To think critically about: The union shop agreements as the violation of freedom of choice at workplace and examine if the agreements unfairly penalize workers that pay dues to the unions they elected.
Introduction:
The agreement as per which the non-members of the union can only be hired for a fixed period of 30days and the further employment depends upon the membership in the union is referred to as the union shop agreement.
Explanation of Solution
The freedom of choice seems to be violated by the union shop agreements as the workers if hired are obliged to become the member of the union. In case, the workers do not wish to become a member, the same fees or dues are applicable to all. As, the employment opportunity are a few, this becomes a case of sheer blackmail to pay the unwanted dues. The workers can neglect the association with such unions to get saved from an agreement situation.
The dues that are paid by the workers as per the union shop agreement if known as to where is it spend or its usage is defined by the union cannot be defined as unfair. If the option to join the union is in the hand of worker and the expenditure of fairs are fairly discussed, the workers will not be addressed as unfairly penalized.
Therefore, it can be concluded that the freedom of the workers is violated in a union shop agreement and the workers are not unfairly penalized if the dues are paid intentionally.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 12 Solutions
EBK UNDERSTANDING BUSINESS
- do worker's unions exist for workers in the financial services sector and what are they doing to combat the level of stress in the sector? if they do exist why are their methods and policies to protect the members of their union from the causes of the stress at work not effective?arrow_forwardAs an expert in Industrial Relations, your friend Mary has come to you for advice. She recently received two job offers. One offer is based on the terms of a contract of service, and the other job offer is based on a contract for service. Mary pointed out that while each job offer had really great salaries, she wants to ensure that she will have job security and be protected from unfair labour practices. With your knowledge of Jamaican Labour Laws, what advice would you give to Mary to help her make her decision. Your advice must reflect current realities and include reference to relevant legislation and/or cases to support your positionarrow_forwardWork Place rights you have to look at your place of work, find out what laws govern you. What rights you have as an employee? Is your employer giving you all that is owed to you; if not, what are the remedies available to you? For individuals who are not working currently, use this opportunity to search about the country you are living in. What rights you have as a citizen? I live in Edmonton AB Canada and I am currently unemployed.arrow_forward
- Do unions make it difficult for companies to attain a competitive advantage? Explainarrow_forwardCritically assess whether employment law maintains a fair balance between the rights of workers and employers in the UK. write up to 500 words.arrow_forward4 ways trade unions influence the wage rates paid to employees.arrow_forward
- Why do you think that the trade/labour unions are successful in achieving their goals?arrow_forwardArguments that labor unions create market conflict that result in less-than-optimal results reflect: Duty ethical beliefs Fairness ethical beliefs Libertarian ethical beliefs Utilitarian ethical beliefsarrow_forwardHow to explain the role of unions in the labor market?arrow_forward