ACC4320 Week 5 D1
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Northeastern University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
100
Subject
Finance
Date
Feb 20, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
2
Uploaded by SuperHumanWillpowerHeron34
Which types of risk were present? List and discuss them.
What types of ratio calculations and analysis should have taken place to better predict Grant's demise?
Which ratios, in particular, were likely indicators of Grant's impending demise?
I think these are some of the evident risks present in the WT Grant case:
Credit Risk: Grant made it very simple to get credit, and the monthly repayment requirements were mainly just $1. The detrimental impacts of the easy-credit lure started to show
up in 1970. However, the corporation did not start to worry about the circumstance until after the
annual report for 1971, which exposed the credit issues. As a result, there was a consistent and large increase in write-offs of uncollectible credit balances. In the fiscal year 1972, uncollectable
increased from 2.1% to 3.2% (Jacob, n.d.).
Economic Risk: Rising interest rates during the 1974–1975 recession affected the economy as a whole. Although it should not impact big businesses like WT Grant, studies suggest otherwise. It's said that the recession was to blame for the business's weak approach to collecting from late-paying customers. Given that so many of Grant's clients appeared to be suffering from the recession, management made the decision not to seek delinquencies hoping that the economy would improve and these clients could catch back. Instead of discontinuing, Grant prolonged its typical time window. Thus, from 1972 to 1973, Grant's past-due accounts grew further significantly because of this slack strategy (Jacob, n.d.).
Sales Risk: From 1966 to 1975, sales volume per sq ft decreased by 33%. Earnings per dollar of sales for the corporation also fell, from 7 cents in 1969 to 2 cents in 1973. There were several indications of deteriorating health, even if the management of the company didn't seem to be fully aware of its true inventories and accounts receivable (Jacob, n.d.).
Bad Debt Risk: The earnings for the entire year had to be restated by Grant by the end of October: $177 million in losses, of which $92 million was deemed to be bad debt (Jacob, n.d.).
Operational risk: Grant's methods allowed the use of operational discretion with some limitations, such as inadequate inventory controls, poor credit controls, and hasty overexpansion.
This direction in decision-making appears to play a significant role in the internal development of the company's cash flow issues. Unfortunately, despite abundant evidence of managerial incompetence, the banking industry—which was highly represented on Grant's board—
continued to offer credit rather than adopt financially sound objectives (Jacob, n.d.).
Ratios and Analysis:
A detailed examination of the cash flows of the business would have shown approaching catastrophe up to 10 years earlier. The company's failure to create any internal cash flow over that decade was its most conspicuous feature. Investors should have immediately understood by looking at Grant's continuous inability to earn cash from operations (the stock was still selling despite this) (Largay & Stickney, 1980).
The profitability ratio, turnover ratio, and liquidity ratio of Grant had been declining throughout the ten years prior to bankruptcy (Largay & Stickney, 1980). This should have helped
expose some of their problems.
Liquidation Analysis: Grant should have done a close analysis of its liquidation and focused on long-term loans. According to Citibank's liquidation study, "the lenders would earn
68 cents per dollar." It proved "that the Grant liabilities were expected to outweigh its assets in liquidation." So, the banks were aware that if Grant was liquidated, they would not be repaid in full for their loans. So, a long-term solution was never what the banks had in mind. The loans' durations were too short for the severely struggling company to adequately repay payments (Jacob, n.d.).
Dividend Payout Ratio: high dividend payout rates increase the company's dependency on outside capital providers since significant amounts are transferred to investors. Thus, the stock is typically desirable to banks if it has a high payout rate. The crucial impact these rates
have on Grant's cash flow situation is more significant than appealing dividend rates to banks. This could have contributed to creating the firm's cash flow issues (Jacob, n.d.).
References:
Jacob, M. (n.d.). The Social Construction of Bankruptcy. Retrieved from https://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpressebooks/view?
docId=ft4x0nb2jj&chunk.id=d0e1075&toc.id=&brand=ucpress
on October 5, 2022. Largay, J. A., & Stickney, C. P. (1980). Cash Flows, Ratio Analysis, and the W.T. Grant Company Bankruptcy. Financial Analysts Journal, 36(4), 51–54. http://www.jstor.org/stable/4478363
Sheirndil, S. (2022). Week 3 Discussion Post # 1.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Related Documents
Related Questions
Now that Hurd has more specifically located the source of the economic exposure, Unit B, it is considering ways to hedge this exposure.
Since Unit B finances some of its operations, one idea being considered by Hurd management is a change the financial structure of Unit B to a mix of
financing in dollars and financing in pounds.
Note: Assume the interest rate on pounds is approximately equal to the interest rate on dollars.
Career Success Tips
ates, Unit B will need
revenue of Unit B.
TOTAL SCORE: 2/3
more
fewer
dollars for loan payments, which would partially offset the effect of this appreciation on the
Grade Final Step
arrow_forward
What are the major flaws with NPV? What are the major flaws with IRR? If you are going to a bank and trying to get a loan, which is the best method to use (NPV, IRR, Payback period)?
arrow_forward
Please help me.
Thankyou.
arrow_forward
could you please help with attached question?
arrow_forward
Please help with the below minicase.
Directions:
The best way to do this case is to use relevant credit information and calculate some financial ratios: ROA, debt ratio, liquidity ratios, ROE, profit margin, Inventory and Asset turnover. Then look at breakeven point probability, and finally the possibility of a repeat order.
What can you say about Miami Spice’s creditworthiness? What is the break-even probability of default? How is it affected by the delay before MS pays its bills? How should George Stamper’s decision be affected by the possibility of repeat orders?
MiniCase:
George Stamper a credit analyst with Micro-Encapsulators Corp. (MEC) needs to respond to an urgent email request from the southeast sales office. The local sales manager reported that she had an opportunity to clinch an order from Miami Spice (MS) for 50 encapulators at $10,000 each She added that she was particularly keen to secure this order since MS was likely to have a continuing need for 50 encapulators a…
arrow_forward
Please help with the below minicase.
Directions:
The best way to do this case is to use relevant credit information and calculate some financial ratios: ROA, debt ratio, liquidity ratios, ROE, profit margin, Inventory and Asset turnover. Then look at breakeven point probability, and finally the possibility of a repeat order.
What can you say about Miami Spice’s creditworthiness? What is the break-even probability of default? How is it affected by the delay before MS pays its bills? How should George Stamper’s decision be affected by the possibility of repeat orders?
MiniCase:
George Stamper a credit analyst with Micro-Encapsulators Corp. (MEC) needs to respond to an urgent email request from the southeast sales office. The local sales manager reported that she had an opportunity to clinch an order from Miami Spice (MS) for 50 encapulators at $10,000 each She added that she was particularly keen to secure this order since MS was likely to have a continuing need for 50 encapulators a…
arrow_forward
Which of these statements is true?
A)There is no reason to pay off a loan early
B) when shopping for a loan, you need to compare only APRs
C) the more you owe, the higher your interest payment will be
D) you can save money by making the smallest down payment the lender will allow
arrow_forward
Recently the M&M Company has been having problems. As a result, its financial situation has deteriorated. M&M approached the First National Bank for a badly needed loan, but the loan officer insisted that the current ratio (now 0.5) be improved to at least 0.8 before the bank would even consider granting the credit. Which of the following actions would do the most to improve the ratio in the short run? *
a. Using some cash to pay off some current liabilities
b. Collecting some of the current accounts receivable.
c. Paying off some long-term debt.
d. Purchasing additional inventory on credit (accounts payable)
arrow_forward
Which of the following statements (is) are TRUE about credit evaluation?
1. In terms of down payment, it follows that the higher the down payment, the higher will
be the risk.
II. The longer the term for the repayment period the more risky the transaction becomes
especially if the unit is exposed to heavy depreciation like taxi or logging transportation
III. In terms of the model in the sale of cars and trucks, there is a risk of product
obsolescence.
IV. The size of income is less important than the amount of money uncommitted to
existing bills.
O II and IV only
OI, Il and II only
O Il and IV only
O l and II only
O II, III and IV only
arrow_forward
I am currently working on a study guide and came across the following question.
Which of the following statements correctly reflects the effects of granting credit to customers?
a) total revenues may increase if both the quantity sold and the price per unit increase when credit is granted
b) a firm's cash cycle generally increases if credit is granted, all else equal
c) both the cost of default and the cost of discounts must be considered before granting credit
d) a firm may have to increase its borrowing if it decides to grant credit to its new customers
e) all of the above
My professor stated that the answer is all of the above, but after going through the readings and resources provided I could not find a way to understand how each answer is considered to be correct. I also e-mailed my professor and am waiting for a response, so I decided to post my question here as well.
arrow_forward
Consider the 2013 rejected loan data from LendingClub titled “DAA Chapter 1-2 Data”. To prepare the dataset for analysis, let’s scrub the risk score data. First, because our analysis requires risk scores, debt-to-income data, and employment length, we need to make sure each of them has valid data.
Open the file in Excel.
Sort the file based on risk score and remove those observations (the complete row or record) that have a missing score or a score of zero, if needed.
Assign each risk score to a risk score bucket similar to the chapter. That is, classify the sample according to this breakdown into excellent, very good, good, fair, poor, and very bad credit according to their credit score noted in Exhibit 1-13. Classify those with a score greater than 850 as “Excellent.” Consider using nested if–then statements to complete this. Or sort by risk score and manually input into appropriate risk score buckets.
Run a PivotTable analysis that shows the number of loans in each…
arrow_forward
How is your borrowing power affected when you are considered a "low risk"?
There is a good chance that you will receive better loan terms and low interest rates.
You might not qualify for a loan to buy a home, car, etc.
You will have to pay higher interest rates.
None of the above.
arrow_forward
In the credit market model with asymmetric information,
determine how a consumer will respond to an increase in the fraction of bad borrowers in the population. And discuss how the credit market model with asymmetric information shows how a financial crisis can reduce consumption.
arrow_forward
What is the advantage of a variable-interest loan?
Protects the borrower from rising interest rates
Borrower can capitalize on a reference rate decrease
Makes it easier for the borrower to plan for future
payments
Reduces the total interest payments
Which of the following tools is used to analyze the
industry attractiveness in the credit application process?
PESTEL analysis
Management analysis
Ratios analysis
SWOT analysis
arrow_forward
Avoiding Overdraft Fees. You know someone who recently had $90 in overdraft fees for two small debit card transactions. Explain to him why such high fees resulted from such small transactions and the relative benefits of having an automatic funds transfer agreement versus an automatic overdraft loan agreement versus overdraft protection.
arrow_forward
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5bbca/5bbca1eeabe7cf3682bcecbe715a4e75cdfe8a35" alt="Text book image"
Intermediate Financial Management (MindTap Course...
Finance
ISBN:9781337395083
Author:Eugene F. Brigham, Phillip R. Daves
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Related Questions
- Now that Hurd has more specifically located the source of the economic exposure, Unit B, it is considering ways to hedge this exposure. Since Unit B finances some of its operations, one idea being considered by Hurd management is a change the financial structure of Unit B to a mix of financing in dollars and financing in pounds. Note: Assume the interest rate on pounds is approximately equal to the interest rate on dollars. Career Success Tips ates, Unit B will need revenue of Unit B. TOTAL SCORE: 2/3 more fewer dollars for loan payments, which would partially offset the effect of this appreciation on the Grade Final Steparrow_forwardWhat are the major flaws with NPV? What are the major flaws with IRR? If you are going to a bank and trying to get a loan, which is the best method to use (NPV, IRR, Payback period)?arrow_forwardPlease help me. Thankyou.arrow_forward
- could you please help with attached question?arrow_forwardPlease help with the below minicase. Directions: The best way to do this case is to use relevant credit information and calculate some financial ratios: ROA, debt ratio, liquidity ratios, ROE, profit margin, Inventory and Asset turnover. Then look at breakeven point probability, and finally the possibility of a repeat order. What can you say about Miami Spice’s creditworthiness? What is the break-even probability of default? How is it affected by the delay before MS pays its bills? How should George Stamper’s decision be affected by the possibility of repeat orders? MiniCase: George Stamper a credit analyst with Micro-Encapsulators Corp. (MEC) needs to respond to an urgent email request from the southeast sales office. The local sales manager reported that she had an opportunity to clinch an order from Miami Spice (MS) for 50 encapulators at $10,000 each She added that she was particularly keen to secure this order since MS was likely to have a continuing need for 50 encapulators a…arrow_forwardPlease help with the below minicase. Directions: The best way to do this case is to use relevant credit information and calculate some financial ratios: ROA, debt ratio, liquidity ratios, ROE, profit margin, Inventory and Asset turnover. Then look at breakeven point probability, and finally the possibility of a repeat order. What can you say about Miami Spice’s creditworthiness? What is the break-even probability of default? How is it affected by the delay before MS pays its bills? How should George Stamper’s decision be affected by the possibility of repeat orders? MiniCase: George Stamper a credit analyst with Micro-Encapsulators Corp. (MEC) needs to respond to an urgent email request from the southeast sales office. The local sales manager reported that she had an opportunity to clinch an order from Miami Spice (MS) for 50 encapulators at $10,000 each She added that she was particularly keen to secure this order since MS was likely to have a continuing need for 50 encapulators a…arrow_forward
- Which of these statements is true? A)There is no reason to pay off a loan early B) when shopping for a loan, you need to compare only APRs C) the more you owe, the higher your interest payment will be D) you can save money by making the smallest down payment the lender will allowarrow_forwardRecently the M&M Company has been having problems. As a result, its financial situation has deteriorated. M&M approached the First National Bank for a badly needed loan, but the loan officer insisted that the current ratio (now 0.5) be improved to at least 0.8 before the bank would even consider granting the credit. Which of the following actions would do the most to improve the ratio in the short run? * a. Using some cash to pay off some current liabilities b. Collecting some of the current accounts receivable. c. Paying off some long-term debt. d. Purchasing additional inventory on credit (accounts payable)arrow_forwardWhich of the following statements (is) are TRUE about credit evaluation? 1. In terms of down payment, it follows that the higher the down payment, the higher will be the risk. II. The longer the term for the repayment period the more risky the transaction becomes especially if the unit is exposed to heavy depreciation like taxi or logging transportation III. In terms of the model in the sale of cars and trucks, there is a risk of product obsolescence. IV. The size of income is less important than the amount of money uncommitted to existing bills. O II and IV only OI, Il and II only O Il and IV only O l and II only O II, III and IV onlyarrow_forward
- I am currently working on a study guide and came across the following question. Which of the following statements correctly reflects the effects of granting credit to customers? a) total revenues may increase if both the quantity sold and the price per unit increase when credit is granted b) a firm's cash cycle generally increases if credit is granted, all else equal c) both the cost of default and the cost of discounts must be considered before granting credit d) a firm may have to increase its borrowing if it decides to grant credit to its new customers e) all of the above My professor stated that the answer is all of the above, but after going through the readings and resources provided I could not find a way to understand how each answer is considered to be correct. I also e-mailed my professor and am waiting for a response, so I decided to post my question here as well.arrow_forwardConsider the 2013 rejected loan data from LendingClub titled “DAA Chapter 1-2 Data”. To prepare the dataset for analysis, let’s scrub the risk score data. First, because our analysis requires risk scores, debt-to-income data, and employment length, we need to make sure each of them has valid data. Open the file in Excel. Sort the file based on risk score and remove those observations (the complete row or record) that have a missing score or a score of zero, if needed. Assign each risk score to a risk score bucket similar to the chapter. That is, classify the sample according to this breakdown into excellent, very good, good, fair, poor, and very bad credit according to their credit score noted in Exhibit 1-13. Classify those with a score greater than 850 as “Excellent.” Consider using nested if–then statements to complete this. Or sort by risk score and manually input into appropriate risk score buckets. Run a PivotTable analysis that shows the number of loans in each…arrow_forwardHow is your borrowing power affected when you are considered a "low risk"? There is a good chance that you will receive better loan terms and low interest rates. You might not qualify for a loan to buy a home, car, etc. You will have to pay higher interest rates. None of the above.arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
- Intermediate Financial Management (MindTap Course...FinanceISBN:9781337395083Author:Eugene F. Brigham, Phillip R. DavesPublisher:Cengage Learning
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5bbca/5bbca1eeabe7cf3682bcecbe715a4e75cdfe8a35" alt="Text book image"
Intermediate Financial Management (MindTap Course...
Finance
ISBN:9781337395083
Author:Eugene F. Brigham, Phillip R. Daves
Publisher:Cengage Learning