The Roadrunner Industries case:- You are an executive for Roadrunner Industries. Suppose that the company has the revenueto reward all employees with a winter holiday bonus. For simplicity, suppose that all theemployees are of the same rank, and that all have worked equally as hard and been equallyas productive — all in all, no one has performed better or worse than another. However,suppose that your boss's nephew, A, is one of the employees, and you suspect that if A'sshown better treatment than the others (for example, by giving A a bigger bonus than theothers), it will increase your value in your boss's eyes. This would be good for you, becauseit increases the likelihood that you would be the one to receive the next big promotion.- How should you distribute the bonuses?- Intuitively, even though it might personally benefit you to give a bigger bonus to A, youshould distribute the bonuses evenly among the group. This is the ethically right choice.- What explains this? Question 1. Which is the correct analysis of the Roadrunner Industries case: utilitarianism, Kantian ethics, virtue ethics, or the non-ethical analysis? Explain.
The Roadrunner Industries case:
- You are an executive for Roadrunner Industries. Suppose that the company has the revenue
to reward all employees with a winter holiday bonus. For simplicity, suppose that all the
employees are of the same rank, and that all have worked equally as hard and been equally
as productive — all in all, no one has performed better or worse than another. However,
suppose that your boss's nephew, A, is one of the employees, and you suspect that if A's
shown better treatment than the others (for example, by giving A a bigger bonus than the
others), it will increase your value in your boss's eyes. This would be good for you, because
it increases the likelihood that you would be the one to receive the next big promotion.
- How should you distribute the bonuses?
- Intuitively, even though it might personally benefit you to give a bigger bonus to A, you
should distribute the bonuses evenly among the group. This is the ethically right choice.
- What explains this?
Question 1. Which is the correct analysis of the Roadrunner Industries case: utilitarianism, Kantian ethics, virtue ethics, or the non-ethical analysis? Explain.
Step by step
Solved in 2 steps
