fact sheet
pdf
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Humber College *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
BICC 100
Subject
Medicine
Date
Dec 6, 2023
Type
Pages
4
Uploaded by ProfBookGerbil12
The Harassment
Towards Hospital
Staff in Ontario
Purpose:
To bring more awareness to harassment
towards hospital staff. The topic Is always tucked
under the rug to keep the image of the medicine
industry good.
Audience:
Hospital staff, higher ups, and health
care workers in Ontario.
How is workplace harassment happening so
frequently without any solutions or
prevention?
The ‘New solutions; research study led by Dr. Margaret
Keith, Dr. Jim Brophy, and Michael hurley, concluded
the health industry is lacking legislative and institu-
tional acknowledgement of the current violence and
harassment directed towards health care workers. They
state there is a lack of resources in the industry such as
preventative programs, appropriate facilities, enough
staff, security, zero tolerance policies, and many more.
This is part of the reason sexual assault and harassment
towards health care workers is left unresolved. There
is very little reports about the harassment and assault
because health care workers feel as if it is better to stay
quiet about their experiences and are more afraid of the
negative repercussions, they may endure by reporting
these issues (Canadian Union of Public Employees, 2017).
Does the race and gender of a person put
them more at risk of experiencing
harassment/assault?
A poll conducted by Oricle research and the CUPE
(Canadian Union of Public Employees) concluded that
155,610 hospital workers get physically assaulted an-
nually, 61, 379 of those cases would be racially mo-
tivated (Yeadon, 2022, para. 6). 71% of hospital staff
reported being subjects to harassment because of their
appearance and race (para.3). Most of the people fac-
ing this harassment and assault include woman and
The Pandemic
Stats collected from the poll relating to
Covid 19:
- 53% reported an increase in violence targeting them
or a co-worker during covid 19.
Para. #2
- 49% of all categories of hospital staff experienced
sexual harassment. Para. #3
- 36% experienced sexual assault. Para. #3
- A lot of the violence is racially motivated. Para. #3
Why was there a surge of assault and
harassment during the pandemic?
The Covid 19 pandemic caused a lot of stress and changes
to everyone’s environment. The place that defiantly expe-
rienced the most trauma and stress was our hospitals. The
pandemic increased the violence and harassment towards
staff, especially woman. There were racially motivated at-
tacks and weapons brought into hospitals such as guns or
knives during the pandemic, the usage of these weapons
in hospitals was increased by 18% during Covid (Yeadon,
2022, para.2). The pandemic caused overcrowding in
hospitals, fewer staff, extreme safety measures that put
more lives at risk than they did save (para.7). This caused
an entire outbreak of violence in our hospitals because
patients and staff became angry, stressed, impatient, and
irritated. The shortages in staff also made female and POC
staff more venerable and susceptible to assault because
they were outnumbered by angry patients and families.
The Harassment
Towards Hospital Staff
in Ontario
woman of colour. Hospitals are very dangerous for
female staff and people of colour; they are targeted to
being assaulted and beaten especially since the increase
in violence the Covid 19 pandemic caused (para.7).
The Harassment
Towards Hospital Staff in Ontario
By; Kayla Napolitano
Workplace harassment and sexual assault have very
serious and negative effects on victims. It is document-
ed that sexual assault decreases job satisfaction (Gru-
ber,1992), ruins relationships with coworkers (Gutek,
1985; Loy & Stewart, 1984) and loss of jobs. This ha-
rassment poses a serious risk to staff ’s physical and
psychological health (Fitzgerald, 1997, para.4). PTSD
and anxiety are the most obvious psychological affects
the victims dealt with. In an interview conducted by
the CUPE (New Solutions) respondents explained the
quick affects following harassment or witnessing it.
Those affects were becoming fearful of going into work,
becoming weary of patients they are caring for, and
feeling the impact of long-term psychological trauma
(Canadian Union of Public Employees, 2017, Para. 4-8).
The lack of support and resources doubles their trauma
and even made them fearful of taking part in the study.
They feared they would be punished for speaking out.
How do victims cope with the harassment?
Is it a healthy coping mechanism?
There are many ways woman in the workplace cope with
the harassment. Some healthy while some are not. In
the table “Use of Coping Strategies in the Two Samples”
Fitzgerald (1997, page 408, table 2) 11 different coping
strategies were recorded. Along with the percentages of
woman who used these strategies. The most common
coping strategy was woman staying away from the person
who assaulted or harassed them, along with thinking it
wasn’t important. A lot of women also explained they
just “put up with it” or tried to forget about it. The most
alarming information seen in this table is making for-
mal complaints or talking with a supervisor has some
of the lowest percentages. The most common coping
mechanisms recorded in the table are the least healthy.
This must be because of the lack of support staff has re-
garding harassment and sexual assault, health care staff
do not feel safe about speaking out to supervisors in their
workplace and will most likely be victim blamed if they
do (Canadian Union of Public Employees, 2017, para.11).
The Effects of Workplace
Harassment:
What are the effects of workplace
harassment?
The Silence:
Why are nurses/ staff not speaking out
about harassment they experience/ witness?
Hospital staff rarely report any sort of violence or abuse
they witness or endure. This is because the health care
system is not at all supportive to these victims and
do not bother helping. In fact, during the poll taken
by the CUPE (New Solutions) participants explained
they were afraid of the negative repercussions they will
face after reporting such incidents. (Canadian Union
of Public Employees, 2017, para.6).
A lot of wom-
en in the workforce also ignore the fact that they are
victims and won’t admit it to themselves. This could
be because of the lack of support and resources our
hospitals have to offer, so they do not see a point in re-
porting the incident since nothing will be done about it.
The Possible Solution
How would educating staff and hospi-
tal members about workplace aggression
change the outcome?
It is hard to control the number of cases health care
workers experience but will educating them maybe
change the outcome? Teaching staff how to be careful
while also keeping up with their quality of work may
help to keep work environments safer. But more efforts
than just education need to be put in place. Education
and training may create no change regarding work-
place harassment and aggression (Geoffrion et al. 2020,
para. 11), this education and training however may be
helpful if other procedures are put into place such as:
-
-
-
-
-
Preventative programs
Zero Tolerance policies
Greater staff levels
Psychological resources for victims
Someone staff can specifically report harassment
and sexual assault to without feeling there will be
negative effects of reporting. (Canadian Union of
Public Employees, 2017).
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
References
Fitzgerald , L. F., Swan, S., & Schneider, K. T. (1997). Job-Related and Psychological Ef-
fects of Sexual Harassment in the Workplace...
https://web-p-ebscohost-com.ezproxy.humber.ca/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=3&si
d=65ad6efc-0879-4304-82d7-674ec9fd6d44%40redis
Geoffrion, S., Hills, D. J., Ross, H. M., Pich, J., Hill, A. T., Dalsbø, T. K., Riahi, S.,
Martínez-Jarreta, B., & Guay, S. (2020, September 8). Education and training for pre-
venting and minimizing workplace aggression directed toward healthcare workers. The Co-
chrane database of systematic reviews.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8094156/
New Study reveals toxic environment of physical and sexual violence against staff in Ontario
Hospitals. Canadian Union of Public Employees. (n.d.).
https://cupe.ca/new-study-reveals-toxic-environment-physical-and-sexual-vi-
olence-against-staff-ontario-hospitals
Yeadon, S. (2022, July 5). Ontario hospital staff subjected to a disturbing pandemic surge in
physical and sexual violence; new CUPE Poll finds. Business Wire.
https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20220705005561/en/Ontario-hospital-staff-sub-
jected-to-a-disturbing-pandemic-surge-in-physical-and-sexual-violence-new-CUPE-poll-
finds