Ethics In Business
Consumers and attorney generals in more than 40 states accused a prominent nationwide chain of auto repair shops of misleading customers and selling them unnecessary parts and services, from brake jobs to front-end alignments. Lynn Sharpe Paine reported the situation as follows in Managing for Organizational Integrity” Harvard Business Review Volume 72 Issue 3:
In the face of declining revenues, shrinking market share, and an increasingly competitive market. . . management attempted to spur performance of its auto Centers.. . . The automotive service advisers were given product-specific sales quotas—sell so many springs shock absorbers, alignments, or brake jobs per shift—and paid a commission based on sales. . .
[F]ailure to meet quotas could lead to a transfer or a reduction in work hours. Some employees spoke of the “pressure. Pressure, pressure” to bring in sales.
This pressure-cooker atmosphere created conditions under which employees felt that the only way to satisfy top management was by selling products and services to customers that they didn’t really need.
Suppose all automotive repair businesses routinely followed the practice of attempting to sell customers unnecessary parts and services.
Required:
- How would this behavior affect customers? How might customers attempt to protect themselves against this behavior?
- How would this behavior probably affect profits and employment in the automotive service industry?
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solutionChapter P Solutions
MANAG ACCT F/..(LL)+CONNECT W/PROCTORIO+
- Identify the major problems in this situation and explain how they impact the organization. You will need to consider both behavioral and analytical factors. Specifically, how might managerial accounting concepts, tools, or techniques be applied to help resolve this dilemma? What are possible consequences of applying the same to this dilemma? Briefly explain Orange Electronics has been experiencing declining profit margins and has been looking for ways to increase operating income. It cannot raise selling prices for fear of losing business to its competitors. It must either cut costs or improve productivity. The company uses a standard cost system to evaluate the performance of the soldering department. It investigates all unfavorable variances at the end of the month. The soldering department rarely completes the operations in less time than the standard allows (which would result in a favorable variance). In most months, the variance is zero or slightly unfavorable. Reasoning that…arrow_forwardgive answarrow_forwardInternal Control System Required: A list of terms and another list of definitions and examples are presented below. Match the directly related definition or example with the each term. Strategic risk Control environment Information and communication Business process risk Monitoring A member of upper management was fired for violating the company's code of conduct. The internal audit group is testing the operating effectiveness of various internal control activities. Competitors begin offering extended warranty coverage on products. Problems with our suppliers have resulted in lost sales because our stores were out of stock. Reports documenting problems with production are forwarded to management.arrow_forward
- The SEC is trying to get companies to notify the investment community more quickly when a "material change" will affect their forthcoming financial results. In what sense might a financial manager be seen as "more ethical" if he or she follows this directive and issues a press release indicating that sales will not be as high as previously anticipated? A manager at a "Check Into Cash" business (see Focus on Ethics box on page 192) defends his business practice as simply "charging what the market will bear." "After all," says the manager, "we don't force people to come in the door." How would you respond to this ethical defense of the payday-advance business? Bond rating agencies have invested significant sums of money in an effort to determine which quantitative and nonquantitative factors best predict bond defaults. Furthermore, some of the raters invest time and money to meet privately with corporate personnel to get nonpublic information that is used in assigning the issue's bond…arrow_forwardIn the complex landscape of business decisions, the question of when to drop an unprofitable customer emerges as a strategic concern for many companies. In considering the decision of when to drop an unprofitable customer, what factors should a company weigh to strike a balance between short-term financial losses and long-term strategic gains? Reflect on the ethical implications of discontinuing a customer relationship and how it may impact the company's reputation. Additionally, discuss alternative approaches to managing unprofitable customers, such as implementing price adjustments, renegotiating terms, or offering additional value to enhance customer loyalty. How do different industries and business models influence the calculus of retaining or parting ways with unprofitable customers? In your opinion, when should unprofitable customers be dropped (if at all)? Provide personal examples, research and textbook integration to help support your arguments. In your opinion, when should…arrow_forwardCorrecting internal control weakness Each of the following situations has an internal control weakness. Jade Applications has decided that one way to cut costs in the upcoming year is to fire the external auditor. The business believes that the internal auditor should be able to efficiently monitor the company’s internal controls. In an effort to minimize the amount of paperwork, Ross Homes has decided that it will not keep copies of customer invoices related to sales revenue. Ross believes that this effort will minimize the amount of data storage the company will have to pay for. Elle Bee, a trusted employee for many years, has never taken a vacation. The owner believes that he’s lucky that she is so committed to her job. The Medicine Chest Company keeps a small petty cash fund to handle small cash transactions. Because no one wants to volunteer to be the custodian, the business manager has decided that all employees should have access to the petty cash. She figures that as long as…arrow_forward
- In the complex landscape of business decisions, the question of when to drop an unprofitable customer emerges as a strategic concern for many companies. In considering the decision of when to drop an unprofitable custome what factors should a company weigh to strike a balance between short-term financial losses and long-term strategic gains? Reflect on the ethical implications of discontinuing a customer relationship and how it may impact the company's reputation. Additionally, discuss alternative approaches to managing unprofitable customers, such as implementing price adjustments, renegotiating terms, or offering additional value to enhance customer loyalty. How do different industries and business models influence the calculus of retaining or parting ways with unprofitable customers? Chapter 7 of your textbook takes a deeper look at product and customer margins. In your opinion, when should unprofitable customers be dropped (if at all)? Provide personal examples, research and…arrow_forwardYour HR Manager approaches you regarding a worker whose performance reports have been deteriorating lately and seeks your opinion on whether to keep or fire the worker. To balance things out, the manager says that the business has invested a lot of time and money in educating this employee on company-specific procedures, and that it would be a shame to let that money go to waste. What response would you have?arrow_forward(1) What are some key differences between financial and managerial accounting? (b) Is it permissible to violate generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) when preparing reports used strictly by company management? If so, why? (c) Please discuss two of the five basic phases of the “management process” discussed in Chapter 18. (d) The top management of a fast-food hamburger chain is considering installing point-of-sale machines that will allow customers to pay for food with a debit or credit card. Previously, the restaurant has accepted only cash. What information could the management accounting department supply to assist management with this decision?arrow_forward
- UESTION 33 Consider the following five situations: (I) Relative performance evaluation is used for evaluating store managers. (II) Insurabce policy holders pay deductibles before being covered by the insurance (III) The warehouse manager is not held responsible for damages and stolen goods during a riot. (IV) Individual stores are allocated (charged) for the cost of advertising done by the headquarters. (V) In performance evaluation, the actual outcome is compared witht the flexible budget, not the original budget. Which of the above would be examples that go againt the controllability principle (concept)? A. I, II, and III B. I, II, and IV C. I and III D. II and IV E. III and Varrow_forwardThe CEO of the Baker Inc, wants to implement a new accounting system, to improve work flow through the company’s sales, cash receipts, accounts payable, and cash disbursement procedures. The CEO is, however, concerned about the potential disruption that the implementation will have on operations. In an announcement letter to Baker’s employees, the CEO stated that: “I have contracted Flybynight Consulting Group to do the needs analysis, system selection, and design work. The programming and implementation will be performed in-house using existing IT department staff. The development process will be unobtrusive to user departments because Flybynight knows what needs to be done. They will work independently, in the background, and will not disrupt departmental and internal audit work flow with time consuming interviews, surveys, and questionnaires. This promises to be an efficient process that will produce a system that will be appreciated by all users.” Required: Draft a memo from George…arrow_forwardRead the following scenarios and answer the questions that follow: i) A young graduate has just been employed as the Receivable Officer, responsible for billing of customers, maintaining customers’ accounts and preparing monthly control accounts. Management has found out that the officer has not been straightforward and honest in the discharge of his duties. He was found to be “cutting corners” and connives with the customers to understate their bills and accounts in order to enrich himself. Management has fired him sadly. ii) You met a friend in church recently and she was looking very flashy, showing clearly that she got a good job. Upon a short conversation, she indicated that she is blessed to be in charge of the payroll of the company. In fact, she told you exactly how much your four other mates working in that organisation are earning. She went further to inform you that the new car driven by Jojo, a popular mate back in school, was a loan of GHc100,000 he took from a bank and…arrow_forward
- Auditing: A Risk Based-Approach (MindTap Course L...AccountingISBN:9781337619455Author:Karla M Johnstone, Audrey A. Gramling, Larry E. RittenbergPublisher:Cengage LearningAccounting Information SystemsAccountingISBN:9781337619202Author:Hall, James A.Publisher:Cengage Learning,
- Business/Professional Ethics Directors/Executives...AccountingISBN:9781337485913Author:BROOKSPublisher:Cengage