MMDB 2024 Innovation & Entr... Tyme Bank. Digital Dis... X + Create All tools Edit Convert Sign e ΑΙ BOO 1,534 Sign in Find text or tools Q TymeBank: Digital Disruption in South Africa's Banking Sector They approached Deloitte Consulting South Africa with the idea of building a new, truly inclusive bank, one that could be adapted for other emerging markets. In September 2011, Jonker joined Deloitte Consulting as a partner and Van der Walt as an independent consultant. They built up a team of financial technology specialists (including Keraan) and began work on a consulting project for mobile phone operator MTN to relaunch its Mobile Money product – a money transfer service – in South Africa. The origins of TymeBank were laid in this Deloitte Consulting project. ¹4 Shortly before the launch in June 2012, the discovery that Deloitte was the auditor of the Bank of Athens' parent company in Greece, highlighted a potential conflict of interest that threatened to derail the project. When MTN declined the offer to bring the project team of 17 specialists in-house, the team negotiated a full project spin-off with Deloitte Consulting and MTN. Along with the team members, all intellectual property was transferred to a new entity, which became Tyme Capital - Tyme being the acronym of Take Your Money Everywhere. MTN became a client of Tyme Capital. Jonker and Van der Walt, together with a number of the other founding team members, were still involved with TymeBank in 2019.15 The success of Mobile Money relied on partnerships with the food retailer Pick n Pay to allow cash deposits and withdrawals at Pick n Pay and Boxer's tills, and the South African Bank of Athens for the bank licence and other regulatory requirements. When Mobile Money relaunched in 2012, it allowed MTN customers to send, receive, deposit and withdraw money from Pick n Pay and Boxer stores, as well as make payments, and purchase pre-paid electricity and airtime. Customers were also able to swipe their Mobile Money cards at any point of sale card device and to withdraw cash from any ATM throughout the country. MTN's initiative was very successful: it opened more than one million accounts, and processed more than R1 billion in transactions in the first nine months of operations. Two years later, almost two million customers had used Mobile Money. 17 16 18 19 During 2014, the international financial services division of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia Limited (CBA), became interested in Tyme Capital because its banking technology was tailored to suit emerging markets, and CBA was interested in expanding its operations in Africa and Asia. In January 2015, CBA acquired 100% of Tyme Capital for a reported AU$40 million (R365 million), taking over its 80 employees and forming the Commonwealth Bank South Africa (CBSA).2 20 Keraan recalled: "We've always had the ambition to become a full-service bank, because we felt that only by being a proper deposit-taking and lending institution, could we make an impact on the financial empowerment of individuals and small businesses in South Africa.”21 CBSA believed that the time was right for a proper digital bank in South Africa, and in October 2015, CBA applied to the SARB for a bank operation licence for CBSA.22 This licence was only awarded in May 2017 and in the interim, in September 2016, MTN decided to terminate its contract with Tyme Capital, citing "lack of commercial viability” as the reason. At the time, Tyme Capital provided services to about 140 000 customers of MTN's Mobile Money. 24 However, Pick n Pay remained a client of Tyme Capital and Tyme Capital continued operating Money Transfer - attracting almost 210 000 new Money Transfer clients by October 2017. After receiving its licence, CBSA started trading as TymeDigital by CBSA (TymeDigital).26 The new bank aimed to be fully operational by March 2018.27 Ownership Changes 23 In early 2018, the investment holding company African Rainbow Capital (ARC) acquired a 10% share in TymeDigital.28 A series of events led CBA to change its strategy and focus on its operations in Australia and New Zealand. Thus, CBA decided to sell TymeDigital and ARC, in November 2019, 3 25 < > C 1:1 0 JUN 2 14 Between 2017 and 2018, CBA came under scrutiny for deficiencies in its anti-money laundering counter-terrorism financing (AML/CTF) protocols. In response, CBA changed its board of directors and its management team, and with it, its strategy [Source: BusinessTech (2018) "Australia's Commonwealth Bank reviewing TymeDigital ownershin in SA· 2 C 1:1 Q BOO 1,534 JUN 2 14 2

Understanding Business
12th Edition
ISBN:9781259929434
Author:William Nickels
Publisher:William Nickels
Chapter1: Taking Risks And Making Profits Within The Dynamic Business Environment
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1CE
icon
Related questions
Question

An entrepreneurial opportunity has three distinct characteristics related to value, novelty and desirability. Examine these characteristics in the entrepreneurial opportunity(ies) captured in the "Tyme Bank: digital disruption in SA’s banking sector" by Urban, B. and Townsend, S. A. (2021) in the Emerald Emerging Markets Case Studies, 11 (2) 2021

MMDB 2024 Innovation & Entr...
Tyme Bank. Digital Dis... X + Create
All tools
Edit
Convert
Sign
e
ΑΙ
BOO
1,534
Sign in
Find text or tools Q
TymeBank: Digital Disruption in South Africa's Banking Sector
They approached Deloitte Consulting South Africa with the idea of building a new, truly inclusive
bank, one that could be adapted for other emerging markets. In September 2011, Jonker joined
Deloitte Consulting as a partner and Van der Walt as an independent consultant. They built up a team
of financial technology specialists (including Keraan) and began work on a consulting project for
mobile phone operator MTN to relaunch its Mobile Money product – a money transfer service – in
South Africa. The origins of TymeBank were laid in this Deloitte Consulting project. ¹4
Shortly before the launch in June 2012, the discovery that Deloitte was the auditor of the Bank of
Athens'
parent company in Greece, highlighted a potential conflict of interest that threatened to derail
the project. When MTN declined the offer to bring the project team of 17 specialists in-house, the
team negotiated a full project spin-off with Deloitte Consulting and MTN. Along with the team
members, all intellectual property was transferred to a new entity, which became Tyme Capital -
Tyme being the acronym of Take Your Money Everywhere. MTN became a client of Tyme Capital.
Jonker and Van der Walt, together with a number of the other founding team members, were still
involved with TymeBank in 2019.15
The success of Mobile Money relied on partnerships with the food retailer Pick n Pay to allow cash
deposits and withdrawals at Pick n Pay and Boxer's tills, and the South African Bank of Athens for
the bank licence and other regulatory requirements. When Mobile Money relaunched in 2012, it
allowed MTN customers to send, receive, deposit and withdraw money from Pick n Pay and Boxer
stores, as well as make payments, and purchase pre-paid electricity and airtime. Customers were also
able to swipe their Mobile Money cards at any point of sale card device and to withdraw cash from
any ATM throughout the country. MTN's initiative was very successful: it opened more than one
million accounts, and processed more than R1 billion in transactions in the first nine months of
operations. Two years later, almost two million customers had used Mobile Money.
17
16
18
19
During 2014, the international financial services division of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia
Limited (CBA), became interested in Tyme Capital because its banking technology was tailored to
suit emerging markets, and CBA was interested in expanding its operations in Africa and Asia. In
January 2015, CBA acquired 100% of Tyme Capital for a reported AU$40 million (R365 million),
taking over its 80 employees and forming the Commonwealth Bank South Africa (CBSA).2
20
Keraan recalled: "We've always had the ambition to become a full-service bank, because we felt that
only by being a proper deposit-taking and lending institution, could we make an impact on the
financial empowerment of individuals and small businesses in South Africa.”21 CBSA believed that
the time was right for a proper digital bank in South Africa, and in October 2015, CBA applied to the
SARB for a bank operation licence for CBSA.22 This licence was only awarded in May 2017 and in
the interim, in September 2016, MTN decided to terminate its contract with Tyme Capital, citing
"lack of commercial viability” as the reason. At the time, Tyme Capital provided services to about
140 000 customers of MTN's Mobile Money. 24 However, Pick n Pay remained a client of Tyme
Capital and Tyme Capital continued operating Money Transfer - attracting almost 210 000 new
Money Transfer clients by October 2017. After receiving its licence, CBSA started trading as
TymeDigital by CBSA (TymeDigital).26 The new bank aimed to be fully operational by March
2018.27
Ownership Changes
23
In early 2018, the investment holding company African Rainbow Capital (ARC) acquired a 10% share
in TymeDigital.28 A series of events led CBA to change its strategy and focus on its operations in
Australia and New Zealand. Thus, CBA decided to sell TymeDigital and ARC, in November 2019,
3
25
< >
C
1:1
0
JUN 2
14
Between 2017 and 2018, CBA came under scrutiny for deficiencies in its anti-money laundering counter-terrorism
financing (AML/CTF) protocols. In response, CBA changed its board of directors and its management team, and with it, its
strategy [Source: BusinessTech (2018) "Australia's Commonwealth Bank reviewing TymeDigital ownershin in SA·
2
<tv
A
X
W
Д
O
T
NEW
ם
Q
Transcribed Image Text:MMDB 2024 Innovation & Entr... Tyme Bank. Digital Dis... X + Create All tools Edit Convert Sign e ΑΙ BOO 1,534 Sign in Find text or tools Q TymeBank: Digital Disruption in South Africa's Banking Sector They approached Deloitte Consulting South Africa with the idea of building a new, truly inclusive bank, one that could be adapted for other emerging markets. In September 2011, Jonker joined Deloitte Consulting as a partner and Van der Walt as an independent consultant. They built up a team of financial technology specialists (including Keraan) and began work on a consulting project for mobile phone operator MTN to relaunch its Mobile Money product – a money transfer service – in South Africa. The origins of TymeBank were laid in this Deloitte Consulting project. ¹4 Shortly before the launch in June 2012, the discovery that Deloitte was the auditor of the Bank of Athens' parent company in Greece, highlighted a potential conflict of interest that threatened to derail the project. When MTN declined the offer to bring the project team of 17 specialists in-house, the team negotiated a full project spin-off with Deloitte Consulting and MTN. Along with the team members, all intellectual property was transferred to a new entity, which became Tyme Capital - Tyme being the acronym of Take Your Money Everywhere. MTN became a client of Tyme Capital. Jonker and Van der Walt, together with a number of the other founding team members, were still involved with TymeBank in 2019.15 The success of Mobile Money relied on partnerships with the food retailer Pick n Pay to allow cash deposits and withdrawals at Pick n Pay and Boxer's tills, and the South African Bank of Athens for the bank licence and other regulatory requirements. When Mobile Money relaunched in 2012, it allowed MTN customers to send, receive, deposit and withdraw money from Pick n Pay and Boxer stores, as well as make payments, and purchase pre-paid electricity and airtime. Customers were also able to swipe their Mobile Money cards at any point of sale card device and to withdraw cash from any ATM throughout the country. MTN's initiative was very successful: it opened more than one million accounts, and processed more than R1 billion in transactions in the first nine months of operations. Two years later, almost two million customers had used Mobile Money. 17 16 18 19 During 2014, the international financial services division of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia Limited (CBA), became interested in Tyme Capital because its banking technology was tailored to suit emerging markets, and CBA was interested in expanding its operations in Africa and Asia. In January 2015, CBA acquired 100% of Tyme Capital for a reported AU$40 million (R365 million), taking over its 80 employees and forming the Commonwealth Bank South Africa (CBSA).2 20 Keraan recalled: "We've always had the ambition to become a full-service bank, because we felt that only by being a proper deposit-taking and lending institution, could we make an impact on the financial empowerment of individuals and small businesses in South Africa.”21 CBSA believed that the time was right for a proper digital bank in South Africa, and in October 2015, CBA applied to the SARB for a bank operation licence for CBSA.22 This licence was only awarded in May 2017 and in the interim, in September 2016, MTN decided to terminate its contract with Tyme Capital, citing "lack of commercial viability” as the reason. At the time, Tyme Capital provided services to about 140 000 customers of MTN's Mobile Money. 24 However, Pick n Pay remained a client of Tyme Capital and Tyme Capital continued operating Money Transfer - attracting almost 210 000 new Money Transfer clients by October 2017. After receiving its licence, CBSA started trading as TymeDigital by CBSA (TymeDigital).26 The new bank aimed to be fully operational by March 2018.27 Ownership Changes 23 In early 2018, the investment holding company African Rainbow Capital (ARC) acquired a 10% share in TymeDigital.28 A series of events led CBA to change its strategy and focus on its operations in Australia and New Zealand. Thus, CBA decided to sell TymeDigital and ARC, in November 2019, 3 25 < > C 1:1 0 JUN 2 14 Between 2017 and 2018, CBA came under scrutiny for deficiencies in its anti-money laundering counter-terrorism financing (AML/CTF) protocols. In response, CBA changed its board of directors and its management team, and with it, its strategy [Source: BusinessTech (2018) "Australia's Commonwealth Bank reviewing TymeDigital ownershin in SA· 2 <tv A X W Д O T NEW ם Q
MMDB 2024 Innovation & Entr...
Tyme Bank. Digital Dis...
+ Create
All tools
Edit
Convert
Sign
TymeBank: Digital Disruption in South Africa's Banking Sector
Find text or tools Q |
Sign in
e.
ΑΙ
At the beginning of 2001, Internet service provider MWeb, had partnered with BoE Bank (later
bought out by Nedbank) to launch icanonline as a purely online bank. It grew quickly to 20 000
customers, but in 2005, Nedbank closed the business because the bank “already had an online offering
and the size of the bank did not warrant a separate strategy".
7
WIZZIT was the only one of the branchless banking entities launched in the early 2000s still
operating in 2019. Launched in 2004, it had no physical points of presence and used individual
salespeople to market its products. It used mobile banking technology to allow transactional banking
on a cell phone and it also offered a debit card. By 2019, WIZZIT International not only ran WIZZIT
Bank in South Africa, it had also expanded into providing mobile-banking solutions to banks in 13
countries.
8
In the mobile money transfer arena, mobile communications company Vodacom had not been
successful with the 2010 launch of M-Pesa - a mobile money transfer product that had achieved huge
success in Kenya. The product failed dismally in South Africa and Vodacom closed it down in mid-
2016. Technology expert and owner of World Wide Worx Arthur Goldstuck, attributed the low
demand for M-Pesa in South Africa to better financial inclusion - a greater proportion of the
population already had bank accounts and therefore the need for a bankless mobile money transfer
service was not as great.
Acceptance of the Cloud
10
TymeGlobal's Hong Kong-based head of strategy, Aaron Foo, believed that a combination of factors
had come into play to give TymeBank a greater chance of success when it launched. He pointed out
that after the dot-com crash in 2000, adoption of digital technologies had gained momentum first in
less regulated industries, such as retail for e-commerce and social media, before moving into
industries where regulatory compliance on issues such as data, cyber security and system resilience
were critical. "It has taken time for technology development, and in particular, cloud technologies, to
arrive at a stage where regulators of systemic institutions are comfortable with them,” clarified Foo."
In this context, TymeBank was the first bank in South Africa to receive approval from the South
African Reserve Bank (SARB) to use the cloud for its core banking technology stack. This, according
to Foo, was very unusual for emerging markets because using the cloud was still a novelty in
regulated industries - even in developed markets. Receiving this approval was an important enabler of
TymeBank's economic model. The traditional banking industry had been capital-intensive, requiring
serious investment in physical branches to reach and service the customer base. “Digital has basically
provided that window of opportunity when new players can come into the market and catch-up with
the incumbents, but with a lower fixed asset investment," said Foo.
11
TymeBank's manager of strategy and partnerships, Neo Phukubje, added another reason for South
Africa being ready for full digital banking: “Looking at environments that have high mobile
adoptions, which is the case in most African countries, and where a very large component of people
are either unbanked or underserved, it almost lends itself to an opportunity for a digital bank. It is
almost a no brainer from an opportunity point of view. So, there are also other market forces that lend
itself for a company to come together, and say it is very timely to be doing this kind of work in this
kind of space."
,,12
The Origins of TymeBank
In April 2011, Coenraad Jonker and Tjaart van der Walt, who had been friends for 22 years, met to
discuss what they saw as an increasingly pressing need for inclusive banking, in South Africa as well
as other emerging markets. Van der Walt had recently sold his artificial intelligence software business
to the global digital industrial company General Electric and Jonker had been working at Standard
Bank as the director of inclusive banking. 13
=
3 88
2
25
< >
C
1:1
Q
BOO
1,534
JUN 2
14
2
<tv
A
X
W
Д
O
T
NEW
ם
Transcribed Image Text:MMDB 2024 Innovation & Entr... Tyme Bank. Digital Dis... + Create All tools Edit Convert Sign TymeBank: Digital Disruption in South Africa's Banking Sector Find text or tools Q | Sign in e. ΑΙ At the beginning of 2001, Internet service provider MWeb, had partnered with BoE Bank (later bought out by Nedbank) to launch icanonline as a purely online bank. It grew quickly to 20 000 customers, but in 2005, Nedbank closed the business because the bank “already had an online offering and the size of the bank did not warrant a separate strategy". 7 WIZZIT was the only one of the branchless banking entities launched in the early 2000s still operating in 2019. Launched in 2004, it had no physical points of presence and used individual salespeople to market its products. It used mobile banking technology to allow transactional banking on a cell phone and it also offered a debit card. By 2019, WIZZIT International not only ran WIZZIT Bank in South Africa, it had also expanded into providing mobile-banking solutions to banks in 13 countries. 8 In the mobile money transfer arena, mobile communications company Vodacom had not been successful with the 2010 launch of M-Pesa - a mobile money transfer product that had achieved huge success in Kenya. The product failed dismally in South Africa and Vodacom closed it down in mid- 2016. Technology expert and owner of World Wide Worx Arthur Goldstuck, attributed the low demand for M-Pesa in South Africa to better financial inclusion - a greater proportion of the population already had bank accounts and therefore the need for a bankless mobile money transfer service was not as great. Acceptance of the Cloud 10 TymeGlobal's Hong Kong-based head of strategy, Aaron Foo, believed that a combination of factors had come into play to give TymeBank a greater chance of success when it launched. He pointed out that after the dot-com crash in 2000, adoption of digital technologies had gained momentum first in less regulated industries, such as retail for e-commerce and social media, before moving into industries where regulatory compliance on issues such as data, cyber security and system resilience were critical. "It has taken time for technology development, and in particular, cloud technologies, to arrive at a stage where regulators of systemic institutions are comfortable with them,” clarified Foo." In this context, TymeBank was the first bank in South Africa to receive approval from the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) to use the cloud for its core banking technology stack. This, according to Foo, was very unusual for emerging markets because using the cloud was still a novelty in regulated industries - even in developed markets. Receiving this approval was an important enabler of TymeBank's economic model. The traditional banking industry had been capital-intensive, requiring serious investment in physical branches to reach and service the customer base. “Digital has basically provided that window of opportunity when new players can come into the market and catch-up with the incumbents, but with a lower fixed asset investment," said Foo. 11 TymeBank's manager of strategy and partnerships, Neo Phukubje, added another reason for South Africa being ready for full digital banking: “Looking at environments that have high mobile adoptions, which is the case in most African countries, and where a very large component of people are either unbanked or underserved, it almost lends itself to an opportunity for a digital bank. It is almost a no brainer from an opportunity point of view. So, there are also other market forces that lend itself for a company to come together, and say it is very timely to be doing this kind of work in this kind of space." ,,12 The Origins of TymeBank In April 2011, Coenraad Jonker and Tjaart van der Walt, who had been friends for 22 years, met to discuss what they saw as an increasingly pressing need for inclusive banking, in South Africa as well as other emerging markets. Van der Walt had recently sold his artificial intelligence software business to the global digital industrial company General Electric and Jonker had been working at Standard Bank as the director of inclusive banking. 13 = 3 88 2 25 < > C 1:1 Q BOO 1,534 JUN 2 14 2 <tv A X W Д O T NEW ם
Expert Solution
steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Understanding Business
Understanding Business
Management
ISBN:
9781259929434
Author:
William Nickels
Publisher:
McGraw-Hill Education
Management (14th Edition)
Management (14th Edition)
Management
ISBN:
9780134527604
Author:
Stephen P. Robbins, Mary A. Coulter
Publisher:
PEARSON
Spreadsheet Modeling & Decision Analysis: A Pract…
Spreadsheet Modeling & Decision Analysis: A Pract…
Management
ISBN:
9781305947412
Author:
Cliff Ragsdale
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Management Information Systems: Managing The Digi…
Management Information Systems: Managing The Digi…
Management
ISBN:
9780135191798
Author:
Kenneth C. Laudon, Jane P. Laudon
Publisher:
PEARSON
Business Essentials (12th Edition) (What's New in…
Business Essentials (12th Edition) (What's New in…
Management
ISBN:
9780134728391
Author:
Ronald J. Ebert, Ricky W. Griffin
Publisher:
PEARSON
Fundamentals of Management (10th Edition)
Fundamentals of Management (10th Edition)
Management
ISBN:
9780134237473
Author:
Stephen P. Robbins, Mary A. Coulter, David A. De Cenzo
Publisher:
PEARSON