Be sure to answer the question you choose in detail and at length (approx 1 page per response).
Apart from those listed by Hohman in chapter 1, what other aspects of white privilege can you think of that are taken for granted in western societies?
Transcribed Image Text: tion of athers. How they' are catalogaed the is ed amuficis
sexual, middle-class people may reap the benefits of special privileges simply by
accident of birth.
Stephen Spencer - Race...
20
Writer Kimberly Hohman (2000) comments on several aspects of white privi-
lege that are taken for granted by white mainstream culture, but which, she sug-
Figure 12 cemplifiea the manner in which a whole poople may be reduced 10
an icon. Racism is deeply embedded in the project of these eivialising caone
mies. Such imagEr show dements of anthropological and romantic discourac that
Maccke (1982) argues are among the narrow lesicon available when talking about
indigenous Australians. The anthsopological discourse, wich ins focus on kinship.
ceremony, totemim and mythologs createn the 'other' an totally removed from the
viewer, semote, fixed in dime. Significantly, they are portrayod as an evolurionary
'cal-de-ac and doubts are espocaed about their aurvival. Such imager ee instruc-
tive not only for what they reveal about the poople in question bur also for what
is revealed abour bow whire Europcan culure s
e objectifica
artefacts
shown, the use of the landscape and the positioning of the family groups, as well
as the contiruity with imagery ued today, suggants that this view of indigenous
Australians as members of a timeless primitive' cukure serves a marked secial funo
cion thar helps to define and legitimate white Australian culkure.
Figure 13 is vurprising in ome respects. Compared with the stereotypical
images that I have just described, it seems to have an auchenticiky, a lack of pos
ing that in unuraal. The test describer thin a'a pleannt rural scene'. However, the
gests, are a constant source of unease for others:
Acordar
being able to turn on the television and see people of their race widely repre-
sented;
Tigue 13 S A pple of the deun, m IL Whles pi fal i
21
never being asked to speak on behalf of their entire
being able to succeed without being called a credit to their race;
being able to have a bad day without wondering what their race had to do
with specific negative incidents.
race;
21
figune 1.3 Nagre wen weding ywang ar cane, fo . lanta upln af Naian
womenis clothing - M ence puricanical and ragged - mcumbers their ahated
bodies, giving an oppressive sense of buck-breaking physical labour in stifing hear
thar makes the soene anything bur peasant. It is a reminder of colonialism and
slavery, despine the fact that the decriprion maker attempts to draw adear distine
tion berween slavery and this pleasant soene, infoeming us thar
Hohman thus demonstrates the pernicious everyday effects of being marked out
as different. However, the consequences can be much more serious. It is well
For many years Jamaica was one of the worlds greatest slave marts, the emanci
parion of the slaves took place in 1834. The negeo peaunt population is chiefly
employed on the sugar plancacion, and here we have a rypial group of women
buily woeking among the young canca.
(Hammerten 1933: 203)
Yer in picnures such as this, which objectify the colonial subject, chere
attemper to coruider them a people oppremad, although they ane burdened by
tranagreionary signs that undermine the mperficial voyeurim employed in the
ter. The face of the woman in dhe cencre of che picture, half curned and regard-
ing the photographer namowly, with uapicion and resentment, forma in Barthe's
terminology the puncrum of this image and tansfoms it fom the artifice of the
popular trivial ethnography by opening up other seadinga so this intended apoliti-
cal diorama, in which separane subjecta are encisely semoved from the perception
of Hammerton's ideal seader. In this way, a smal sign, a look, a gesture, the set of a
are no
22
22
REPRESENTATION
23
body (a featune unintended by the photographer who componed the image) tran-
forms and denies che dominant reading's implied dosure.
WHITENESS AS MYTH
"Whinemen' in an caample af a dominant yet naturalised and mythologiaed cultural
form. Michael Pickering oxposes the underlying truch abour the discourse of race as
a marker of difference from a poniion of invisible white domination:
In contemporary discourse, 'race seiera to people who are non-white, and
denotes oulrural afference. 'Race is used asa way of designating cortain car-
qgories within our culture, and it don this from an invisible, underignated posi-
tion. This is the posicion of whiteness. As a normative posicion, whiteness is
taken to be a narural fact, existing beyond the bounds of consideration. It is noc
racially marked a white in she wayr that hlack is marked.
(Pikering 2004 91)
This is casy to illustrate in everyday languape to specify that something is 'whie
may scem norueraical or tranagrenive, while ming the labeh "black' or Auian may
seem quice justifiable. The song "Whie Rior', by The Clash (1977), challenges our
aumptionu of what a riot can or hould be. The deevlepment of "Whine Studies
in an intereting phenomenen in that ingnise and serutinises whinmen' in an
atempt o seveal what is typically rendered invisible and normative. The uneamed
privilege acceded to white people in eur cinien operan in a compurable way
De ocher markes of power in society Similarls young, male. able-bodied, henena
scual, middle-dan people may reap the benefitn of pecial privilagea imply by
accident of birth.
Writer Kimberty Hohman (2000) commenes on several aspects of whice privi
lege that are taken for granned by white mainemeam culure, but which, the mg-
gests, are a conspant source of uncase for others
• being able to turn on the televiion and see people of their race widely repre
• never being asked oo speak on behalf of their entire race.
• being ahle to succeed without bcing called a credit to their race;
• being able to have a bad day withour wondering what cheir race had to do
with specific negative incidents.
Hohman chur demanatraten the pemicioun everyday effecta of being marked out
as different. However, the consequences can be much more serious. Ir is well
21