Please help me with the conclusion, In a paragraph of 150 words state the "best" option(s), and explain how a true Kantian would come to this conclusion. Describe the results of applying Universality and Respect-for-Persons

Understanding Business
12th Edition
ISBN:9781259929434
Author:William Nickels
Publisher:William Nickels
Chapter1: Taking Risks And Making Profits Within The Dynamic Business Environment
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1CE
icon
Related questions
Question
Please help me with the conclusion, In a paragraph of 150 words state the "best" option(s), and explain how a true Kantian would come to this conclusion. Describe the results of applying Universality and Respect-for-Persons.
The main ethical issue:
Mario is disregarding the new policy against giving free samples to customers, which was
implemented by grocery Store owners:
What should Anthony to do Mario's action?
Options:
1. Anthony could report Mario's action to his supervisor or Peloni family.
2. Anthony could try to convince Mario to stop giving free samples.
3. Anthony could ignore Mario action and not report them.
4. Anthony could talk to Peloni family about the policy and the potential benefits of offering
free samples.
Apply Categorical Imperative/Universality:
1. Anthony could report Mario's action to his supervisor or Peloni family. Would I want
all people, consistently and universally, to report others who break rules or
policies? Yes. Reporting rule-breakers promotes fairness and equality for all and
ensures that everyone is held accountable for their actions.
X could report Mario's action to his supervisor or Pelopi,family.
-
Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to report the actions of
others that violate established policies or rules? Yes.
Rationale: Reporting violations of policies or rules is necessary to ensure fairness
and maintain order. If everyone disregarded rules and policies, chaos would
ensue.
2. Anthony could try to convince Mario to stop giving free samples. Would I want all
people, consistently and universally, to try to persuade rule-breakers to comply with
policies? Yes. Persuasion is a peaceful and non-coercive way to promote adherence to
rules and can help maintain order and fairness.
X could try to convince Mario to stop giving free samples.
- Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to try to persuade others to
comply with established policies or rules? Yes.
Rationale: Persuasion is a respectful way to encourage compliance without
resorting to punitive measures. It also promotes dialogue and understanding.
3. Anthony could ignore Mario's actions and not report them. Would I want all people,
consistently and universally, to turn a blind eye to rule-breaking? No. Ignoring rule-
breaking can create a culture of impunity and undermine the effectiveness of policies
and can be unfair to those who do follow the rules.
X could ignore Mario's actions and not report them.
Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to ignore violations of
established policies or rules? No.
Rationale: Ignoring violations of policies or rules undermines the authority and
legitimacy of those policies or rules. It also creates an unfair advantage for those
who violate them.
4. Anthony could talk to the Peloni, family about the policy and the potential benefits of
offering free samples. Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to
advocate for changes to policies that they disagree with? Yes. Advocacy can be an
effective way to promote changes that can benefit individuals and communities if it is
done peacefully and respectfully.
X could talk to the Peloni family about the policy and the potential benefits of
offering free samples.
Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to engage in constructive
dialogue about policies or rules? Yes.
Rationale: Engaging in dialogue promotes understanding and cooperation and can
lead to positive changes.
Applying Respect:
None of the options listed involve using someone for personal gain, so none of them
involve exploitation.
Transcribed Image Text:The main ethical issue: Mario is disregarding the new policy against giving free samples to customers, which was implemented by grocery Store owners: What should Anthony to do Mario's action? Options: 1. Anthony could report Mario's action to his supervisor or Peloni family. 2. Anthony could try to convince Mario to stop giving free samples. 3. Anthony could ignore Mario action and not report them. 4. Anthony could talk to Peloni family about the policy and the potential benefits of offering free samples. Apply Categorical Imperative/Universality: 1. Anthony could report Mario's action to his supervisor or Peloni family. Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to report others who break rules or policies? Yes. Reporting rule-breakers promotes fairness and equality for all and ensures that everyone is held accountable for their actions. X could report Mario's action to his supervisor or Pelopi,family. - Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to report the actions of others that violate established policies or rules? Yes. Rationale: Reporting violations of policies or rules is necessary to ensure fairness and maintain order. If everyone disregarded rules and policies, chaos would ensue. 2. Anthony could try to convince Mario to stop giving free samples. Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to try to persuade rule-breakers to comply with policies? Yes. Persuasion is a peaceful and non-coercive way to promote adherence to rules and can help maintain order and fairness. X could try to convince Mario to stop giving free samples. - Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to try to persuade others to comply with established policies or rules? Yes. Rationale: Persuasion is a respectful way to encourage compliance without resorting to punitive measures. It also promotes dialogue and understanding. 3. Anthony could ignore Mario's actions and not report them. Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to turn a blind eye to rule-breaking? No. Ignoring rule- breaking can create a culture of impunity and undermine the effectiveness of policies and can be unfair to those who do follow the rules. X could ignore Mario's actions and not report them. Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to ignore violations of established policies or rules? No. Rationale: Ignoring violations of policies or rules undermines the authority and legitimacy of those policies or rules. It also creates an unfair advantage for those who violate them. 4. Anthony could talk to the Peloni, family about the policy and the potential benefits of offering free samples. Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to advocate for changes to policies that they disagree with? Yes. Advocacy can be an effective way to promote changes that can benefit individuals and communities if it is done peacefully and respectfully. X could talk to the Peloni family about the policy and the potential benefits of offering free samples. Would I want all people, consistently and universally, to engage in constructive dialogue about policies or rules? Yes. Rationale: Engaging in dialogue promotes understanding and cooperation and can lead to positive changes. Applying Respect: None of the options listed involve using someone for personal gain, so none of them involve exploitation.
Conclusion - If
were a Kantian she could
Reminder - the option or combination of options you choose must pass both tests.
Transcribed Image Text:Conclusion - If were a Kantian she could Reminder - the option or combination of options you choose must pass both tests.
Expert Solution
Step 1

Meaning:-

Based on the application of the categorial imperative/universality and respect-for-persons, the best option for Anthony would be try to convince Mario to stop giving free samples.

This option respect Mario as a person and encourages peacefully adherence to rules.

It also aligns with the principle of universality , as persuading rule-breakers to comply with policies promotes order and fairness which are universal values. 

trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 3 steps

Blurred answer
Recommended textbooks for you
Understanding Business
Understanding Business
Management
ISBN:
9781259929434
Author:
William Nickels
Publisher:
McGraw-Hill Education
Management (14th Edition)
Management (14th Edition)
Management
ISBN:
9780134527604
Author:
Stephen P. Robbins, Mary A. Coulter
Publisher:
PEARSON
Spreadsheet Modeling & Decision Analysis: A Pract…
Spreadsheet Modeling & Decision Analysis: A Pract…
Management
ISBN:
9781305947412
Author:
Cliff Ragsdale
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Management Information Systems: Managing The Digi…
Management Information Systems: Managing The Digi…
Management
ISBN:
9780135191798
Author:
Kenneth C. Laudon, Jane P. Laudon
Publisher:
PEARSON
Business Essentials (12th Edition) (What's New in…
Business Essentials (12th Edition) (What's New in…
Management
ISBN:
9780134728391
Author:
Ronald J. Ebert, Ricky W. Griffin
Publisher:
PEARSON
Fundamentals of Management (10th Edition)
Fundamentals of Management (10th Edition)
Management
ISBN:
9780134237473
Author:
Stephen P. Robbins, Mary A. Coulter, David A. De Cenzo
Publisher:
PEARSON