Choice Table whether to invest in X or Y or do nothing.

Question

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Answer 1

Question

Chapter 8, Problem 3P

To determine

Choice Table whether to invest in X or Y or do nothing.

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer to Problem 3P

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Explanation of Solution

Given information:

Interest Rate is from 0% to 100%.

Year	A	B
0	($10,000)	($15,000)
1--5	3200	4500

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A
Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Conclusion:

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!

Students have asked these similar questions

1. After the reopening of borders with mainland China following the COVID-19 lockdown, residents living near the border now have the option to shop for food on either side. In Hong Kong, the cost of food is at its listed price, while across the border in mainland China, the price is only half that of Hong Kong's. A recent report indicates a decline in food sales in Hong Kong post-reopening. ** Diagrams need not be to scale; Focus on accurately representing the relevant concepts and relationships rather than the exact proportions. (a) Using a diagram, explain why Hong Kong's food sales might have dropped after the border reopening. Assume that consumers are indifferent between purchasing food in Hong Kong or mainland China, and therefore, their indifference curves have a slope of one like below. Additionally, consider that there are no transport costs and the daily food budget for consumers is identical whether they shop in Hong Kong or mainland China. I 3. 14 (b) In response to the…

2. Health Food Company is a well-known global brand that specializes in healthy and organic food products. One of their main products is organic chicken, which they source from small farmers in the area. Health Food Company is the sole buyer of organic chicken in the market. (a) In the context of the organic chicken industry, what type of market structure is Health Food Company operating in? (b) Using a diagram, explain how the identified market structure affects the input pricing and output decisions of Health Food Company. Specifically, include the relevant curves and any key points such as the profit-maximizing price and quantity. () (c) How can encouraging small chicken farmers to form bargaining associations help improve their trade terms? Explain how this works by drawing on the graph in answer (b) to illustrate your answer.

2. Suppose that a farmer has two ways to produce his crop. He can use a low-polluting technology with the marginal cost curve MCL or a high polluting technology with the marginal cost curve MCH. If the farmer uses the high-polluting technology, for each unit of quantity produced, one unit of pollution is also produced. Pollution causes pollution damages that are valued at $E per unit. The good produced can be sold in the market for $P per unit. P 1 MCH 0 Q₁ MCL Q2 E a. b. C. If there are no restrictions on the firm's choices, which technology will the farmer use and what quantity will he produce? Explain, referring to the area identified in the figure Given your response in part a, is it socially efficient for there to be no restriction on production? Explain, referring to the area identified in the figure If the government restricts production to Q1, what technology would the farmer choose? Would a socially efficient outcome be achieved? Explain, referring to the area identified in…

Answer 2

Question

Chapter 8, Problem 3P

To determine

Choice Table whether to invest in X or Y or do nothing.

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer to Problem 3P

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Explanation of Solution

Given information:

Interest Rate is from 0% to 100%.

Year	A	B
0	($10,000)	($15,000)
1--5	3200	4500

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A
Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Conclusion:

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!

Answer 3

Question

Chapter 8, Problem 3P

To determine

Choice Table whether to invest in X or Y or do nothing.

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer to Problem 3P

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Explanation of Solution

Given information:

Interest Rate is from 0% to 100%.

Year	A	B
0	($10,000)	($15,000)
1--5	3200	4500

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A
Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Conclusion:

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!

Answer 4

Question

Chapter 8, Problem 3P

To determine

Choice Table whether to invest in X or Y or do nothing.

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer to Problem 3P

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Explanation of Solution

Given information:

Interest Rate is from 0% to 100%.

Year	A	B
0	($10,000)	($15,000)
1--5	3200	4500

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A
Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Conclusion:

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Want to see more full solutions like this?

Subscribe now to access step-by-step solutions to millions of textbook problems written by subject matter experts!

Answer 5

Chapter 8, Problem 3P

To determine

Choice Table whether to invest in X or Y or do nothing.

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer to Problem 3P

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Explanation of Solution

Given information:

Interest Rate is from 0% to 100%.

Year	A	B
0	($10,000)	($15,000)
1--5	3200	4500

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A
Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Conclusion:

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Answer 6

Chapter 8, Problem 3P

To determine

Choice Table whether to invest in X or Y or do nothing.

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer to Problem 3P

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Explanation of Solution

Given information:

Interest Rate is from 0% to 100%.

Year	A	B
0	($10,000)	($15,000)
1--5	3200	4500

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A
Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Conclusion:

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Answer 7

Chapter 8, Problem 3P

To determine

Choice Table whether to invest in X or Y or do nothing.

Answer 8

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer to Problem 3P

At 0% investor will invest in Alternative B

From 1% to 49%, No investment will be done as net present value is negative

After 50% to 100%, investor will invest in Alternative A.

Answer 9

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer 10

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer 11

Explanation of Solution

Given information:

Interest Rate is from 0% to 100%.

Year	A	B
0	($10,000)	($15,000)
1--5	3200	4500

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A
Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A

Year	Cash flow A	Cash flow B
0	-10,000	-15,000
1	3,000	4,500
2	3,000	4,500
3	3,000	4,500
4	3,000	4,500
5	3,000	4,500


Interest Rates	NPV- A	NPV- B	Do Nothing	Decision
0%	5,000	6,500	-	B
1%	-24500	-36000	-	Do Nothing
2%	-24000	-35500	-	Do Nothing
3%	-23500	-35000	-	Do Nothing
4%	-23000	-34500	-	Do Nothing
5%	-22500	-34000	-	Do Nothing
6%	-22000	-33500	-	Do Nothing
7%	-21500	-33000	-	Do Nothing
8%	-21000	-32500	-	Do Nothing
9%	-20500	-32000	-	Do Nothing
10%	-20000	-31500	-	Do Nothing
11%	-19500	-31000	-	Do Nothing
12%	-19000	-30500	-	Do Nothing
13%	-18500	-30000	-	Do Nothing
14%	-18000	-29500	-	Do Nothing
15%	-17500	-29000	-	Do Nothing
16%	-17000	-28500	-	Do Nothing
17%	-16500	-28000	-	Do Nothing
18%	-16000	-27500	-	Do Nothing
19%	-15500	-27000	-	Do Nothing
20%	-15000	-26500	-	Do Nothing
21%	-14500	-26000	-	Do Nothing
22%	-14000	-25500	-	Do Nothing
23%	-13500	-25000	-	Do Nothing
24%	-13000	-24500	-	Do Nothing
25%	-12500	-24000	-	Do Nothing
26%	-12000	-23500	-	Do Nothing
27%	-11500	-23000	-	Do Nothing
28%	-11000	-22500	-	Do Nothing
29%	-10500	-22000	-	Do Nothing
30%	-10000	-21500	-	Do Nothing
31%	-9500	-21000	-	Do Nothing
32%	-9000	-20500	-	Do Nothing
33%	-8500	-20000	-	Do Nothing
34%	-8000	-19500	-	Do Nothing
35%	-7500	-19000	-	Do Nothing
36%	-7000	-18500	-	Do Nothing
37%	-6500	-18000	-	Do Nothing
38%	-6000	-17500	-	Do Nothing
39%	-5500	-17000	-	Do Nothing
40%	-5000	-16500	-	Do Nothing
41%	-4500	-16000	-	Do Nothing
42%	-4000	-15500	-	Do Nothing
43%	-3500	-15000	-	Do Nothing
44%	-3000	-14500	-	Do Nothing
45%	-2500	-14000	-	Do Nothing
46%	-2000	-13500	-	Do Nothing
47%	-1500	-13000	-	Do Nothing
48%	-1000	-12500	-	Do Nothing
49%	-500	-12000	-	Do Nothing
50%	0	-11500	-	A
51%	500	-11000	-	A
52%	1000	-10500	-	A
53%	1500	-10000	-	A
54%	2000	-9500	-	A
55%	2500	-9000	-	A
56%	3000	-8500	-	A
57%	3500	-8000	-	A
58%	4000	-7500	-	A
59%	4500	-7000	-	A
60%	5000	-6500	-	A
61%	5500	-6000	-	A
62%	6000	-5500	-	A
63%	6500	-5000	-	A
64%	7000	-4500	-	A
65%	7500	-4000	-	A
66%	8000	-3500	-	A
67%	8500	-3000	-	A
68%	9000	-2500	-	A
69%	9500	-2000	-	A
70%	10000	-1500	-	A
71%	10500	-1000	-	A
72%	11000	-500	-	A
73%	11500	0	-	A
74%	12000	500	-	A
75%	12500	1000	-	A
76%	13000	1500	-	A
77%	13500	2000	-	A
78%	14000	2500	-	A
79%	14500	3000	-	A
80%	15000	3500	-	A
81%	15500	4000	-	A
82%	16000	4500	-	A
83%	16500	5000	-	A
84%	17000	5500	-	A
85%	17500	6000	-	A
86%	18000	6500	-	A
87%	18500	7000	-	A
88%	19000	7500	-	A
89%	19500	8000	-	A
90%	20000	8500	-	A
91%	20500	9000	-	A
92%	21000	9500	-	A
93%	21500	10000	-	A
94%	22000	10500	-	A
95%	22500	11000	-	A
96%	23000	11500	-	A
97%	23500	12000	-	A
98%	24000	12500	-	A
99%	24500	13000	-	A
100%	25000	13500	-	A