CASE: The case starts with Dr. Ramirez approaching a girl outside the family planning clinic to whom she offered a free therapy session. In the session, she discovered that Amy is an underage girl assaulted by her stepfather. Dr. Ramirez's information automatically made her carry the weight of cognizance regarding unethical acts such as sexual exploitation and abuse. As a doctor, she has to keep confidentiality. As an advocate for women's and children’s rights, she can report the situation to the rightful authorities. As a person, she has the urge to sympathize and show her rage. However, her actions can only be limited as she balances her multiple roles. Dr. Ramirez is the only person who can help her because Amy cannot bear to tell her mother what her stepfather has been doing to her. She knows that her mother would not believe her, which would probably cause many problems later. Now, if Dr. Ramirez helps Amy, it would mean that Dr. Ramirez would compromise and exert excessive effort beyond her supposed job description, primarily to listen, advise, and prescribe. In addition, she has many duties as a psychiatrist for her other patients. However, if Dr. Ramirez decided to help Amy, she would need to testify in court and defend the girl who had undergone statutory rape. Defending a client is something she has never done, and it would be the first time she will meddle due to her ethical consideration and the personal drive to help. QUESTION 1: The conflicting interest in the case is what Dr. Ramirez would do in the case of Amy since she feels that it is her responsibility and that her chosen course of action will change Amy’s life. Dr. Ramirez wanted to help Amy because she was aware that no one else could be adequately helpful to Amy other than her. She is the best-suited psychiatrist/psychologist for the case because the case is her forte, knowing that she has only limited alternatives. What specific step of Scott Rae's seven-step model of moral reasoning is Dr. Ramirez currently using, as evidenced by these remarks that have taken place in her mind? A. Gather the facts B. List of Alternatives C. Compare alternatives with principles D. Make a decision E. None of the above
CASE: The case starts with Dr. Ramirez approaching a girl outside the family planning clinic to whom she offered a free therapy session. In the session, she discovered that Amy is an underage girl assaulted by her stepfather. Dr. Ramirez's information automatically made her carry the weight of cognizance regarding unethical acts such as sexual exploitation and abuse. As a doctor, she has to keep confidentiality. As an advocate for women's and children’s rights, she can report the situation to the rightful authorities. As a person, she has the urge to sympathize and show her rage. However, her actions can only be limited as she balances her multiple roles. Dr. Ramirez is the only person who can help her because Amy cannot bear to tell her mother what her stepfather has been doing to her. She knows that her mother would not believe her, which would probably cause many problems later. Now, if Dr. Ramirez helps Amy, it would mean that Dr. Ramirez would compromise and exert excessive effort beyond her supposed job description, primarily to listen, advise, and prescribe. In addition, she has many duties as a psychiatrist for her other patients. However, if Dr. Ramirez decided to help Amy, she would need to testify in court and defend the girl who had undergone statutory rape. Defending a client is something she has never done, and it would be the first time she will meddle due to her ethical consideration and the personal drive to help.
QUESTION 1:
The conflicting interest in the case is what Dr. Ramirez would do in the case of Amy since she feels that it is her responsibility and that her chosen course of action will change Amy’s life. Dr. Ramirez wanted to help Amy because she was aware that no one else could be adequately helpful to Amy other than her. She is the best-suited psychiatrist/psychologist for the case because the case is her forte, knowing that she has only limited alternatives. What specific step of Scott Rae's seven-step model of moral reasoning is Dr. Ramirez currently using, as evidenced by these remarks that have taken place in her mind?
QUESTION 2:
If Dr. Ramirez decides to assist Amy, it is because she believes that doing so will help her project a positive image while she pursues the case. She will appear honorable, kind, and notable. What moral philosophy is Dr. Ramirez applying?
QUESTION 3:
Dr. Ramirez is thinking about giving Amy free therapy sessions till she heals, aiding Amy in filing a complaint against her stepfather, and raising money to help Amy go through the legal process to get the justice she deserves. Which of Scott Rae's Seven Steps is Dr. Ramirez currently in?
QUESTION 4:
What if Dr. Ramirez genuinely gives up her resources for Amy, with no concern for self-interest, because the doctor's intentions are pure and it is done out of goodwill? What ethical theory does she adhere to?
QUESTION 5:
What if Dr. Ramirez chooses to help many patients? The income she could gain in her practice could help numerous women and children through their organization. What ethical theory does she adhere to?
Trending now
This is a popular solution!
Step by step
Solved in 2 steps
