Case Summary: The people D, S, B and a teenage boy were casted away in the sea on a lifeboat due to a storm. The only means of sustenance they had was two pounds of turnip which eventually got finished. So, D proposed to sacrifice one of the four persons on the boat for further sustenance, to which S agreed but B disagreed. The boy was ignored. The following day, D killed the boy who had become quite weak, and all three fed on him for survival until they were saved four days later by an ongoing boat. After being rescued, they were put to trial for the murder of the boy in England.
To Explain: The possibility of three survivors to be subjected to penalties as per English criminal law given their unique circumstances.
Trending nowThis is a popular solution!
Chapter 1 Solutions
Bundle: The Legal Environment Of Business: Text And Cases, 10th + Mindtap Business Law, 1 Term (6 Months) Printed Access Card
- Pablo, a resident of New Mexico, while driving through Arizona, was struck by an SUV driven by Derek, a resident of California. Derek was speeding when the accident happened, and Pablo suffered severe injuries that ruined a potential acting career. Pablo's damages are estimated at $200,000. What type of case is this?arrow_forwardexplain How does the principle of comparative fault apply in tort law?arrow_forwardExplain the concept of vicarious liability in business law and provide an example of a situation where an employer could be held responsible for the actions of their employee.arrow_forward
- Negligence CaseWest v. East Tennessee Pioneer Oil Co.In Knox County Tennessee, a convenience store clerk refused to sell Brian Taver beer because he wasalready intoxicated. However, the clerk eventually activated the gas pump and, with the assistance of twoadditional store employees, who helped Taver operate the pump, Taver was able to purchase a small amount ofgas.Taver then drove off, going the wrong way on the highway and without his headlights on. Shortlyafterward, he crashed into an oncoming car, injuring Gary West and Michelle Richardson.West suffered several fractures of his legs, a head injury, and a broken elbow. West works in theconstruction industry. West, who has basic health insurance provided by his employer, was left with over$200,000 in personal debt as a consequence of the accident. Richardson suffered a severe closed-head injury.Richardson is an administrative assistant for the state of Tennessee. Her employer provided betterhealth insurance coverage, so she did not…arrow_forwardJason Lasseigne, a Little League baseball player, was seriously injured at a practice session when he was struck on the head by a poorly thrown baseball from a team member, Todd Landry. The league was organized by American Legion Post 38. Claude Cassel and Billy Johnson were the volunteer coaches of the practice session. The Lasseignes brought suit on behalf of Jason against Post 38, claiming that the coaching was negligent and that Post 38 was vicari- ously liable for the harm caused by such negligence. Post 38 contended that it had no right to control the work of the volunteer coaches or the manner in which practices were conducted and as a result should not be held vicariously liable for the actions of the coaches. Decide. Please answer is the IRAC format Issue: Call of the QuestionRule: Rule of Law to be applied to properly answer the questionAnalysis:…arrow_forward5-3 PROXIMATE CAUSE. Galen Stoller was killed at a railroad crossing when a train hit his car. The crossing was marked with a stop sign and a railroad-crossing symbol. The sign was not obstructed by vegetation, but there were no flashing lights. Galen’s parents filed a suit against Burlington Northern & Santa Fe Railroad Corp. The plaintiffs accused the defendant of negligence in the design and maintenance of the crossing. The defendant argued that Galen had not stopped at the stop sign. Was the railroad negligent? What was the proximate cause of the accident? Discuss. [Henderson v. National Railroad Passenger Corp., __ F.3d __ (10th Cir. 2011)] (See Negligence.)arrow_forward
- Discuss the ADA, along with the notions of reasonable accommodation and undue hardship in relation to the idea of an ethical minimum.arrow_forwardAnswer the questions below related to the negligence case. Thank you.arrow_forwardClarice, a young woman with a mental disability, brought a malpractice suit against a doctor at the Medical Center. As a result, the Medical Center refused to treat her on a nonemergency basis. Clarice then went to another local clinic, which was later acquired by the Medical Center. Because the new clinic also refused to treat her, Clarice had to seek medical treatment in another town 40 miles away. Has the Medical Center violated the antitrust laws? Was it ethical to deny treatment to a patient?arrow_forward
- 2arrow_forwardBrendan Bosse and Michael Griffin were part of a group of four teenagers eating a meal at a Chili’s restaurant in Dedham, Massachusetts. Chili’s is owned by Brinker Restaurant Corporation (collectively “Chili’s”). The cost of the meal was $56. The teenagers decided not to pay. They went out of the building, got in their car, and drove away, heading northward up Route 1. A patron of the restaurant saw the teenagers leave without payment. He followed them in his white sport-utility vehicle (SUV). The teenagers saw him following them. A high-speed chase ensued through Dedham side streets. The patron used his cell phone to call the Chili’s manager. The manager called 911 and reported the incident and the location of the car chase. The teenagers’ car collided with a cement wall, and Bosse and Griffin were seriously injured. The Chili’s patron drove past the crash scene and was never identified. Bosse and Griffin sued Chili’s for compensatory damages for their injuries. The plaintiffs argued…arrow_forwardAfter meeting with a supervisee, the supervisor believes that one of the supervisee’s clients is in danger of harming herself. The supervisee disagrees, he believes that the client is not at risk and decides not to take any action, despite requests by the supervisor. The supervisor decides to contact the client herself and makes arrangements to have her committed to a psychiatric unit. Has the supervisee acted ethically? Professionally? Has the supervisor acted ethically? Professionally?arrow_forward
- BUSN 11 Introduction to Business Student EditionBusinessISBN:9781337407137Author:KellyPublisher:Cengage LearningEssentials of Business Communication (MindTap Cou...BusinessISBN:9781337386494Author:Mary Ellen Guffey, Dana LoewyPublisher:Cengage LearningAccounting Information Systems (14th Edition)BusinessISBN:9780134474021Author:Marshall B. Romney, Paul J. SteinbartPublisher:PEARSON
- International Business: Competing in the Global M...BusinessISBN:9781259929441Author:Charles W. L. Hill Dr, G. Tomas M. HultPublisher:McGraw-Hill Education