Given situation: Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law. Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding. To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

Question

Want to see the full answer?

Answer 1

Question

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Expert Solution & Answer

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Students have asked these similar questions

How can I fill the bullet points below to my strength? Strength: Received a scholarship to attend my University. Situation: Task: Action: Result:

How can I fill the bullet points below to my strength? Strength: Made the Dean's List for three consecutive years. Situation: Task: Action: Result:

How can I fill the bullet points below to my strength? Strength: Received University Grant: Situation: Task: Action: Result:

Answer 2

Question

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Expert Solution & Answer

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Answer 3

Question

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Expert Solution & Answer

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Answer 4

Question

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Expert Solution & Answer

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Answer 5

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Answer 6

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

Answer 7

Chapter 3, Problem 1Q

a)

Summary Introduction

Given situation:

Person G quit his job and vended his property for loss based on the decision of a newspaper columnist that State X will be flooded on Sept 1. As on the date, flooding didn’t came so he sued against the columnist in State X court for damages. Later on court dismissed the case on the grounds that a failure to state a cause of action under applicable State law.

Later he appeal, State X Supreme Court supported the lower court of law. After three months, lower court has ruled that a reader could sue a columnist for incorrectly predicting flooding.

To discuss: Whether State Y supreme court following the ruling of State X court as on the matter of stare decisis.

Answer 8

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

Answer 9

b)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

Answer 10

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

Answer 11

c)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

Answer 12

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Answer 13

d)

Summary Introduction

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Answer 14

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer 15

Expert Solution & Answer

Answer 16

Want to see the full answer?

Check out a sample textbook solution

See solution

Answer 17

Ch. 3 - Prob. 1CO Ch. 3 - Prob. 2CO Ch. 3 - Prob. 3CO Ch. 3 - Prob. 4CO Ch. 3 - Prob. 5CO Ch. 3 - Prob. 1Q Ch. 3 - Prob. 2Q Ch. 3 - Prob. 3Q Ch. 3 - Prob. 4Q Ch. 3 - Prob. 5Q

To discuss: Whether State Y Supreme court have followed the ruling of state X until State Y Supreme court issued ruling.

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme court overrules the ruling issued by State X Supreme court.

To discuss: Whether Country U Supreme Court will resolve the conflicts between State X Supreme Court and State Y Supreme Courts when they rule exactly in opposite way.

Want to see the full answer?

Chapter 3 Solutions