(a)
The key screening strategies and the reason for them to be important than others.
(a)
Explanation of Solution
As per the table, option 1, 3 and 6 could be considered as dominant options. In option 1 it is true that there is an incremental cost. Nevertheless, its QALY value is positive. Hence it could be considered as dominant. Further, in option 3, a positive QALY has been derived with an incremental cost that is considerably low. In option 6, both the tests could be done. However, the incremental cost involved does not seem alarming. Its QALY value is also a positive figure.
Introduction:
When selecting between various treatment options, it is important to look into various measures that make them dominant. In this case, the cost of the treatment as well as the QALY value has been looked into. QALY or Quality Adjusted Life Year is a weighted average measure that takes into account both the qualitative and quantitative aspects of the burden of a disease. This is helpful in determining the level of medical intervention needed.
(b)
The incremental cost values, incremental QALY values and incremental cost effective ratios for the treatment options that seem to be economically rationale and state why they are so.
(b)
Explanation of Solution
As per the table, option 3 and 6 seems to be economically rationale. Option 3 has an incremental value that is considerably low, together with a positive QALY value. Option 6 too consists of a somewhat lower incremental cost with a positive QALY value. Hence both these options could be considered as economically rational.
Introduction:
In determining the economically rational treatment options out of a list, it is important to consider measures such as the incremental cost, incremental QALY and the incremental cost effectiveness ratio. An economically rational option would ideally have a lower incremental cost and a positive QALY value.
(c)
The best strategy to be recommended from a standpoint of public health.
(c)
Explanation of Solution
As per the table, option 6 could be considered the best strategy to be recommended from a public health standpoint. The option included both the tests Pap and HPV, with a reasonable incremental cost as well as a positive QALY value. Hence it could be recommended as the best strategy.
Introduction:
When recommending health strategies from the perspective of public health, it is important that they address to the needs of a wider population, at a lower cost. In this regard, out of the strategy options given, the one with a considerably low incremental cost together with a positive QALY value must be selected.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 4 Solutions
EBK HEALTH ECONOMICS AND POLICY
- answerarrow_forwardDiscuss the preferred deterrent method employed by the Zambian government to combat tax evasion, monetary fines. As noted in the reading the potential penalty for corporate tax evasion is a fine of 52.5% of the amount evaded plus interest assessed at 5% annually along with a possibility of jail time. In general, monetary fines as a deterrent are preferred to blacklisting of company directors, revoking business operation licenses, or calling for prison sentences. Do you agree with this preference? Should companies that are guilty of tax evasion face something more severe than a monetary fine? Something less severe? Should the fine and interest amount be set at a different rate? If so at why? Provide support and rationale for your responses.arrow_forwardNot use ai pleasearrow_forward
- For the statement below, argue in position for both in favor or opposed to the statement. Incompetent leaders can't be ethical leaders. Traditional leadership theories and moral standards are not adequate to help employees solve complex organizational issues.arrow_forwardpresentation on "Dandelion Insomnia." Poemarrow_forwardDon't used Ai solutionarrow_forward
- "Whether the regulator sells or gives away tradeable emission permits free of charge, the quantities of emissions produced by firms are the same." Assume that there are n identical profit-maximising firms where profit for each firm is given by π(e) with л'(e) > 0; π"(e) < 0 and e denotes emissions. Individual emissions summed over all firms gives E which generates environmental damages D(E). Show that the regulator achieves the optimal level of total pollution through a tradeable emission permit scheme, where the permits are distributed according to the following cases: Case (i) the firm purchases all permits; Case (ii) the firm receives all permits free; and Page 3 of 5 ES30031 Case (iii) the firm purchases a portion of its permits and receives the remainder free of charge.arrow_forwardcompare and/or contrast the two plays we've been reading, Antigone and A Doll's House.arrow_forwardPlease answer step by steparrow_forward
- Suppose there are two firms 1 and 2, whose abatement costs are given by c₁ (e₁) and C2 (е2), where e denotes emissions and subscripts denote the firm. We assume that c{(e) 0 for i = 1,2 and for any level of emission e we have c₁'(e) # c₂' (e). Furthermore, assume the two firms make different contributions towards pollution concentration in a nearby river captured by the transfer coefficients ε₁ and 2 such that for any level of emission e we have C₂'(e) # The regulator does not know the resulting C₁'(e) Τι environmental damages. Using an analytical approach explain carefully how the regulator may limit the concentration of pollution using (i) a Pigouvian tax scheme and (ii) uniform emissions standards. Discuss the cost-effectiveness of both approaches to control pollution.arrow_forwardBill’s father read that each year a car’s value declines by 10%. He also read that a new car’s value declines by 12% as it is driven off the dealer’s lot. Maintenance costs and the costs of “car problems” are only $200 per year during the 2-year warranty period. Then they jump to $750 per year, with an annual increase of $500 per year.Bill’s dad wants to keep his annual cost of car ownership low. The car he prefers cost $30,000 new, and he uses an interest rate of 8%. For this car, the new vehicle warranty is transferrable.(a) If he buys the car new, what is the minimum cost life? What is the minimum EUAC?(b) If he buys the car after it is 2 years old, what is the minimum cost life? What is the minimum EUAC?(c) If he buys the car after it is 4 years old, what is the minimum cost life? What is the minimum EUAC?(d) If he buys the car after it is 6 years old, what is the minimum cost life? What is the minimum EUAC?(e) What strategy do you recommend? Why? Please show each step and formula,…arrow_forwardO’Leary Engineering Corp. has been depreciating a $50,000 machine for the last 3 years. The asset was just sold for 60% of its first cost. What is the size of the recaptured depreciation or loss at disposal using the following depreciation methods?(a) Straight-line with N = 8 and S = 2000(b) Double declining balance with N = 8(c) 40% bonus depreciation with the balance using 7-year MACRS Please show every step and formula, don't use excel. The answer should be (a) $2000 loss, (b) $8000 deo recap, (c) $14257 dep recap, thank you.arrow_forward
