Ethical Dilemma Peer Review-1

Ethical Dilemma – Review Checklist Recommendation ☐ Approve X Return for Revision Please fill out each row of this worksheet. If you approve the essay for submission as is, provide evidence from the text in support of your recommendation. If you recommend revisions to the essay, provide evidence in support of your recommendation. Finally, write a summary of your recommendation below. Article Requirements Yes No Evidence From Text Clear Judgment Writer makes a strong, clear ethical judgment in response to an ethical dilemma. yes "…it can be determined that the most ethical choice in this situation is to tell your parents the truth about your plans, but to also take steps to mitigate their worry. This decision not only aligns with the virtue of honesty and compassion, but also promotes trust and communication in the relationship with your parents.” Ethical Framework Judgment is grounded in a clear ethical framework. yes “Virtue ethics is a moral theory that emphasizes the development of virtuous character traits and the pursuit of the "good life." According to virtue ethics, the most ethical decision is one that is made by someone with a virtuous character, who acts in accordance with their moral virtues and is guided by the concept of the ‘Golden Mean.’” Support for Judgment Ethics tests and substantive examples support the judgment. yes “Another way to confirm your judgment is by applying the ethics test of "The Categorical Imperative." This test states that one should always act in a way that they would be willing to make into a universal law. In this situation, it can be argued that if everyone always kept their loved ones in the dark about potentially dangerous situations, it would lead to a lack of trust and communication in relationships. Therefore, it is morally imperative to be honest with your parents about your plans.” Rationalizations Argument is free of all rationalizations. no “This can be done by providing them with information about the safety measures that are in place in Kyiv and the steps that your organization is taking to ensure your safety, as well as letting them know that you will be in regular contact with them during your detachment. Additionally, it is important to reassure them that you are taking the risks of the situation seriously and have thought through the decision carefully.” Rhetorical Context Writer recognizes the rhetorical context and effectively positions his/her appeal within that context. Yes “According to virtue ethics, it is important to be honest with your parents and not deceive them, as this undermines the trust they have in you. Additionally, the virtue of compassion is also important in this situation. Compassion is the ability to understand and empathize with the feelings of