ESL 3303 - Case Study (Cynthia)
pdf
keyboard_arrow_up
School
University of Houston, Downtown *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
3303
Subject
English
Date
Feb 20, 2024
Type
Pages
6
Uploaded by khanhphan0708
Khanh Phan
ESL 3303
Case Study
Fall 2023
Case Study
Organization for the Case Study (Final)
Student’s Name: Cynthia (Elementary)
I.
Background Information
Give information about your student. Identify some of the areas of concern that
you think are academically challenging.
Cynthia, a second-year student in the ESOL program, encountered a series of
challenges in her education while adjusting to a new life in America. The scenario
suggests that she arrived from Puerto Rico with limited English proficiency, having no
prior knowledge of the English language. Despite her mother's active participation in
her educational journey, attending conferences, and addressing concerns even
during working hours, a language barrier persisted at home as her father only spoke
Spanish. Cynthia's academic struggles were evident, particularly in math and Spanish
reading and writing skills, where she fell behind her grade level. Although she
participated in a phonics program to enhance her decoding and English sound
system, she continued to struggle with ending consonants. At first, Cynthia
depended on her bilingual classmates, but she demonstrated resilience in becoming
more independent. However, her academic progress was completely in contrast to
her classmates. Her advancement is hindered by obstacles related to confidence and
motivation. Although her engagement in independent reading was beneficial, her
preference for socializing over educational programs like Accelerated Reading may
disrupt her. The decision for her retention, supported by both her teacher and
mother, underscores the severity of academic gaps. Furthermore, persistent
challenges in math, Spanish language skills, and a lack of confidence present
significant barriers to her academic success. Overcoming these challenges requires a
comprehensive approach, including language development, advancements in math
skills, consistent parental engagement, personalized strategies for enhancing
motivation and self-esteem, and the cultivation of confidence across a range of
academic subjects.
ESL 3303 – Case Study
Page
1
II.
Assessment and Evaluation
Describe what language theories you might consider to use when teaching this
student. Give a description about what your student can do and what your student
cannot do.
Numerous English Language Learners (ELLs) often experience anxiety and a sense of
being overwhelmed in foreign environments where language comprehension is
challenging. This difficulty extends to participating in regular classrooms where
content subjects like language arts, math, science, and social studies are exclusively
taught in English. The case of Cynthia, who has limited English proficiency in
speaking, listening, writing, and reading, highlights the need for a comprehensive
approach in the ESOL program. Utilizing a combination of language theories is
recommended to address her diverse language needs. The Grammar-Translation
Method reinforces Cynthia's understanding of English grammar and structure by
utilizing her existing proficiency in Spanish, bridging the gap between the two
languages for a smoother transition. The Audiolingual Approach, emphasizing
repetitive drills and oral practice, is valuable for improving her phonics skills. The
Communicative Approach is crucial for Cynthia's development, focusing on authentic
communication and meaningful interactions. By encouraging her to engage actively
in discussions, both within and outside the classroom, her ability for effective
communication is improved. This approach supports her transition from relying on
bilingual classmates to independently communicating in English-speaking settings.
The Total Physical Response Approach (TPR) is adapted to align with Cynthia's
preference for independent reading and her lack of motivation to participate in
formal testing. This approach incorporates physical movement and actions to
strengthen language learning, offering a kinesthetic element that aligns with
Cynthia's learning style. It is essential to maintain flexibility and adaptability in
implementing these language theories, in addition to ongoing communication with
her supportive mother, to effectively address Cynthia's unique linguistic challenges
and foster a positive language-learning experience.
III.
Plan of Action
Describe the activities that you would use to help this student comprehend your
subject in detail.
In addressing Cynthia's language learning difficulties in the ESOL program, I would
implement three targeted activities to enhance her comprehension and
engagement. The first activity, named "Literary Exploration Book Club," centers
ESL 3303 – Case Study
Page
2
around Cynthia's preference for independent reading. Within this activity, Cynthia
and her classmates collaboratively select books to match their individual interests
and reading abilities. Consistent discussions and reflections in English provide a
social and engaging context, offering Cynthia opportunities to enhance her language
skills. The goal of this book club is to transform reading into a more interactive and
enjoyable experience, fostering a positive attitude toward language learning. The
second activity, the multimedia storytelling project, "My Journey," provides Cynthia
with a creative outlet to express herself. Through this project, she has the
opportunity to craft a multimedia presentation detailing her immigration from
Puerto Rico to the United States. By incorporating images, narration, and written
elements, Cynthia not only refines her English writing skills but also shares her
unique cultural background with her classmates. This project fosters self-expression,
enhances confidence, and cultivates a positive perspective on her language journey.
In the final activity, known as "Language Bridge Journaling," Cynthia engages in
maintaining a journal to document her thoughts and experiences in English. This
activity is essential as it involves expressing ideas in English, utilizing her
foundational writing skills in the language. The journaling process offers a personal
and reflective space for Cynthia to strengthen her confidence in her writing abilities.
These activities are specifically designed to address Cynthia's individual challenges
and strengths, providing a comprehensive approach that integrates language
development into engaging assignments. The goal is to cultivate a positive and
inclusive learning environment, empowering Cynthia through active participation
and establishing a foundation for her advanced language skills and academic success.
IV.
Connection to Theory
As you begin to think about this teaching and learning process, connect the
learning theories that we have discussed about in class.
●
Language Theories (Natural Approach – TPR, etc.)
In addressing Cynthia's diverse language learning needs within the ESOL
program, it is crucial to incorporate a combination of language theories. Given
her initial limited English proficiency, the inclusion of the Grammar-Translation
Method and the Audiolingual Approach becomes imperative. The
Grammar-Translation Method, focusing on grammar rules and translation
exercises, can provide Cynthia with a foundation to understand English syntax
and structure. The Audiolingual Approach, emphasizing oral drills and repetitive
practice, is valuable for addressing her articulation difficulties and fostering
ESL 3303 – Case Study
Page
3
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
accurate pronunciation and sound patterns. As Cynthia has advanced in
independent communication, it is crucial to shift towards the Communicative
Approach and the Total Physical Response Approach (TPR). The Communicative
Approach, emphasizing real-life communication and meaningful language use, is
aligned with Cynthia's need to express herself in everyday situations. The Total
Physical Response Approach (TPR), integrating physical actions with language
input, continues to play a vital role in making language learning interactive and
engaging for Cynthia, especially considering her initial shyness. A dynamic
integration of the Grammar-Translation Method, Audiolingual Approach,
Communicative Approach, and Total Physical Response Approach (TPR) is
essential to address Cynthia's evolving language needs. These language theories
offer her a comprehensive language education, addressing specific challenges
such as articulation difficulties, lack of confidence, and limited motivation while
creating a supportive environment for her academic growth in English.
●
Learning Styles (True Colors – Gold – Blue – Green – Orange)
Cynthia's learning styles align with the Green personality dimension of True
Colors, as evidenced by her preference for independent reading, reluctance to
engage in the Accelerated Reading program, and her capacity to communicate
independently by the middle of her first year. To support a learner with
characteristics resembling Cynthia's Green personality, it is crucial to provide
environments that stimulate curiosity and permit self-directed exploration.
Utilizing project-based learning tasks, encouraging her to explore topics of
personal interest, and offering opportunities for creative expression can use her
natural curiosity, promoting a deeper connection with the language. Recognizing
her preference for independent reading emphasizes the significance of
presenting a diverse range of materials aligned with her individual interests,
allowing her to select texts that deeply connect with her, thereby enhancing her
enthusiasm for language learning. Furthermore, the incorporation of this
learning style could entail introducing a personalized reading journal or
participating in literature circles within small groups. These methods not only
promote independent reading but also offer chances for meaningful discussion
and social interaction, thereby enriching the overall learning experience.
●
Learning Theories (Cooperative Learning, Whole Group, Small Group,
Individual, Centers, etc.)
ESL 3303 – Case Study
Page
4
Cynthia's learning styles suggest that a combination of small group and individual
learning approaches would be beneficial to address her specific needs and
overcome challenges. Considering her initial reliance on bilingual classmates
during the first year, engaging in small group activities can create a supportive
and less challenging environment. In this setting, Cynthia can actively interact
with her classmates, enhancing her communication skills and gaining confidence
through shared experiences. Collaborative learning activities, like small group
discussions or projects, can contribute to language skill development while also
benefiting from the support of her classmates. Nevertheless, it is crucial to
implement individual learning when taking into account Cynthia's transition to
independent communication. Her preference for independent reading indicates a
self-directed learning style. The use of personalized materials that align with her
language proficiency and the encouragement of independent research or
projects can strengthen her ability to work independently. An ideal combination
involves integrating small groups to promote social interaction, along with
individual learning for her independent reading preferences. These learning
strategies acknowledge her educational journey from dependence to
independence and provide crucial support to effectively address her language
development challenges.
V.
Personal Reflection
Describe what you personally have learned from working with an ELL student.
What do you know now that is different from before you started?
Working with an English Language Learner (ELL) student like Cynthia was an
eye-opening experience that significantly deepened my understanding of the
complexities and challenges involved in acquiring a new language. Prior to this
experience, I might have underestimated the multifaceted nature of language
acquisition and the importance of offering comprehensive support to ELL students.
Cynthia's journey of transitioning to a new country with limited English proficiency
highlighted the significance of addressing not only language barriers but also
considering the broader educational context. It becomes clear that supporting ELL
students goes beyond language instruction alone. Collaborating with Cynthia's
mother, who despite language limitations actively engaged with the teacher and
supported Cynthia's learning, underscores the crucial role of parental involvement in
a student's academic success. This experience highlights the importance of fostering
strong partnerships with parents, even when there are language barriers. Cynthia's
academic struggles in both English and Spanish emphasize the need for targeted
ESL 3303 – Case Study
Page
5
interventions that address not only the acquisition of the new language but also the
maintenance of proficiency in the native language. It is essential to provide support
that strengthens both languages to ensure overall language development.
Furthermore, Cynthia's hesitation to participate in certain academic activities, like
the Accelerated Reader program, reminds me of the significance of considering
individual learning preferences. It is crucial to implement strategies and activities to
foster motivation and confidence in ELL students, ensuring their active engagement
in the learning process. My experience with Cynthia reinforces the idea that effective
ELL education requires a comprehensive approach. It involves addressing linguistic
and academic challenges to provide support for ELL students. By recognizing and
addressing the complexities involved, I can better equip these students for success in
their educational journey.
ESL 3303 – Case Study
Page
6
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help