-Asian hate protests, Martin Luther King Jr.'s reaction to the Alabama clergymen can be perceived as having a significant moral and ethical appeal (Jr, M. L. K. (2018). King's letter is an articulate and passionate defense of
nonviolent direct action and a potent condemnation of the inequities of racial segregation. The inherent dignity and worth of every human being is one of the major moral and ethical concepts that underline King's approach. King underlines how crucial it is to respect and affirm the inherent worth of every person, and he contends that any rule or political structure that does so is inherently unjust. This idea is crucial to current initiatives like the Me-Too movement, which aims to address and stop sexual assault and harassment of women in workplaces. The Me-
Too movement's objectives of promoting respect, safety, and justice for sexual assault victims are
consistent with King's conviction in the inherent dignity of every person. Additionally, King's support for nonviolent resistance demonstrates a dedication to moral and
ethical values that can be used to analyze diverse civil unrest movements. He contends that peaceful protest is ethically preferable to violent protest in that it is both a practical way to bring about social change and a practical way to do it. The goal of Black Lives Matter is to address systematic racism and violence against Black people. Movements like this one can benefit from
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
7
the nonviolent concept. King advances the belief that everyone, regardless of race, ought to be treated with respect and dignity by promoting nonviolence. King's statement again emphasizes the significance of unity and group effort. The interconnection of all battles for equality and justice is highlighted in his argument that injustice everywhere is a threat to justice everywhere. The anti-Asian hate protests that aim to increase awareness of and combat violence and discrimination against the Asian minority are one example of how this principle is applicable to movements tackling many forms of discrimination.
King's appeal for cooperation is in line with the notion that social justice movements ought to band together to combat all types of injustice and discrimination. King's response not only stresses the value of patience and perseverance in the face of adversity but also makes numerous moral and ethical points. He understands that development frequently faces opposition, and that change takes time. As movements for civil unrest frequently
face criticism and backlash, this idea has resonance in the present. For those now engaged in ongoing battles for equality and justice, King's message of tenacity in the quest for justice can serve as inspiration and direction. Overall, Martin Luther King Jr.'s response to the clergymen from Alabama has a moral and ethical resonance that may be extended to contemporary civil disturbance movements. His focus on the dignity and intrinsic worth of every person, peaceful resistance, community, and tenacity in the face of hardship continues to ring true and serve as a guide for those working for social change.
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
8
2.
Nonviolent resistance: The famous "Letter from Birmingham Jail," in which Martin Luther King Jr. responded to the Alabama clergymen's criticism, can be considered as having relevance for current civil disturbance movements like the Me-Too campaign, Black Lives Matter, and anti-Asian hate protests. These modern groups may learn a lot from King's strategy for nonviolent protest, as outlined in his letter, which is a priceless resource. Martin Luther King Jr. emphasized in his letter the effectiveness of nonviolent direct action as a way to draw attention to and confront unfair societal structures (Letter from Birmingham Jail. (n.d.)). He argued that nonviolent resistance is an active and brave involvement with the issues at hand rather than the passive acceptance of injustice. This idea is consistent with movements like Me Too, Black Lives Matter, and anti-Asian marches, which aim to confront systemic injustices and overthrow repressive structures. First, the Me-Too movement can benefit from King's emphasis on the moral and spiritual aspects of peaceful resistance. The campaign strives to increase awareness of and fight against sexual assault and harassment. The movement promotes empathy, solidarity, and justice instead of employing violence or retaliation by taking a nonviolent stance and encouraging survivors to speak up and share their stories. This is similar to King's outlook on how to bring about long-
lasting change by appealing to the oppressor's conscience and looking for a higher moral foundation. Second, King's idea of using peaceful resistance to reveal underlying racial injustice is extremely applicable to the Black Lives Matter movement. This movement, like King's, calls for justice, equality, and an end to racial profiling while attempting to expose systematic racism and police violence. The movement emphasizes the ability of nonviolent resistance to confront and alter unjust laws and practices by using nonviolent protests, marches, and civil disobedience.
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
9
The anti-Asian hate rallies that have erupted in response to the surge in racism and violence against Asian populations can also be considered as being in line with King's nonviolent philosophy. These protests, which support peaceful resistance, seek to increase public understanding of anti-Asian prejudice, educate the public, and call for change. The protesters reject the cycle of violence and seek transformative change via peaceful means, just like King, and hope to confront hate with love, understanding, and togetherness. Overall, Martin Luther King Jr.'s reaction to the clergymen of Alabama, with its emphasis on nonviolent resistance, is still relevant and offers a template for the present civil disobedience movements. The objectives and tactics of campaigns like Me-Too, Black Lives Matter, and anti-
Asian hate protests are consistent with the values of nonviolence, moral appeal, and revealing underlying injustices. These movements are carrying on King's legacy of peacefully promoting justice, equality, and social change by taking inspiration from his strategy. 3.
Appeals to empathy and consciousness: The infamous "Letter from Birmingham Jail," which is Martin Luther King Jr.'s response to the Alabama clergymen, successfully invokes empathy
and consciousness. King uses convincing rhetoric and strong emotional pleas in his letter to question the unfair treatment of African Americans and to demand social change. Empathy is established via shared pain, as demonstrated by King in his discussion of the injustices and suffering experienced by African Americans. He discusses how segregation, police
violence, and the violation of fundamental human rights are experienced on a daily basis. King aims to make his readers understand the African American community's hardships by providing a
vivid image of them.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
10
Questioning the morals and ethics of the status quo, King makes an appeal to the consciences
of the clergymen and the larger society. He emphasizes the intrinsic value and dignity of every person, regardless of ethnicity. King contends that society as whole and individual citizens must take a position against oppression and injustice
(Modern Lessons from the Letter from Birmingham jail (n.d.)). Arguments based on moral and ethical standards: King makes his point using moral and ethical standards. In order to refute the clergymen's resistance to his action, he leans on religious doctrine and makes references to biblical characters and ideas. According to King, concerns of social justice and civil rights are not only political ones but also ones of right versus wrong and good vs evil. King emphasizes the humanity of African Americans and fights against the dehumanizing effects of segregation and discrimination by emphasizing that they are human beings. According to his argument, unfair laws degrade both the oppressed and the oppressor, weakening the moral foundation of society. King implores his audience to recognize the shared humanity that unites the marginalized by humanizing them. King emphasizes universal principles like justice, equality, and freedom in his call for a common language. He explains to the clerics and the larger crowd how the fight for racial rights is consistent with the ideals upon which America was created (Letter from Birmingham Jail. (n.d.)). King appeals to his audience's sense of justice and fairness by situating his argument within the framework of these common principles. Call for action and empathy: Throughout the letter, King exhorts the clergy and the general public to consider themselves to be African Americans and to act to combat injustice (A
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
11
Summary., 2023). He exhorts them to recognize the seriousness of the civil rights movement and the necessity for rapid and significant change. In conclusion, by eloquently describing the suffering endured by African Americans, drawing upon universal moral norms, and urging compassion and action, Martin Luther King Jr.'s response to the Alabama clergymen successfully
invokes empathy and consciousness. His letter is still a potent example of the application of empathy and consciousness in the cause of social justice. 4.
Strategic organization and mobilization: The "Letter from Birmingham Jail," written by Martin Luther King Jr. in response to the Alabama pastors, served as an example of effective planning and mobilization in the context of the civil rights struggle (Modern lessons from the letter from Birmingham jail (n.d.)). We may draw comparisons between King's method and the tactics used in these contemporary civil unrest movements, despite
the fact that the movements you specifically mentioned such as the Me-Too movement, Black Lives Matter, and anti-Asian demonstrations emerged after King's time. King made it clear in "Letter from Birmingham Jail" why the civil rights movement was important and how quickly racial injustice needed to be addressed. Similar to these groups, Me Too and Black Lives Matter seek to highlight social injustice and structural oppression. By using a variety of tactics, including social media campaigns, public speeches, and protests, they get their issues known and enlist support from the general public. King emphasized the value of strategic planning and forging allies with many organizations. In order to gather resources and support for the campaign, he worked in conjunction with civil rights organizations, religious figures, and local communities. Similar to earlier movements, contemporary movements like Black Lives Matter and the
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
12
Me-Too campaign place a strong emphasis on forming alliances with a variety of stakeholders, including grassroots activists, community organizations, celebrities, and advocacy groups. This tactical group aids in amplifying its message and creating a widespread change movement. King understood how important public opinion and media coverage were in determining how the civil rights movement turned out. In order to spread his message and win over the people, he exploited the media channels efficiently. Similar to earlier movements, contemporary ones make use of online campaigns, social media platforms, and viral videos to reach a wider audience and question prevailing narratives. To get publicity and influence public opinion, they also work with the traditional media. King's vision for social justice extended beyond racial equality, despite the fact that this was his primary area of concern. He recognized how various battles were interconnected and wanted to stand in solidarity with other outcast groups (Jr, M. L. K. (2018)). Similar to how the Black Lives Matter and Me-Too campaigns address the intertwined experiences of racism, sexism, homophobia, and other forms of oppression, modern movements also acknowledge the significance of intersectionality. In order to fight injustice as a united front, they promote unity among various communities. 5.
Long-term vision and commitment: In fact, Martin Luther King Jr.'s response to the Alabama clergymen, as described in his well-known "Letter from Birmingham Jail," demonstrates a commitment to long-term vision and dedication that is comparable to contemporary civil unrest movements like the Me-Too movement, Black Lives Matter, and anti-Asian hate demonstrations. King's answer displays his awareness of the
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
13
interconnectivity of social justice efforts and the need for persistent commitment to bring about long-lasting change. In his remark, King demonstrated his dedication to a long-term vision for social change (Jr, M. L. K. (2018)). He stresses that the struggle for civil rights is an ongoing fight for justice and equality rather than being restricted to a specific event or time. Similar to this, activists in contemporary movements like Black Lives Matter and the Me-Too campaign have realized the importance of long-term solutions to systemic problems rather than concentrating only on short-
term wins. The interconnectedness of various injustices is acknowledged in King's statement. He makes the case that racial discrimination isn't the only social issue that has to be addressed; economic inequality and other issues are also threats to justice everywhere. This viewpoint is in line with modern movements like Black Lives Matter, which acknowledges the interconnectedness of racial, social class, and gender issues in the struggle against institutional oppression. In his statement, King emphasized the value of community involvement and grassroots activism in bringing about change. He emphasizes how boycotts, protests, and direct action may energize popular sentiment and put pressure on institutions to deal with structural problems (King & Hornsby, 1986). This strategy is reflected in modern movements like Black Lives Matter, which place a strong emphasis on the ability of group action and grassroots organizing to
undermine established power structures and call for social justice. King emphasizes in his letter the need for sacrifice and dedication in order to bring about long-term change. He realizes the dangers and struggles on a personal level that come with questioning the established system, but he insists that justice demands unflinching dedication. In
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
14
a similar vein, contemporary movements like Black Lives Matter, the Me-Too campaign, and anti-Asian hate protests have seen people giving up their own freedoms to further their causes, demonstrating their long-term dedication to justice and equality. A long-term vision and dedication to social change are exemplified by Martin Luther King Jr.'s answer to the Alabama pastors. He emphasizes the need for persistent efforts, interrelated struggles, nonviolent resistance, grassroots mobilization, and individual commitment in resolving
issues like racial inequality, gender discrimination, and social injustice (King & Hornsby, 1986). His beliefs are relevant to modern civil unrest movements. While modifying their tactics to meet today's difficulties, these movements are inspired by King's legacy. In his response to the Alabama clergymen, Martin Luther King Jr. displayed qualities that are still relevant and helpful for current civil disturbance activities. His moral and ethical appeal, nonviolent resistance, appeals to empathy and consciousness, strategic organization and mobilization and long-term vision continue to serve as an example and a source of inspiration for
those working to address social injustices and build a more just society. Weaknesses Analysis
Analyzing or moreover critiquing statements written by icons such as Martin Luther King Jr.,
is an apolitically sensitive undertaking. Such written conclusions could even come across as offensive to some people. However, it is a necessary undertaking in order to merge the modern Civil Disobedience movements with his points of view. To understand this fact, we only have to realize that since Martin Luther King Jr., has been one of the key players in some of humanity´s most important political advances ever, he has become a symbol and his words have become a mantra. This is exactly the reason why we have to submit his opinions for constant revision. I am
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
15
pretty sure that if he were still alive, he would want us to discuss his ideas in order to get better results and not allow his work to become something unlinked with the present reality. As the laws, the constitutions, and the societies themselves are evolving constantly, our interpretation of
our leader’s thoughts must evolve as well. In that sense, there are three ideas that deserve to be reconsidered in Martin Luther King’s response in “Letter from a Birmingham Jail” since they could be problematic from nowadays perspective.
First, there is the theory according to which the morality and justice principles that must rule our society and the seeking of equality for all should flow from a religious tradition. In other
words, the Christian church should work as an engine of change. The second idea is to discuss whether violence is justified or not even if it is used to defend a just cause. The third idea is that Martin Luther King’s argumentation drove the cause of civil rights the wrong way because he didn’t go far enough. His strategy left out the fight of some people like atheists and Muslims for instance.
First, religion as a basis for the fight against segregation: Martin Luther King Jr. builds up
his argument overall based on religious aspects instead of the scientific fact that there are no significant differences between human beings. That people, no matter their race or gender, are capable of any success or failure. In a democracy, no one can be judged or treated for the color of
their skin or their ideas; one has to be judged for their actions and their respect for the law. Dr. King uses none of the fundamentals of international public laws. For example, since The French Revolution, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights placed segregation and racism as crimes against humanity. The problems of that kind of religious fundamentals are various. The most obvious is that the opposing party, the segregationist, could simply argue that they don’t believe in God, or that they don’t believe in the same way that Dr. King believes. Therefore, Dr. King’s
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
16
morality based on Christianity would not apply to them. Moreover, justifying morality according to the word of God is a dangerous thing, even when the intention is the best. For some people God says one thing, for others, God could say the opposite, and for those that don’t believe, it would not make sense. That is the reason why many modern democracies are secular systems where laws tend to come from social and scientific facts and not from anybody’s faith.
Second, when it comes to the legitimacy of using violence in extreme cases, again, King uses religion as a guide to explain why violence could never be used as a means to end discrimination against Black folks in Alabama. At that moment and as a strategy, he was probably right. The forces between the parts were too uneven. Besides, Dr. King knew that the federal government barely had the capacity for action since they were stuck in a terrible and unpopular war in Vietnam, and riots and demonstrations were happening every day in the universities across the country. However, if we look at his decisions from today’s point of view and attend to the fact that minorities are still suffering the injustice of economic segregation and police brutality, among other injustices, we can say that he did not go far in his approach. Therefore, we can rethink if appealing to violence to avoid those problems could be considered just self-defense. For example: when communities are being devastated by poverty, drugs, and criminality, and the authorities don’t do anything to protect them just because they are black, Latin, or American Natives, don’t they have the right to fight back? Moreover, when they have to
watch every day on television the awful crimes that some authorities commit against minorities with no punishment in most cases, don’t they have the right to defend their own life? It is a fact that violence is not desirable, but we have to be reminded that the end of slavery in the United States cost a civil war, that the liberation of Europe from the oppression of Nazis cost the life of more than 220,000 American soldiers, and that the combats in the streets of Paris during The
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
17
French revolution allowed Haiti to become the first country in the American continent to abolish slave trade/slavery. There is no easy answer about whether violence is necessary or not in some extreme cases.
Third, the heritage of Martin Luther King’s strategy: Almost nobody doubts that Dr. King
contributed in a decisive way to the end of many forms of segregation in the United States. He is probably one the most important American citizens ever, but his strategy of “turn the other chick”, perhaps has spread the idea among minorities that violence is an asset that only the majority can use even when it is used in inappropriate or illegal ways. Perhaps they think that the
only thing they can do is to resist using only nonviolent methods no matter how poor or humiliated they are. From a humanistic point of view, this is a wonderful idea but in reality, segregation still stands, violence against marginalized communities still stands, and the authorities don’t do enough to change those facts yet. Martin Luther King Jr’s methods do not go
far enough. Justice and religion should be separated. It is imperative to find out a middle term between non-violent resistance and the legitimate right of self-defense.
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
18
Conclusion
Martin Luther King Jr.'s response to the Alabama clergymen in his well-known "Letter from Birmingham Jail" demonstrated his extraordinary capacity to express his views on civil rights and the necessity of nonviolent resistance. He made clear how strongly he felt about his positions by basing them on moral, ethical, and constitutional foundations. King's rebuttal had several qualities, among them his deft use of rhetorical tropes and evocative metaphors, which gave his point more weight and resonance. King also successfully refuted the clergymen's charges of impatience and outside interference by highlighting the necessity of the civil rights fight and the interconnectivity of all communities. King's statement may have some flaws, while,
including more of the systemic and economic causes of racial disparity could have improved his overall case. Although generations have since been inspired to fight for justice, equality, and freedom for all, King's strong and passionate words continue to ring true.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
19
References
A summary and analysis of Martin Luther King’s ‘Letter from Birmingham Jail’. (2023, March 10). Interesting Literature. https://interestingliterature.com/2023/03/letter-from-
birmingham-jail-summary-analysis/
Dworkin, R. (2001). On Not Prosecuting Civil Disobedience. In J. Arthur and W.H. Shaw (Eds.), Readings in the Philosophy of Law (3rd ed.) (pp. 71–77). Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice-Hall.
Jr, M. L. K. (2018, April 4). Martin Luther King Jr. ’s ‘Letter from Birmingham Jail’. The Atlantic. https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/02/letter-from-a-
birmingham-jail/552461/
King, M.L., Jr., and Hornsby, A., Jr. (intro.). (1986). Martin Luther King, Jr. “Letter from Birmingham Jail” (1963, April 16). The Journal of Negro History
, 71(1/4): 38–44. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2717650
Letter from Birmingham Jail. (n.d.). Encyclopedia of Alabama. Retrieved 2 June 2023, from https://encyclopediaofalabama.org/article/letter-from-birmingham-jail/
Modern lessons from the Letter from Birmingham Jail | Michigan State University College of Communication Arts and Sciences. (n.d.). Retrieved 2 June 2023, from https://comartsci.msu.edu/about/newsroom/news/modern-lessons-letter-birmingham-jail
Statement by Eight Alabama Clergymen
: April 12, 1963. (1963). The Birmingham Public Library. Retrieved March 4, 2019, from https://ibs.cru.org/index.php/download_file/view/1262/
Key Points in Martin Luther King Jr.’s Response to the Alabama Clergymen
20