Broken Window Essay

.docx

School

Grand Canyon University *

*We aren’t endorsed by this school

Course

620

Subject

Law

Date

May 25, 2024

Type

docx

Pages

7

Uploaded by DeanStraw15262

Broken Window Essay 1 Broken Window Essay Roderick White Grand Canyon University JUS 620: Exploration of Law and Public Policy November 6, 2023
Broken Window Essay 2 Regarding policing, there are various methods. Think about the "broken windows" strategy. Based on the idea that physical degradation in a society can promote disorder and lead to more serious crime by signaling that laws are not being followed, the broken windows theory serves as the foundation for this strategy (Worrall, 2015, p. 165). Put another way, more serious crimes will occur if the police do not give priority to low-level disorder and deviance. With this strategy, law enforcement organizations can become more successful in decreasing crime by concentrating on and addressing little issues in local communities. This essay aims to investigate the following queries: 1.) The reasons why policing through smashed windows has a detrimental effect, 2.) Is it feasible for the police to be proactive and forceful without drawing unfavorable complaints? 3.) What kind of policing is an alternative to breaking windows? and finally, 4.) Is it appropriate to police metropolitan areas using a quality of life approach? Why Using the Broken Windows Style Doesn't Always Produce the Best Outcomes There have been a number of points raised regarding the broken windows form of police, including the fact that the poor and people of the affected region who identify as minorities suffer when this kind of policing is applied. I concur with this statement because, according to Jefferson (2016) on page 1270, "broken windows policing has become a widely scrutinized phrase in the public lexicon, and is commonly attributed to the astonishing racial disparities in police brutality and arrests." It is causing trouble to grow rather than end. "May be partly explained by a summary of the social norms theory on which is based – that unfixed broken windows signal neighborhood disorder and, left uncorrected, such disorder gives way to more serious crime" (p. 166) is Davis (2017)'s explanation for the intricacy of broken windows policing. Disorderly behavior can include things like drunkenness in public, foul language, raucous behavior, graffiti, trash, abandoned buildings, retreating from society, and smashed
Broken Window Essay 3 windows. Disorder is primarily observed in communities populated by minorities and those with low socioeconomic status. Police mostly target these groups in broken windows policing because it is where the majority of unrest happens. According to Howell (2016), the goal of broken window policing is to keep public areas safe so that people feel at ease spending time there. Nonetheless, broken window enforcement “does make public spaces extremely dangerous for individuals who identify as black, LGBTQ, struggling with substance abuse, mentally ill, and homeless” (Howell, 2016, p. 1060). Every time they leave their houses, the majority of these folks feel some level of terror. They are afraid of the cops because they think they are crazy and will act aggressively toward them. Because there is no way out of the system once they are in it and a lengthy criminal record starts, they are afraid of the possibility of becoming the subject of a stop, summons, or even arrest for minor violations. Police violence and discrimination against poor and minority groups have resulted from this overpolicing approach and exacerbated racist police aggression. Most minorities and economically disadvantaged people are seen as disorderly people and become targets under this style of policing, according to Jefferson (2016), who claims that “city and police officials justify broken windows through 'us versus \them' scripts that identify the racialized poor as existential threats to predominantly White spaces of residence, leisure, and consumption” (p. 1279). Many of these people view broken window policing as a danger to their neighborhood. It appears to accentuate and perpetuate income and social inequality by favoring the wealthy and harming the poor (Howell, 2016). A number of protests have been sparked by this type of police. For instance, "Mass protests against broken window policing erupted at several of the city's most iconic sites in New York City after the city failed to try an officer who killed an unarmed 43-
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
  • Access to all documents
  • Unlimited textbook solutions
  • 24/7 expert homework help