Dean likes to practice guitar in his apartment, working primarily on mastering old Velvet Underground songs. Because he’s sure that developing guitar prowess will lead to riches – or at least critical acclaim in indie circles – he derives $500 in surplus from being able to practice. Dean’s practicing, however, is quite loud and can be heard clearly through paper-thin walls in his hip Brooklyn apartment. Britta lives next door and likes to read, but she is unable to do so when Dean plays guitar. She gets $350 in surplus from the satisfaction of reading. Suppose that when Dean and Britta bargain, they always split any surplus to be divided evenly. Assume that it’s common knowledge that courts always overestimate damages by $200, and transaction costs are $50. Given these assumptions, which of the following legal rules is most efficient: A. Britta's entitlement to read protected by a liability rule B. Dean having a property right to play C. Britta having a property right to read D. An inalienability rule for Britta's right to read
Dean likes to practice guitar in his apartment, working primarily on mastering old Velvet Underground songs. Because he’s sure that developing guitar prowess will lead to riches – or at least critical acclaim in indie circles – he derives $500 in surplus from being able to practice. Dean’s practicing, however, is quite loud and can be heard clearly through paper-thin walls in his hip Brooklyn apartment. Britta lives next door and likes to read, but she is unable to do so when Dean plays guitar. She gets $350 in surplus from the satisfaction of reading. Suppose that when Dean and Britta bargain, they always split any surplus to be divided evenly. Assume that it’s common knowledge that courts always overestimate damages by $200, and transaction costs are $50. Given these assumptions, which of the following legal rules is most efficient:
A. |
Britta's entitlement to read protected by a liability rule |
|
B. |
Dean having a property right to play |
|
C. |
Britta having a property right to read |
|
D. |
An inalienability rule for Britta's right to read |
Trending now
This is a popular solution!
Step by step
Solved in 2 steps