A. COST OF RENTING 1. Annual rental costs ( 12 x monthly rental rate of $ 2. Renter's insurance 3. Opportunity cost of security deposit: B. COST OF BUYING Total cost of renting (line A.1 + line A.2 + line A.3) 1. Annual mortgage payments (Terms: ( 12 x monthly mortgage payment of 2. Property taxes % of price of home) 3. Homeowner's insurance % of price of home) 4. Maintenance Less: % of price of home) 6. Total costs (sum of lines B.1 through B.5) 5. After-tax cost of interest on down payment and closing costs ( $ 8. Tax savings due to interest deductions* (Interest portion of mortgage payments 9. Tax savings due to property tax deductions* (line B.2 x tax rate of 7. Principal reduction in loan balance (see note below) 10. Total deductions (sum of lines B.7 through B.9) $ 11. Annual after-tax cost of home ownership (line B.6-line B.10) $ $ 12. Estimated annual appreciation in value of home ( % of price of home) Total cost of buying (line B.11-line B.12) % after-tax rate of return) $ RENT-OR-BUY ANALYSIS %) x after-tax savings rate x tax rate of months, %) %) $ Note: Find monthly mortgage payments from the Exhibit in chapter 5 of your textbook. An easy way to approximate the portion of the annual loan payment that goes to interest (line B.8) is to multiply the interest rate by the size of the loan. To find the principal reduction in the loan balance (line B.7), simply subtract the amount that goes to interest from total annual mortgage payments. *Tax-shelter items. $ $ $ $ $ I'
fill in the blanks using this information:
Theoretical Housing Situation:
Renting:
- Monthly Rent: $1,800
- Renter’s Insurance: $200 per year
- Security Deposit: $2,000
- After-tax Savings Rate: 5%
Buying:
- Home Price: $250,000
- Down Payment: $50,000
- Loan Amount: $200,000
- Loan Term: 25 years
- Interest Rate: 3.5%
- Property Taxes: 1.25% of the home price
- Homeowner’s Insurance: 0.4% of the home price
- Maintenance Costs: 1.5% of the home price
- Closing Costs: $5,000
- After-tax
Rate of Return : 4% - Tax Rate: 25%
- Estimated Annual Appreciation: 2%
Now, fill in the worksheet:
A. COST OF RENTING:
-
Annual Rental Costs (Line A.1):
- 12×$1,800=$21,60012×$1,800=$21,600
-
Renter’s Insurance (Line A.2):
- $200
-
Opportunity Cost of Security Deposit (Line A.3):- $2,000×0.05=$100$2,000×0.05=$100
-
Total Cost of Renting (Line A.1 + Line A.2 + Line A.3):
- $21,600+$200+$100=$21,900$21,600+$200+$100=$21,900
B. COST OF BUYING:
-
Annual Mortgage Payments (Line B.1):
- Use a mortgage calculator to find the monthly mortgage payment and then multiply by 12.
-
Property Taxes (Line B.2):
- $250,000×0.0125=$3,125$250,000×0.0125=$3,125
-
Homeowner’s Insurance (Line B.3):
- $250,000×0.004=$1,000$250,000×0.004=$1,000
-
Maintenance (Line B.4):
- $250,000×0.015=$3,750$250,000×0.015=$3,750
-
After-Tax Cost of Interest on Down Payment and Closing Costs (Line B.5):
- $5,000×0.04=$200$5,000×0.04=$200
-
Total Costs (Line B.6):
- Sum of Lines B.1 through B.5.
-
Principal Reduction in Loan Balance (Line B.7):
- Follow the note's instructions to find this value.
-
Tax Savings Due to Interest Deductions (Line B.8):
- Interest portion of mortgage payments×Tax rateInterest portion of mortgage payments×Tax rate
-
Tax Savings Due to Property Tax Deductions (Line B.9):
- Property taxes×Tax rateProperty taxes×Tax rate
-
Total Deductions (Line B.10):
- Sum of Lines B.7 through B.9.
-
Annual After-Tax Cost of Home Ownership (Line B.11):
- Line B.6 - Line B.10Line B.6 - Line B.10
-
Estimated Annual Appreciation in Value of Home (Line B.12):
- $250,000×0.02=$5,000$250,000×0.02=$5,000
-
Total Cost of Buying (Line B.11 - Line B.12):
- Line B.11 - Line B.12Line B.11 - Line B.12
Unlock instant AI solutions
Tap the button
to generate a solution