Qualitative Study Appraisal Form
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
University of North Texas *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
6060
Subject
Industrial Engineering
Date
Feb 20, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
1
Uploaded by kenziebug0210
Qualitative Study Appraisal Form
Name:
__Mackenzie Puentez______ Is study part of a mixed-methods study: Yes Article Title: Using administrative data to uncover how often and why supervisory neglect happens: Implications for child maltreatment prevention
Author(s):
_ Rebeccah L. Sokol, Bryan G. Victor, E. Susana Mariscal, Joseph P. Ryan , Brian E. Perron
Aspect of Study
Appraisal Questions
Scale
Rating
Strategies for Rigor (Internal Validity)
Was the research approach (design) specified and rationale provided for its selection?
0 = not specified/not provided
1 = research design is specified and rationale for selection is provided
1
Was triangulation used as aspect of observation/data collection?
0 = not used
1 = used triangulation
0
Was member checking used?
0 = not used
1 = used member checking
1
Was prolonged engagement used?
0 = not used
1 = used prolonged engagement
0
Strategies for Rigor (External Validity)
Were criteria for sample selection and sample size applied (data saturation)?
0 = no sample selection criteria were used/specified
1 = sample selection criteria relevant to research were applied
2 = sample selection criteria & sample size were relevant to research & data saturation
2
Results
Was data analysis technique described?
0 = not described 1 = data analysis technique described
1
Was inter-observer agreement applied to analysis of the results?
0 = not applied 1 = inter-observer agreement applied and specifics provided
1
Was an audit trail described?
0 = not described 1 = described, but does not provide the specifics of what constituted the audit trail
2 = described with specific reference to transcripts of interviews, coding memos, and/or similar elements
2
Utility & Implications for Practice
Applicability of study results to your EBP topic:
a.
How similar is your EBP topic setting to the setting in the study?
b.
How similar is your EBP topic population
to the sample in the study?
0 = not at all similar; 1 = somewhat similar; 2
= mostly similar; 3 = similar
0
1
2
3
0
1
2
3
2
3
Scoring: Add up ratings from each row Total Score:
(16 points possible)
13
Adapted from Dr. Pam Yankeelov, Kent School of Social Work & Family Science, University of Louisville
Discover more documents: Sign up today!
Unlock a world of knowledge! Explore tailored content for a richer learning experience. Here's what you'll get:
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help