Based solely (only) on the calculated payback periods for each proposal above, which project and why, is management likely to prefer for investment? **Griffith Vehicle: Evaluation of Proposals for New Vehicle-Painting Machine**Griffith Vehicle has received three proposals for its new vehicle-painting machine. The details for each proposal are outlined below:**Proposal X**- **Initial investment in equipment:** $240,000- **Working capital needed:** $0**Annual Cash Saved by Operations:**- Year 1: $80,000- Year 2: $80,000- Year 3: $80,000- Year 4: $80,000**Salvage Value at End of Year:**- Year 1: $100,000- Year 2: $80,000- Year 3: $40,000- Year 4: $10,000- **Working capital returned:** $0---**Proposal Y**- **Initial investment in equipment:** $150,000- **Working capital needed:** $0**Annual Cash Saved by Operations:**- Year 1: $50,000- Year 2: $42,000- Year 3: $46,000- Year 4: $24,000**Salvage Value at End of Year:**- Year 1: $80,000- Year 2: $60,000- Year 3: $40,000- Year 4: $20,000- **Working capital returned:** $0---**Proposal Z**- **Initial investment in equipment:** $190,000- **Working capital needed:** $10,000**Annual Cash Saved by Operations:**- Year 1: $80,000- Year 2: $80,000- Year 3: $80,000- Year 4: $80,000**Salvage Value at End of Year:**- Year 1: $60,000- Year 2: $50,000- Year 3: $30,000- Year 4: $15,000- **Working capital returned:** $10,000The table provides a comprehensive comparison of the cash savings and salvage values over a four-year period for each proposal, assisting in the decision-making process for investment in a new vehicle-painting machine.

The question is based on the concept of Financial Management.

Griffith Vehicle has received three proposals for its new vehicle-painting machine. Information on each proposal is as follows: Proposal X Proposal Y Proposal Z Initial investment in equipment $240,000 $150,000 $190,000 Working capital needed 10,000 Annual cash saved by operations: Year 1 80,000 50,000 80,000 Yoar ? 80 000 42000 80000

Griffith Vehicle has received three proposals for its new vehicle-painting machine. Information on each proposal is as follows: Proposal X Proposal Y Proposal Z Initial investment in equipment $240,000 $150,000 $190,000 Working capital needed 10,000 Annual cash saved by operations: Year 1 80,000 50,000 80,000 Yoar ? 80 000 42000 80000

FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING

10th Edition

ISBN:9781259964947

Author:Libby

Publisher:Libby

Chapter1: Financial Statements And Business Decisions

Section: Chapter Questions

Problem 1Q

See similar textbooks

Similar questions

Illustrate Investment Decision for a Nonsimple Project?
Describe the Incremental Analysis for Cost-Only Projects?
Financially, what is the economic worth of outbidding thecompetitors for a project?
Why is it important to make the distinction between company required rate of return (WACC) and project required rate of return when evaluating projects?
a. You are requested to assess the projects using payback period method and suggest the director on the selection of the project. b. You are also requested to appraise the management on the limitations of Payback period method.
A preference decision in capital budgeting: O is concerned with whether a project clears the minimum required rate of return hurdle. comes before the screening decision. O is concerned with determining which of several acceptable alternatives is best. O involves using market research to determine customers' preferences.
Are capital budgeting decisions termed either replacement decisions or expansion decisions? How can I distinguish between these two decision types and illustrate with an example?
Below are some statements about risk and investment appraisal. Which one is incorrect? A. Risk-adjusted hurdle rates could be used to allow for the risk of a project B. Risk could be allowed for in a project by shortening the pay-back period C. While sensitivity analysis does not directly imbed risk in the appraisal process it is helpful for identifying "key" variables D. Risk decreases with the length of a project E. Probability analysis can be used to allow for the risk of different economic conditions
Is this statement ture or false? Requiring a relative short pay-back period for projects indicates a high risk avoiding propensity within the organisation