Project 1 Critique Essay Outline

doc

School

Centennial College *

*We aren’t endorsed by this school

Course

171

Subject

English

Date

Apr 3, 2024

Type

doc

Pages

Uploaded by MateRook14526

1 Project 1: Critique Essay Outline Name: Anmoljeet kaur Centennial College Course-Section: 710 Professor: Sonia Senior- Martin Date: 23-09-2023

2 Critique Essay Outline Template (10%) Part 1: Using the source, you picked in Unit 2, identify the rhetorical context in point form: Author: Andrew Coyne, an established journalist and commentator with a background discussing societal and technological issues. Purpose: This article aims to assess and deliberate on the obstacles and potential dangers posed by the rapid expansion of artificial intelligence, while promoting proactive strategies to alleviate these perils. Genre: Opinion piece in news paper Language: Formal Timeliness: Published on May 6,2023, it is a current and relevant source. Part 2: What types of persuasive techniques has the writer used? Find an example to support your response. Your author may have used one or all three. Ethos (appealing to authority): He discusses Geoffrey Hinton, a renowned AI expert, who expresses sorrow over his life's work, implying that even AI experts are concerned about the implications of his work. Pathos (appealing to the audience’s emotions): To evoke powerful emotional responses from the audience, he used emotionally charged phrases like "human extension." Logos (using facts, evidence, and logic) He provides logical arguments, supported by evidence and facts, illustrating the high expenses of AI research, the need for huge data and processing capacity, and the hazards of unregulated AI advancement.

3 Part 3: Fill out the t-chart and evaluate the effectiveness of the article using the CRAAP TEST. Circle yes or no and then explain and find an example from the text. Some instructors will do this with you in class if you are part of a DLO or in-person session. Currency Is it current? Yes or No Relevance Is it relevant: Yes or No Authority Does the author have experience discussing the topic? Are there authority figures used in the supports? Yes or No Accuracy Is the article accurate? You may need to do a little bit of fact checking. Yes or No Purpose Does the author achieve their purpose? Yes or No Yes, the article is of contemporary relevance by its publication date of May 2023, thereby validating its timeliness and significance in the present era. Yes, it is extremely relevant to the conflict around the exponential evolution of artificial intelligence. It goes into the concerns and implications of AI development in term of modern society. The author, Andrew Coyne, is well known for discussing both social and technical issues and has a long history as a seasoned journalist and commentator. The article appears to give facts accurately. It analyses investigates possible risks and concerns about AI, avoids baseless claims, and relies on logical reasoning and evidence. Yes, the main goal of the author is to undertake a critical analysis of the difficulties caused by the rapid growth of AI which is accomplished successfully by providing a strong argument Supported by strong evidence. To support his arguments, he mentions experts in the field of artificial intelligence, such as Geoffrey Hinton. This enhances the article's authority and reliability. However, it could benefit if there were more fact- checking and data to enhance accuracy.

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help

4 Part 4: Outline Write in complete sentences or point form. Make sure that your ideas are clear if you are using point form. Use ONE framework for each response section: Currency, Relevance, Authority, Accuracy, Purpose, Appeal to emotion, Bias, Hasty generalizations, etc. Introduction Hook: Does the exponential advancement of AI indicate potential unforeseen dangers? Title, author, year, published in, context: The article “ Dr. Frankenstein awakens to the AI monster he has made” by Andrew Coyne was published in The Globe and Mail in 2023. The essay explores the rapid evolution of artificial intelligence and the issues expressed by the authorities about the potentially harmful consequences of unregulated AI growth. Thesis: Create a thesis statement that indicates your evaluation of the source. In other words, do you think the article is effective or flawed? The essay builds a convincing argument for the importance of controlling artificial intelligence by carefully utilizing persuasive strategies and depending on reliable sources, creating a powerful and well-supported stance. Summary Edit and paste your summary paragraph from Project1: Process Assignment here. In “Dr. Frankenstein Awakens to the AI Monster He Has Made”, Andrew Coyne (2023) addresses issues regarding the consequences of artificial intelligence. The potential for artificial intelligence to outperform human intelligence and make judgments on its own is cause for alarm. The author advocates establishing regulatory measures and controlling AI to ensure that the advancement of this innovative technology generates beneficial results. This

5 essay provides an in-depth study of the level of requisite extent of regulation for artificial intelligence, considering the enormous expenditures made by technology corporations and universities in its progress. Response Segment 1 Write a topic sentence choosing a framework that evaluates the article. In other words, is the article written well, or are there gaps and flaws? The article demonstrates a proficient level of writing and effectively argues for the regulation of artificial intelligence, using effective methods and reliable evidence. Use evidence (examples, quotations, and analysis) to support the topic sentence and comment on the evidence. 1. The author uses terms like "rapid AI advancement" and "unregulated AI expansion" to express the significance of the circumstances, for capturing audiences immediately. 2. The essay skilfully employs persuasive strategies that appeal to both emotions and intellect to construct a compelling and attractive tale. 3. The article's comprehensive and interesting narrative by the author successfully conveys its message. Response Segment 2 Write a topic sentence choosing another framework that evaluates the article. In other words, is the article written well, or are there gaps and flaws? There are certain crucial and actual errors in the article that demand addressing.

6 Use evidence (examples, quotations, and analysis) to support the topic sentence and comment on the evidence. 1. The article should provide more specific examples or insights into potential regulatory measures to address concerns about AI development. 2. It might be helpful to provide additional instances or statistical proof to support claims concerning the impacts of unrestrained AI growth to make certain assertions in the article more accurate. 3. The essay could have provided specific case studies or real-world examples to back up its arguments regarding the effects of unchecked AI advancement and offer more convincing proof. Conclusion Restate the thesis statement: In conclusion, the article effectively convinces readers about the imperative need for regulation in the field of Artificial Intelligence (AI) by employing adept persuasive techniques and authoritative references. Restate the main points: The analysis does a satisfactory task of conveying the issue's seriousness, supports its reliability with credible sources, and uses strong arguments, but there are some inaccuracies in the analyses' precision and correctness that might be fixed to make it more thorough. Add a memorable statement: This article emphasizes the need for AI regulation to address its potential dangers and protect humanity's future. It highlights the importance of accurate guidance and heeding the call for regulation to shape the future of this technology. DECLARATION OF AUTHORSHIP

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help

7 I confirm that I am the sole author of “ Dr. Frankenstein awakens to the AI monster he has made.” This means that the assignment is my own work. I developed the ideas for, wrote, formatted, and edited the assignment. I did not get the assistance of other individuals. In addition, any sources that I refer to in the assignment have been acknowledged and cited. Further, artificial intelligence tools (e.g., ChatGPT, Grammarly) were not used in this assessment. This assessment has not been submitted for any other course, and I understand that it will be vetted by Turnitin for its use of sources and for detection of AI-generated content. Name: Anmoljeet Kaur Signature: Anmoljeet Kaur Date: 23-09-2023

8 Reference Coyne, A. (2023, May 06). Dr. Frankenstein awakens to the AI monster he has made: The exponential growth of artificial intelligence could have catastrophic consequences, and leading researchers in the field are speaking out about their fears. But it’s not too late to change course. The Globe and Mail http://ra.ocls.ca/ra/login.aspx? inst=centennial&url=https://www.proquest.com/newspapers/dr-frankenstein-awakens-ai-monster-he-has-made/ docview/2810046301/se-2

Project 1 Critique Essay Outline

Related Documents