Case study for
docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Houston Community College *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
345
Subject
Finance
Date
Nov 24, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
7
Uploaded by LieutenantBatPerson731
1
Case study for "Pulling out of bankruptcy"
Students' Name
Institution
Instructor
Course
Date
2
Background
Since December 2002, when it filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, the UAL
Corporation, United Airlines' parent corporation, has been unable to operate normally. There
have been several obstacles for the firm in the two years since then, including severe competition
in a difficult economic climate, an underfunded pension plan of over $7.5 billion, and the
necessity to present a restructuring package that is acceptable to its creditors. As a response to
low-cost carriers like Southwest Airlines, JetBlue, and Frontier Airlines, UAL introduced a new
low-fare airline named Ted in February 2004. However, on June 17, 2004, the company's
restructuring plan failed when a request for government loan guarantees was denied by the Air
Transportation Stabilization Board (Bergstresser et al., 2005). A new business plan that is
acceptable to UAL's creditors must be developed soon if the airline is to emerge from
bankruptcy. The firm would need to make a decision about its pension plans: whether to keep
making payments or to stop making payments and try to renegotiate the pension's liabilities.
In addition, UAL was feeling the consequences of decreased air travel demand after the
terrorist events of September 11, 2001, as well as the rising cost of gasoline. It had to cancel
contracts for a number of planes, liquidate unused assets, and renegotiate worker pay to get the
bills down. An further major obstacle was UAL's pension fund, which had a deficit of $7.6
billion as of the end of 2003 and required contributions of $72 million by July 15, 2004 and
another $500 million by the end of the year.
Some tough choices have to be made quickly. Management's reform strategy was
rendered ineffective when the Air Transportation Stabilization Board denied UAL's request for
loan guarantees in June 2004. In order to compete with low-cost airlines, UAL introduced a new
3
low-fare carrier named Ted. Nonetheless, UAL still had pension fund problems and had to
determine whether to pay the necessary contributions or try to cancel its pension schemes.
Key Issues
When 2004 rolled around, UAL Corporation's biggest problem was getting the
corporation out of bankruptcy. Since its inception in December 2002, the firm has been operating
under Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection for almost 19 months (Bergstresser et al., 2005).
It was
necessary for the corporation to present a restructuring strategy that would be acceptable to the
firm's creditors while also addressing the firm's cost structure, competitiveness, and pension plan,
which was underfunded by more than $7.5 billion. The Air Transportation Stabilization Board's
government loan guarantees, which the business had previously rejected in June 2004, also
required a decision.
Company problems included a pension fund that was over $7.5 billion in the red. The
corporation had to make a decision between maintaining its current pension contribution levels
or stopping payments in an effort to restructure the pension's liabilities. UAL may have complied
with the law and made the needed payments, sought immediate termination of its pension
schemes, or continued discussions with its workers by not paying the required contributions.
The corporation also had to deal with the difficulty of introducing its new budget airline,
Ted, which was designed to go head-to-head with other low-cost carriers like Southwest, JetBlue,
and Frontier. Ted's successful introduction gave Tilton and UAL reason to believe that their
restructured airline could compete well (Bergstresser et al., 2005). Therefore, in 2004, the most
pressing concerns for UAL were how to start the new low-fare airline, Ted, and how to draft a
restructuring plan that creditors would approve.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
4
Risks
United Airlines (UAL) faces a wide variety of difficult risks as it emerges from
bankruptcy. The biggest threat to UAL's success is the possibility that it won't be able to
renegotiate labor contracts with its unions and get the salary and benefit reductions it needs to
lower costs and remain competitive in the airline sector. UAL cannot save enough money to stay
competitive and sustainable without these concessions.
The possibility of further increases in gasoline costs is another threat to UAL. Due to its
bankruptcy, UAL cannot access derivatives markets, making it unable to protect itself from rising
fuel prices by purchasing insurance.
UAL's pension liabilities might be a significant financial strain if certain assumptions
about future costs are incorrect. UAL must pay $72 million by July 15, 2004 and $500 million by
the end of the year to cover its unfunded pension liabilities of $7.6 billion. As a result of this
obligation, UAL may be forced to eliminate its pension programs, which would have devastating
effects on the company's current and former workers and retirees. Finally, UAL must deal with
the possibility that its creditors would reject its restructuring plan. If UAL's creditors don't agree
to the company's reorganization plan, the airline may be forced to file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy
and be liquidated.
Overall, UAL's endeavor to emerge from bankruptcy is fraught with many difficulties.
The possibility for fuel costs to rise, failure to reach an agreement on labor contracts, the
substantial financial weight of pension payments, and the possible rejection of the restructuring
plan by creditors are all factors that might affect the company's ability to go forward. UAL may
5
be compelled to file for Chapter 7 bankruptcy and dissolve if it is unable to address and mitigate
these threats.
Recommendation
Bankruptcy is likely to be a long and arduous procedure for UAL Corp. due to the
complexity of their current condition. The company's cost structure, competitiveness, and
pension liabilities must all be addressed for UAL to emerge from bankruptcy.
The first step for UAL to become more competitive in the airline sector is to renegotiate
its labor contracts with its unions and get the salary and benefit cutbacks needed to do so. In
order for UAL to survive in the face of rising competition, this is a necessary but challenging
step.
The second problem that needs fixing is UAL's unfunded pension commitments. UAL
has to put away $72 million by July 15, 2004 and another $500 million by the end of the year to
cover its $7.6 billion unfunded obligation. UAL may either comply with the law and pay the
necessary contributions, immediately seek to dissolve its pension schemes, or refuse to make the
necessary contributions and continue talks with its workers. UAL has to think carefully about all
of these alternatives to choose the one that will be best for the firm, its workers, and its creditors.
Third, UAL should keep pushing forward with the introduction of Ted, its new low-cost
airline meant to compete with Southwest Airlines, JetBlue, and Frontier Airlines. UAL has to do
everything it can to make sure the Ted launch goes well so that the firm can gain a competitive
advantage.
UAL must provide a plan for reorganization that will be approved by the airline's
creditors. If UAL's creditors don't agree with the company's planned reorganization, the airline
6
will have to make some tough choices. If this happens, UAL could have to file for Chapter 7
bankruptcy, which would be the end of the corporation.
UAL's cost structure, competitiveness, and pension commitments all need to be addressed
for the airline to effectively emerge from bankruptcy. UAL will need to adopt some tough
measures and take some risks if it wants to emerge from bankruptcy and keep competing in the
aviation market.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
7
References
Bergstresser, D., Froot, K. A., & Smart, D. R. (2005).
"UAL, 2004: Pulling Out of
Bankruptcy."
Harvard Business School Case 205-090.(Revised June 2006.)
Related Documents
Related Questions
Please help me to solve this problem
arrow_forward
Answer general Accounting question
arrow_forward
Peltzer Manufacturing is experiencing financial difficulties. Rather than entering into a lengthy bankruptcy proceeding, the company has reached an agreement with its long-term creditors to restructure various loans. The restructured loans are described below.Loan A—This 12% debt has a principal balance of $4,000,000 and accrued interest of $80,000. Under the restructuring agreement, $500,000 of debt would be forgiven, and the balance of the amounts due would be refinanced at a rate of 10% with monthly installment payments of $50,000 and a term of eight years. Assets with a net realizable value of $2,500,000 would also be pledged as additional security against the restructured loan.Loan B—This debt has a principal balance of $1,000,000 and accrued interest of $25,000. Under the restructuring agreement, the accrued interest would be forgiven, and the principal amount would be exchanged for preferred stock with a par value of $500,000 and a fair value of $900,000.Loan C—This 12% debt has…
arrow_forward
Your Question : Please introduction and correct and incorrect option explain!
arrow_forward
Provide Correct answer please
arrow_forward
Check my work
Shi Company is going through a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. All assets have been liquidated, and the company retains only $25,900 in
free cash. The following debts, totaling $41,550, remain:
Government claims to unpaid taxes
Salary during last month owed to Mr. Key
(not an officer)
Administrative expenses
Salary during last month owed to Ms. Rankin
(not an officer)
Unsecured accounts payable
$ 6,700
18,525
3,150
Fook
5,925
7,250
"rint
erences
Indicate how much money will be paid to the creditor associated with each debt.
Types of Debts
+
Amounts
Mc
Graw
Hill
MAY
dtv
SOUTARE
* F2
14 E7
F3
F4
FS
M5
23
2$
%
&
2
3
4
5
7
9
W
E
T.
Y
S
F
G
K
C
V
alt
mmand
command
option
V
arrow_forward
Dengar
arrow_forward
What are possible reasons for a company with $20 million worth of assets that files for chapter 7 bankruptcy and a secured creditor with claims of over $100 million and the building as a secuirty end up with nothing?
arrow_forward
Financial Difficulty: The “Going-Concern” Problem. Pitts Company has experienced significant financial difficulty. Current liabilities exceed current assets by $1 million, cash has decreased to $10,000, the interest on the long-term debt has not been paid, and a customer has brought a lawsuit against Pitts for $500,000 on a product liability claim. Significantquestions concerning the going-concern status of the company exist. The lawsuit and information about the going-concern status have been appropriately described in footnote 3 to the financial statements.Required:a. Draft AOW’s report, assuming that the auditors decide that an unmodified opinion instead of a disclaimer of opinion is appropriate in the circumstances.b. Draft AOW’s report, assuming that the auditors decide the uncertainties are so serious that they do not wish to express an opinion on Pitts’ financial statements
arrow_forward
Ataway Company has suffered severe financial difficulties and is considering filing a bankruptcy petition. It has the following assets and liabilities. The assets are stated at net realizable value.
Assets (pledged against debts of $74,000)
$
124,000
Assets (pledged against debts of $138,000)
54,000
Other assets
84,000
Liabilities with priority
76,400
Other unsecured creditors
204,000
In a liquidation, how much money would be paid on the partially secured debt?
arrow_forward
3
arrow_forward
Ataway Company has severe financial difficulties and is considering filing a bankruptcy petition. At this time, it has the
following assets and liabilities. The assets are stated at net realizable value.
Assets (pledged against debts of $76,000)
$128,000
Assets (pledged against debts of $142,000) 56,000
Other assets
Liabilities with priority
Other unsecured creditors
86,000
65,000
206,000
In a liquidation, how much money would be paid on the partially secured debt?
arrow_forward
Telstar Co. had severe financial difficulties and was considering the possibility of filing a bankruptcy petition. At that time, the company had the following assets (stated at net realizable value) and liabilities.
Assets (pledged against debts of $91,000) 150,800
Assets (pledged against debts of $169,000) 65,000
Other assets 104,000
Liabilities with priority 54,600
Unsecured creditors 60,000
A. Prepare a schedule to show the amount of total assets available to pay liabilities with priority and unsecured creditors
B. Prepare a schedule to show the amount of assets that are available for unsecured creditors after payment of liabilities with priority
C. Prepare a schedule to show the amount of total unsecured liabilities
D. Prepare a schedule…
arrow_forward
Saved
Shi Company is going through a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. All assets have been liquidated, and the company retains only $26,800 in free
cash. The following debts, totaling $46,050, remain:
Government claims to unpaid taxes
$ 7,600
Salary during last month owed to Mr. Key (not an officer)
Administrative expenses
19,425
4,050
Salary during last month owed to Ms. Rankin (not an officer)
Unsecured accounts payable
5,925
8,150
Required:
Indicate how much money will be paid to the creditor associated with each debt.
Types of Debts
Amounts
Administrative expenses
$
4,050
Salary during last month owed to Mr. Key and Ms. Rankin
$
25,350
Government claims to unpaid taxes
$
7,600
$
0
arrow_forward
as per given information provide required answer
arrow_forward
2.Chapter 11 When the Master Printing Company filed for bankruptcy, it filed under Chapter 11 of the U.S. bankruptcy code. Key information is shown here:
Assets
Claims
Mortgage bonds
$27,000
Senior debentures
12,100
Junior debentures
8,500
Going concern value
$37,500
Book equity
−10,100
As a trustee, what reorganization plan would you accept?
INTERMEDIATE(Questions 3–4)
3.Z-Score Fair-to-Midland Manufacturing, Inc. (FMM), has applied for a loan at True Credit Bank. Jon Fulkerson, the credit analyst at the bank, has gathered the following information from the company’s financial statements:
Total assets
$115,000
EBIT
7,900
Net working capital
4,100
Book value of equity
23,000
Accumulated retained earnings
19,600
Sales
112,000
The stock price of FMM is $31 per share and there are 7,800 shares outstanding. What is the Z-score for this company?
arrow_forward
Jaez Corporation is in the process of going through a reorganization. As of December 31, 2024, the company’s accountant has determined the following information although the company is still several months away from emerging from the bankruptcy proceeding.
Net Book Value
Fair Value
Assets
Cash
$ 31,000
$ 31,000
Inventory
53,000
55,000
Land
164,000
218,000
Buildings
228,000
268,000
Equipment
162,000
165,000
Allowed Claims
Expected Settlement
Liabilities as of the date of the order for relief
Accounts payable
$ 131,000
$ 28,000
Accrued expenses
38,000
12,000
Income taxes payable
30,000
26,000
Note payable (due 2027, secured by land)
108,000
108,000
Note payable (due 2029)
178,000
88,000
Liabilities since the date of the order for relief
Accounts payable
$ 68,000
Note payable (due 2026)
118,000
Stockholders' equity
Common stock
$ 208,000
Deficit
(241,000)
Required:
Prepare the balance sheet for Jaez…
arrow_forward
Problem 5-2. Notes payable and Debt restructuring
Hope Company is experiencing financial difficulties due to the impact of the Pandemic on its business. In recent years, the company was forced to scale down its business operations and retrench a significant part of its work force. Also, it negotiated restructuring some of its borrowings with its creditors.
The company was not able to pay the creditor as of 12/31/2022 and arranged restructuring with its creditors with the details as follows as of December 31, 2022:
Date
Principal & Terms
Status
Mode of settlement
1/1/2020
3-year, 1,000,000 mortgage note. 10% interest, payable annually.
Due immediately; only interest has been paid to date.
Transfer the land used as security to the creditor. Cost of land P900,000, fair value P1.5 million
1/1/2021
2-year, 500,000 note. Ordinary shares of entity held as collateral. 12% interest, payable annually.
Due immediately; Principal and interest for 2022 unpaid as of…
arrow_forward
Which of the following statements about WorldCom is true?
a. WorldCom filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2002.
b. They overreported the line costs by recording them as liabilities.
c. It began in 1999 as Long Distance Discount Services, Inc.
d. Five techniques were used to cook its books.
arrow_forward
Hi I need the answer Key to these Questions
arrow_forward
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Related Questions
- Please help me to solve this problemarrow_forwardAnswer general Accounting questionarrow_forwardPeltzer Manufacturing is experiencing financial difficulties. Rather than entering into a lengthy bankruptcy proceeding, the company has reached an agreement with its long-term creditors to restructure various loans. The restructured loans are described below.Loan A—This 12% debt has a principal balance of $4,000,000 and accrued interest of $80,000. Under the restructuring agreement, $500,000 of debt would be forgiven, and the balance of the amounts due would be refinanced at a rate of 10% with monthly installment payments of $50,000 and a term of eight years. Assets with a net realizable value of $2,500,000 would also be pledged as additional security against the restructured loan.Loan B—This debt has a principal balance of $1,000,000 and accrued interest of $25,000. Under the restructuring agreement, the accrued interest would be forgiven, and the principal amount would be exchanged for preferred stock with a par value of $500,000 and a fair value of $900,000.Loan C—This 12% debt has…arrow_forward
- Your Question : Please introduction and correct and incorrect option explain!arrow_forwardProvide Correct answer pleasearrow_forwardCheck my work Shi Company is going through a Chapter 7 bankruptcy. All assets have been liquidated, and the company retains only $25,900 in free cash. The following debts, totaling $41,550, remain: Government claims to unpaid taxes Salary during last month owed to Mr. Key (not an officer) Administrative expenses Salary during last month owed to Ms. Rankin (not an officer) Unsecured accounts payable $ 6,700 18,525 3,150 Fook 5,925 7,250 "rint erences Indicate how much money will be paid to the creditor associated with each debt. Types of Debts + Amounts Mc Graw Hill MAY dtv SOUTARE * F2 14 E7 F3 F4 FS M5 23 2$ % & 2 3 4 5 7 9 W E T. Y S F G K C V alt mmand command option Varrow_forward
- Dengararrow_forwardWhat are possible reasons for a company with $20 million worth of assets that files for chapter 7 bankruptcy and a secured creditor with claims of over $100 million and the building as a secuirty end up with nothing?arrow_forwardFinancial Difficulty: The “Going-Concern” Problem. Pitts Company has experienced significant financial difficulty. Current liabilities exceed current assets by $1 million, cash has decreased to $10,000, the interest on the long-term debt has not been paid, and a customer has brought a lawsuit against Pitts for $500,000 on a product liability claim. Significantquestions concerning the going-concern status of the company exist. The lawsuit and information about the going-concern status have been appropriately described in footnote 3 to the financial statements.Required:a. Draft AOW’s report, assuming that the auditors decide that an unmodified opinion instead of a disclaimer of opinion is appropriate in the circumstances.b. Draft AOW’s report, assuming that the auditors decide the uncertainties are so serious that they do not wish to express an opinion on Pitts’ financial statementsarrow_forward
- Ataway Company has suffered severe financial difficulties and is considering filing a bankruptcy petition. It has the following assets and liabilities. The assets are stated at net realizable value. Assets (pledged against debts of $74,000) $ 124,000 Assets (pledged against debts of $138,000) 54,000 Other assets 84,000 Liabilities with priority 76,400 Other unsecured creditors 204,000 In a liquidation, how much money would be paid on the partially secured debt?arrow_forward3arrow_forwardAtaway Company has severe financial difficulties and is considering filing a bankruptcy petition. At this time, it has the following assets and liabilities. The assets are stated at net realizable value. Assets (pledged against debts of $76,000) $128,000 Assets (pledged against debts of $142,000) 56,000 Other assets Liabilities with priority Other unsecured creditors 86,000 65,000 206,000 In a liquidation, how much money would be paid on the partially secured debt?arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you