### Proposition Analysis**Problem:**Examine the provided "proof" of the given "proposition." Is this "proposition" true? If not, identify a counterexample.#### PropositionConsider sets $ A $, $ B $, and $ C $ such that $ A \subseteq B \cup C $. This implies $ A \subseteq B $ or $ A \subseteq C $.#### Provided ProofTo prove or disprove the proposition, follow these steps:1. **Assumption:** Let $ x $ be any arbitrary object and suppose $ x \in A $. 2. **Implication:** Since $ A \subseteq B \cup C $, it implies $ x \in B \cup C $. 3. **Definition of Union:** By the definition of the union, $ x \in B $ or $ x \in C $.4. **Conclusion:** Therefore, for any object $ x $, if $ x \in A $, then $ x \in B $ or $ x \in C $.5. **Subset Definition:** Hence, by the definition of a subset, we can conclude $ A \subseteq B $ or $ A \subseteq C $.#### Analysis and Error IdentificationThe provided "proof" contains a flaw. It incorrectly assumes that if $ x $ belongs to the union $ B \cup C $, then $ x $ necessarily belongs to either $ B $ or $ C $ independently for all elements in $ A $. However, there could be elements of $ A $ that belong to $ B \cup C $ but not entirely to one set $ B $ or $ C $.#### CounterexampleConsider the following sets:- $ A = \{1, 2\} $- $ B = \{1\} $- $ C = \{2\} $Here, $ A \subseteq B \cup C $ because every element of $ A $ is in the union of $ B $ and $ C $:\[ A = \{1, 2\} \text{ and } B \cup C = \{1, 2\} \]However, $ A $ is not a subset of $ B $ (since \(

Name: ### Proposition Analysis**Problem:**Examine the provided "proof" of t
Uploaded: 2024-03-20T06:38:44.000Z
Channel: Bartleby
Description: ### Proposition Analysis**Problem:**Examine the provided "proof" of the given "proposition." Is this "proposition" true? If not, identify a counterexample.#### PropositionConsider sets $ A $, $ B $, and $ C $ such that \( A \subseteq B \cup C

Answered: Image /qna-images/answer/c65f6e0f-e4bc-4613-8d04-9ad72133d68c.jpg

Math

Advanced Math

24. Find the mistake in the "proof" of the following "proposition." Is this "proposition true? If not, find a counterexample. "Proposition." Let A, B and C be sets and suppose that ACBỤC Then A s Bor ACC. "proof" Let x be any object and suppose that xEA. ThenxEBUC since ACBUC Thus, by the definition of union, xE Bor xe C. Therefore, for all objects x, ifEA, then xe Bor, for all objects x, if xEA, then xEC. Hence, by the definition of subset, AC Bor ACC.

24. Find the mistake in the "proof" of the following "proposition." Is this "proposition true? If not, find a counterexample. "Proposition." Let A, B and C be sets and suppose that ACBỤC Then A s Bor ACC. "proof" Let x be any object and suppose that xEA. ThenxEBUC since ACBUC Thus, by the definition of union, xE Bor xe C. Therefore, for all objects x, ifEA, then xe Bor, for all objects x, if xEA, then xEC. Hence, by the definition of subset, AC Bor ACC.

Advanced Engineering Mathematics

10th Edition

ISBN:9780470458365

Author:Erwin Kreyszig

Publisher:Erwin Kreyszig

Chapter2: Second-order Linear Odes

Section: Chapter Questions

Problem 1RQ

See similar textbooks

Related questions

Q: Question 11. Taking a (x), b(x) and c(x) to denote the statements "x E A", "x E B" and "x E C"…

A: Given: A∪B=A∪B-A A∪B⊆C≡A⊆C∧B⊆C ax, bx, and cx denotes x∈A, x∈B, and x∈C respectively. To do:…

Q: Prove each of the given theorems of propositional logic. Conclusion: p → s a. Premises: p-q, s V q;…

A: Approach to solving the question: Detailed explanation: Examples: Key references: I sincerely…

Q: 9.) In the domain of all Baseball teams, let B(x) be the predicate, “x is a good team”. Write the…

Q: Use truth sets to prove or disprove the following quantified statements. Note: You can view the…

Q: Suppose tand k are these propositions: t:"you take the job" k:"you know how to program" Express in…

A: Given - Suppose t and k are two propositions. t : '' you take the job '' k : '' you know how to…

Q: QUESTION 6 Suppose x is an element from the set (2, 3, 4) and y is an element from the set (5, 6).…

Q: Question 6. Let S, T and U be three sets. (1) Write the statement SnT U using the logic symbols (but…

A: Given: S, T, and U are three sets. To Do: (a) Write the statement S∩T⊈U using logic symbols. (b)…

Q: Use the laws of propositional logic to prove that the following compound propositions are…

A: To use law of propositional logic to prove that the below compound propositions are tautologies.…

Q: Show that de’Morgan law holds for propositions.

Q: (png)→p=T b. -p→F = p а.

Q: Let the statement A be given by A: (not p) implies (q and r). For which value is A = F? Op=q = T,r =…

A: To find for which value the given statement A is false. Given: A: (not p) implies (q and r).

Q: Express each of these statements using predicates, quantifiers and logical connectives. Domain: All…

A: Please cheek next steps for details

Q: a)find a proposition using only p, q, and ~ (negation) and V (or) b) find a propostion with three…

Q: Consider the open statement P(t) which says (∃x)(tx = 20). Find the full truth set for P if the…

A: Given that the statement P(t) is "(∃x)(tx = 20)" We have to determine the truth set for P where the…

Concept explainers

Statements and Logic

Logic is the analysis of general patterns of thoughts without regard to any specific sense of context.

Topic Video

Question

### Proposition Analysis

**Problem:**
Examine the provided "proof" of the given "proposition." Is this "proposition" true? If not, identify a counterexample.

#### Proposition
Consider sets $ A $, $ B $, and $ C $ such that $ A \subseteq B \cup C $. This implies $ A \subseteq B $ or $ A \subseteq C $.

#### Provided Proof
To prove or disprove the proposition, follow these steps:

1. **Assumption:**
Let $ x $ be any arbitrary object and suppose $ x \in A $.

2. **Implication:**
Since $ A \subseteq B \cup C $, it implies $ x \in B \cup C $.

3. **Definition of Union:**
By the definition of the union, $ x \in B $ or $ x \in C $.

4. **Conclusion:**
Therefore, for any object $ x $, if $ x \in A $, then $ x \in B $ or $ x \in C $.

5. **Subset Definition:**
Hence, by the definition of a subset, we can conclude $ A \subseteq B $ or $ A \subseteq C $.

#### Analysis and Error Identification

The provided "proof" contains a flaw. It incorrectly assumes that if $ x $ belongs to the union $ B \cup C $, then $ x $ necessarily belongs to either $ B $ or $ C $ independently for all elements in $ A $. However, there could be elements of $ A $ that belong to $ B \cup C $ but not entirely to one set $ B $ or $ C $.

#### Counterexample

Consider the following sets:
- $ A = \{1, 2\} $
- $ B = \{1\} $
- $ C = \{2\} $

Here, $ A \subseteq B \cup C $ because every element of $ A $ is in the union of $ B $ and $ C $:
\[ A = \{1, 2\} \text{ and } B \cup C = \{1, 2\} \]

However, $ A $ is not a subset of $ B $ (since \(

Expert Solution

This question has been solved!

Explore an expertly crafted, step-by-step solution for a thorough understanding of key concepts.

SEE SOLUTION Check out a sample Q&A here

Step 1

VIEW

Step 2

VIEW

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps with 2 images

SEE SOLUTION Check out a sample Q&A here

Knowledge Booster

$Propositional Calculus$

Learn more about

Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, advanced-math and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.

Similar questions

Discrete Mathmetics 2015 Review for Test 1 1. Determine whether the following propositions are T or F a) 2+1 = 4 or 4+3 = 6 b) 4+5 = 8 or 2+5 = 7 c) 8-5 = and 3 6 = 9 d) 5+6 = 10 and 2+3 =6 2. Determine the truth values of the following statements. If False, give a counter- example. Suppose the domain = {1,2,3,4} a) Vx (x+3<6) b) 3x (x+<6) 3. Let p: I go to Delhi Q: I visit Red Fort R:I visit Rajghat Which propositions for the following sentences using symbols. a) If I go to Delhi, then I visit Red Fort b) I go to the Delhi, but I do not visit Red Fort. c) Either I visit Red Fort it I visit Rajghat. d) Neither do I visit Red Fort, nor do I visit Rajghat. e) I go to Delhi, and I visit Rajghat, but I do not Red Fort. f) If I go to Delhi, and do not visit Red Fort, then to Delhi. g) To visit Delhi Red Fort, it is necessary that I go to Delhi. h) I go to Delhi if and only if I visit Red Fort and Rajghat. i) To visit Red Fort and Rajghat, it is sufficient for me to go to Delhi.
Exercise 1.1.3: Applying logical operations. infoAbout Assume the propositions p, q, r, and s have the following truth values: p is false q is true r is false s is true What are the truth values for the following compound propositions? (a) ¬p (b) p ∨ r (c) q ∧ s (d) q ∨ s (e) q ⊕ s (f) q ⊕ r
If 1 is used to represent true and 0 is used to represent false, determine the symbolic proposition that is computed by the following function: def Proposition(p,q):if p == 1 and q == 1:return 1elif p == 1 and q == 0:return 0elif p == 0 and q == 1:return 0elif p == 0 and q == 0:return 1
Give an example of each or state that the request is impossible.When a request is impossible, provide a compelling argument for why this isthe case.(a) Two sets A and B with A ∩ B = ∅, supA = supB, supA /∈ A andsupB /∈ B.
Evaluate the proposition ∀∃y.P(x,y) ⇐⇒ ∃y.∀x.P(x,y) for an unknown predicate P. Could the statement be true? Must the statement be true for all P? Give a specific P (with domains for x and y) where it is either true or false. Prove that it is true for all P, or show a contradiction.
3. If A and B are ANY two sets, determine the truth-values of the following statements. If a statement is false, give specific examples of sets A and B that serve as a counter- example a. (A\B) BØ b. (A\B) (B\A) = Ø
3.) (P→Q)=CQ→°P) Build the truth table. P -P P →Q According to the truth table you built, are these statements logically equivalent? Why or why not?
2. Let A, B, and C be sets. Prove the following deduction. x=A\B, x¤BUC, ..XEANC
For each logical argument, select all the truth assignments for the propositional variables that show the logical argument is invalid. 1) 2) r S T T r T F T F p+ -q rv ¬S FT F T :- F F F F