Imagine a sinking ship with 15 people. There are two lifeboats. One lifeboat can fit 9 people and has relatively few supplies, while the other lifeboat can fit 5 people and has ample supplies. Obviously, this makes it such that there is more demand than there are supplies. Imagine that among the passengers on the ship are the following:

College Physics
11th Edition
ISBN:9781305952300
Author:Raymond A. Serway, Chris Vuille
Publisher:Raymond A. Serway, Chris Vuille
Chapter1: Units, Trigonometry. And Vectors
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1CQ: Estimate the order of magnitude of the length, in meters, of each of the following; (a) a mouse, (b)...
icon
Related questions
icon
Concept explainers
Topic Video
Question

Imagine a sinking ship with 15 people. There are two lifeboats. One lifeboat can fit 9 people and has relatively few supplies, while the other lifeboat can fit 5 people and has ample supplies. Obviously, this makes it such that there is more demand than there are supplies. Imagine that among the passengers on the ship are the following:

  • A 70-year-old cancer patient
  • A 40-year-old obese man with Type 2 diabetes
  • A 20-year-old heroin addict
  • A 30-year-old HIV positive pregnant woman with a 5-year-old child

Imagine that all the other passengers on the sinking ship are otherwise relatively young and healthy. How would you answer the following questions?

  1. Would a lottery be an ethically acceptable way of determining access to resources? Why or why not?
  2. Would it be ethical to try to accommodate all 15 passengers, or would it be ethical to exclude one or more passengers from access to the lifeboats? 
  3. If you were to exclude, which passengers would it be ethical to exclude and why? Should those who have more needs (i.e., those who are unhealthy) or those who have more ability (i.e., those who are healthy) be excluded?
  4. How would you decide who gets on which lifeboat? Should those who have more needs qualify for access to more resources or less?
  5. To what extent would it be fair or rational to redistribute supplies between the lifeboats so as to accommodate everyone?
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Kinetic energy
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, physics and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
College Physics
College Physics
Physics
ISBN:
9781305952300
Author:
Raymond A. Serway, Chris Vuille
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
University Physics (14th Edition)
University Physics (14th Edition)
Physics
ISBN:
9780133969290
Author:
Hugh D. Young, Roger A. Freedman
Publisher:
PEARSON
Introduction To Quantum Mechanics
Introduction To Quantum Mechanics
Physics
ISBN:
9781107189638
Author:
Griffiths, David J., Schroeter, Darrell F.
Publisher:
Cambridge University Press
Physics for Scientists and Engineers
Physics for Scientists and Engineers
Physics
ISBN:
9781337553278
Author:
Raymond A. Serway, John W. Jewett
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Lecture- Tutorials for Introductory Astronomy
Lecture- Tutorials for Introductory Astronomy
Physics
ISBN:
9780321820464
Author:
Edward E. Prather, Tim P. Slater, Jeff P. Adams, Gina Brissenden
Publisher:
Addison-Wesley
College Physics: A Strategic Approach (4th Editio…
College Physics: A Strategic Approach (4th Editio…
Physics
ISBN:
9780134609034
Author:
Randall D. Knight (Professor Emeritus), Brian Jones, Stuart Field
Publisher:
PEARSON