Homework Help is Here – Start Your Trial Now!
Engineering
Civil Engineering
5 5a 5b 5c Alaterally supported beam was designed for flexure. The beam is safe for shear & deflection. The most economical section is W 8 x 13 however the said section is not readily available at the time of the construction. If you are the engineer in charge of the construction what alternative section will be the best replacement? Why? Use: Fy=248 MPa: E=200,000 MPa Designation Weight Ag (mm2) 1910 kg/m d (depth) mm 15 width 19 30 24 flange bf 100.06 W8 x 10 200.41 5.21 expla'n briefly your cho'ce. (transform your comparative analys's 'nto a narat've form to support your cho'ce) W8 x 13 2477 202.05 101.60 W6 x 20 3787 157.48 W6 x 16 3058 159.51 thickness tf 152.91 102.36 Web 6.48 9.27 10.29 thickness tw 4.32 5.84 Elastic Properties mm 4 mm 3 Ix x 106 Sxx 103 6.60 6.60 13 16 17 13 126 162 220 167 mm rx 81.79 81.53 67.56 66.04 mm 4 lyx 106 1 1 6 2 mm 3 Sy x 106 17 22 mm ry 21.36 21.41 72 38.10244 36 24.54 Plastic properties mm 3 mm 3 Zxx 103 145 187 244 192 Zyx 103 27 35 110 56 h=d-2k h 168.28 168.28 120.65 120.65

5 5a 5b 5c Alaterally supported beam was designed for flexure. The beam is safe for shear & deflection. The most economical section is W 8 x 13 however the said section is not readily available at the time of the construction. If you are the engineer in charge of the construction what alternative section will be the best replacement? Why? Use: Fy=248 MPa: E=200,000 MPa Designation Weight Ag (mm2) 1910 kg/m d (depth) mm 15 width 19 30 24 flange bf 100.06 W8 x 10 200.41 5.21 expla'n briefly your cho'ce. (transform your comparative analys's 'nto a narat've form to support your cho'ce) W8 x 13 2477 202.05 101.60 W6 x 20 3787 157.48 W6 x 16 3058 159.51 thickness tf 152.91 102.36 Web 6.48 9.27 10.29 thickness tw 4.32 5.84 Elastic Properties mm 4 mm 3 Ix x 106 Sxx 103 6.60 6.60 13 16 17 13 126 162 220 167 mm rx 81.79 81.53 67.56 66.04 mm 4 lyx 106 1 1 6 2 mm 3 Sy x 106 17 22 mm ry 21.36 21.41 72 38.10244 36 24.54 Plastic properties mm 3 mm 3 Zxx 103 145 187 244 192 Zyx 103 27 35 110 56 h=d-2k h 168.28 168.28 120.65 120.65

Structural Analysis
Structural Analysis
6th Edition
ISBN:9781337630931
Author:KASSIMALI, Aslam.
Publisher:KASSIMALI, Aslam.
Chapter2: Loads On Structures
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 1P
See similar textbooks
icon
Related questions
Question
5 5a 5b 5c Alaterally supported beam was designed for flexure. The beam is safe for shear & deflection. The most economical section is W 8 x 13 however the said section is not readily available at the time of the construction. If you are the engineer in charge of the construction what alternative section will be the best replacement? Why? Use: Fy=248 MPa: E=200,000 MPa Designation Ag (mm2) Weight kg/m 1910 19 30 width 24 flange. thickness d (depth) mm 200.41 bf 100.06 W8 x 10 4.32 15 expla'n briefly your cho'ce. (transform your comparative analys's 'nto a narat've form to support your cho'ce) W8 x 13 2477 202.05 101.60 6.48 W6 x 20 3787 157.48 9.27 152.91 102.36 W6 x 16 3058 159.51 10.29 tf Web 5.21 thickness tw Elastic Properties mm 4 Ix x 106 mm 3 Sx x 103 5.84 6.60 6.60 13 16 17 13 126 162 220 167 mm rx 81.79 81.53 67.56 66.04 mm 4 lyx 106 1 1 6 2 mm 3 Sy x 106 17 22 72 36 mm ry 21.36 21.41 38.10244 24.54 Plastic properties mm 3 Zx x 103 145 187 244 192 mm 3 Zyx 103 27 35 110 56 h=d-2k h 168.28 168.28 120.65 120.65
Transcribed Image Text:5 5a 5b 5c Alaterally supported beam was designed for flexure. The beam is safe for shear & deflection. The most economical section is W 8 x 13 however the said section is not readily available at the time of the construction. If you are the engineer in charge of the construction what alternative section will be the best replacement? Why? Use: Fy=248 MPa: E=200,000 MPa Designation Ag (mm2) Weight kg/m 1910 19 30 width 24 flange. thickness d (depth) mm 200.41 bf 100.06 W8 x 10 4.32 15 expla'n briefly your cho'ce. (transform your comparative analys's 'nto a narat've form to support your cho'ce) W8 x 13 2477 202.05 101.60 6.48 W6 x 20 3787 157.48 9.27 152.91 102.36 W6 x 16 3058 159.51 10.29 tf Web 5.21 thickness tw Elastic Properties mm 4 Ix x 106 mm 3 Sx x 103 5.84 6.60 6.60 13 16 17 13 126 162 220 167 mm rx 81.79 81.53 67.56 66.04 mm 4 lyx 106 1 1 6 2 mm 3 Sy x 106 17 22 72 36 mm ry 21.36 21.41 38.10244 24.54 Plastic properties mm 3 Zx x 103 145 187 244 192 mm 3 Zyx 103 27 35 110 56 h=d-2k h 168.28 168.28 120.65 120.65
Expert Solution
steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps with 2 images

SEE SOLUTIONCheck out a sample Q&A here
Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Bars
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, civil-engineering and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Recommended textbooks for you
Structural Analysis
Structural Analysis
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9781337630931
Author:
KASSIMALI, Aslam.
Publisher:
Cengage,
Structural Analysis (10th Edition)
Structural Analysis (10th Edition)
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9780134610672
Author:
Russell C. Hibbeler
Publisher:
PEARSON
Principles of Foundation Engineering (MindTap Cou…
Principles of Foundation Engineering (MindTap Cou…
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9781337705028
Author:
Braja M. Das, Nagaratnam Sivakugan
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
Fundamentals of Structural Analysis
Fundamentals of Structural Analysis
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9780073398006
Author:
Kenneth M. Leet Emeritus, Chia-Ming Uang, Joel Lanning
Publisher:
McGraw-Hill Education
Sustainable Energy
Sustainable Energy
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9781337551663
Author:
DUNLAP, Richard A.
Publisher:
Cengage,
Traffic and Highway Engineering
Traffic and Highway Engineering
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9781305156241
Author:
Garber, Nicholas J.
Publisher:
Cengage Learning
SEE MORE TEXTBOOKS