3149 final
.docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
University of Ottawa *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
3149
Subject
Economics
Date
Apr 3, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
8
Uploaded by BarristerSkunk523
The Answer of PART A (question 1)
Introduction
Confronted with the exigent global dilemma of climate change, the world stands at a critical juncture that demands prompt and efficacious measures. The prevailing legal frameworks and regulatory mechanisms have proven ineffectual in engendering a tangible decline in carbon emissions. This report delineates a novel governmental initiative, encompassing both legislative measures and fiscal incentives, aimed at cultivating a more salubrious environment. It undertakes a meticulous examination of the prospective benefits and costs, juxtaposes them with the existing paradigm, and employs Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) to articulate a definitive stance.
Proposed Government Program
Laws:
Emission Caps: The imposition of rigorous constraints on industrial emissions, accompanied by punitive measures for transgressions.
Clean Energy Standards: The statutory obligation to derive a specified proportion of energy from renewable sources.
Incentives:
Tax Incentives for Clean Technology: Fiscal concessions to incentivize corporate and individual investment in environmentally benign energy solutions.
Grants for Research and Development: Allocation of funds to stimulate innovation in renewable energy and energy conservation technologies.
Subsidies for Public Transportation: Financial encouragement to augment the utilization of public transportation, thereby curtailing emissions.
Costs and Benefits Analysis
Assumptions:
The metamorphosis towards cleaner technology will transpire in a phased manner.
Alignment with international climate objectives through global collaboration.
The hypothetical costs and benefits are substantiated by empirical data where feasible.
Direct Costs:
Implementation and Compliance Costs: Expenditures incurred by businesses and governmental bodies in the execution and adherence to novel regulations.
Potential Impact on Traditional Energy Sector: Transient economic repercussions on industries reliant on fossil fuels.
Indirect Costs:
Potential Job Loss: The conceivable attrition of employment in specific sectors.
Short-term Economic Slowdown: Initial economic perturbations concomitant with the
transition.
Direct Benefits:
Reduction in Carbon Emissions: The realization of marked curtailments in greenhouse
gas emissions.
Health Improvements: The mitigation of pollution, culminating in enhanced public health.
Technological Advancement: The nurturing of innovation within the realm of clean technology.
Indirect Benefits:
Long-term Economic Opportunities: The genesis of novel industries and employment avenues within the clean energy domain.
Environmental Preservation: The safeguarding of ecosystems and diminution of climate-associated hazards.
Conclusion and Position Using CBA
The proposed initiative's multifaceted benefits, both immediate and ancillary, manifestly surpass the concomitant costs. While immediate economic apprehensions are not to be dismissed lightly, the enduring dividends in public health, technological innovation, environmental stewardship, and economic prospects are of paramount significance.
The contention that the transition towards an environmentally sustainable paradigm is prohibitively costly neglects the overarching societal dividends and the latent prospects for sustained economic vitality. The ramifications of inertia, encompassing the perpetual degradation of climate, health, and prospective economic turmoil, are inordinately more grievous.
Recommendation
The proposed governmental scheme embodies a judicious and indispensable strategy to confront climate change. By assiduously weighing the costs and benefits and leveraging the analytical tools of CBA, the commitment to a cleaner environment transcends mere ethical imperatives, resonating as an economically prudent course of action.
The audience, potentially skeptical, is exhorted to contemplate the holistic nature of this approach, its congruence with long-term societal aspirations, and the boundless potential for innovation and growth that this transformative shift heralds.
The answer of Part B (1456)
1.
How does the issue of efficiency play out in a cost-benefit analysis framework? Efficiency in CBA is about ensuring that resources are allocated in a way that maximizes the net social benefit. It involves identifying, measuring, and comparing the benefits and costs of a policy, project, or program, and quantifying them in monetary terms. The Net Social Benefit (NSB) is calculated to identify the increase or
decrease in welfare to society derived from alternative policies, programs, or projects.
If the social benefits are higher than the social costs, the project should be accepted. Efficiency also relates to opportunity costs, where the value of the next best alternative use is considered. In CBA, this would be the next best project. Allocative efficiency is where resources are utilized in their best use within the economy, and CBA helps in identifying relative allocative efficiency.
How does the issue compare between a public versus a private program?
Private Sector: CBA in the private sector formalizes the investment process to ensure precise decision-making. It allows firms to analyze wider impacts, including opportunities for commercial profitability (benefits) and risks to reputation or branding (costs). External effects that may be harmful or beneficial to a company are captured. Public Sector: Public sector CBA is more complex and considers a multitude of stakeholders. It allows governments to effectively allocate scarce resources and provides a transparent framework for decision-making. Public sector CBA often considers market failure and non-monetary impacts, making it more challenging than private sector CBA. Externalities and broader societal impacts are key considerations in public sector CBA. The key difference is that private sector CBA often focuses on financial gains and losses, while public sector CBA takes a broader view, considering social welfare, externalities, and the overall impact on society.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Related Questions
Overview: The US government is reviewing the topic of a cap-and-trade system for carbon emissions, and the Secretary of State (the Secretary) has been asked to weigh in on whether they should support the system or not. The Secretary has asked you to write a recommendation memo on the subject, recommending what side of the argument they should land. Instructions: • Familiarize yourself with what a cap-and-trade emission system is. • Research and locate data points on the subject that will help form your argument. This data point can be environmental, political, and/ or business-centric. • Create a recommendation memo using the assignment template with a recommendation of if the Secretary should be for or
arrow_forward
CH9: which of the following statements are true about ecological footprint?
The Earth has about 4.2 acres of sustainable productive land area per person,
but humans consume 7.1 acres worth of resources.
Since the 1970s, our economic growth has supported our increasing planetary
population with unsustainable methods.
Both A and B
ONeither A nor B
arrow_forward
Describe one type of negative market externality with a forest as it relates to climate change. Explain what the negative externality is and what it means for the market with no government intervention.
b)
Now describe two different ways the government could intervene in the market you described in the previous question. How does each government action change that market and what are those changes
c)
Identify two important ways that a natural resource economist can support the government interventions you have described in this question
arrow_forward
"Examine the economic impacts of
implementing a carbon tax as a policy
measure to combat climate change. Discuss
how a carbon tax might influence consumer
behavior, energy production, and
technological innovation. Additionally,
evaluate the potential effects on global trade
patterns and the distribution of income.
between different socioeconomic groups
within a country."
arrow_forward
What communication strategies would be most effective in conveying findings and recommendations to stakeholders? Select two strategies below and provide an explanation of why these are the best options.
Face-to-face interaction communicationPhone communicationWritten communication (letters, posters, memos, charts)Electronic communication (social networking, text messaging, chat websites)Email communicationWeb conferencing
arrow_forward
PLEASE HELP, PLEASE
A) Read up about the benefits of Global Citizenship Education in resolving environmental issues based on the THREE (3) domains of learning, namely cognitive, socio-emotional and behaviour.
arrow_forward
Describe the example given of the market-based “solution” to climate change thatexacerbated global uneven development. Did this program at least achieve its statedenvironmental goals?
arrow_forward
What Enviornment and climate change program has been initiated and implemented by the govenment of Pakistan for the fiscal year 2021-22? Explain.
arrow_forward
Some economists claim that grinding poverty and impatience impel people to strive for immediate gain,
forgetting long-term environmental sustainability. You are an Environmental Economist in the Ministry
of the Environment and Beautification in your local country, and you are tasked with holding a team
meeting and the Chief Economist has given the following guidelines:
II. two critiques (most recent) of the environmental Kuznets Curve.
III. the importance of inter-generational equity and optimal depletion with regards to
non-renewable resources.
arrow_forward
Identify a newspaper article that illustrates a market failure in your assignedCaribbean country. Ensure that you provide a screenshot of the article in your submission. NOTE: Only the following market failures should be examined: public good, asymmetric information, positive or negative externality.
(i) Provide a brief summary of the main points in the article. (Maximum 30 words)
(ii)Identify the type of market failure being discussed in the article and discuss why market failure occurs in this scenario.
(iii) Suggest a relevant government policy that would yield the efficient outcome andcarefully explain the process through which the implementation of the government policy will lead to the optimal outcome. (Maximum 30 words)
(iv) How will the imposition of the chosen government policy impact consumer surplus, producer surplus and total surplus in this scenario? (Maximum 30 words)
arrow_forward
(a) Explain what is meant by command-and-control in terms of a demand side climate
change policy. What are the pros and cons of this as a poliey option?
(b) Using a diagram, explain how a carbon tax could help reduce pollution.
(c) Using a diagram or diagrams, explain how a cap-and-trade scheme could result in
pollution reduction.
arrow_forward
Question #4: Natural resource policies and management practices often focus on addressing “spillover” effects of one person’s actions on other people. For example, we discussed how logging practices might impact the livelihood of salmon fishermen in the Pacific Northwest of the United States. A situation where logging results in erosion with consequential reduction in water quality and adverse effects on both recreational and commercial fishing. We have considered the issue of how one farmer’s use of water from the Ogallala aquifer effects other users of the aquifer. Property rights arrangements will dictate the extent to which these interactions persist and perhaps continue to degrade the resource, but so will the individual perceptions of the costs associated with the resource use. In many of these situations, the private costs diverge significantly from the social costs of resource use and extraction. In a well-organized essay, using material from class, describe how socially…
arrow_forward
The revenues from an emissions-charge approach to controlling climate change would be unusually large in comparison to other pollutants. What circumstances would lead to high revenues?
arrow_forward
The race to the bottom scenario of global environmental degradation is explained roughly like this:
Question 13 options:
Companies seek to reduce their costs of operations on plant and equipment design and this results in higher levels of pollution.
Companies seek the lowest market prices on products in order to gain market share, resulting in inferior goods and increased waste and pollution.
Profit-seeking multinational companies shift their production from countries with strong environmental standards to countries with weak standards, thus reducing their costs and increasing their profits.
Companies seek to influence environmental legislation standards are set to the lowest possible standards in the USA in order to maximize profits.
arrow_forward
Illustrate the potential economic and financial effects of climate change
arrow_forward
What do you understand by externalities? Why do they have to be addressed for sustaining economic activity or human wellbeing? A private or a market mediated approach to address externalities may not always be adequate in resolving the issue, therefore a recourse to public sector solutions is inevitable? Give suitable examples in elaborating your answer. With DIAGRAM (400-500 words)
arrow_forward
While the traditional approach of U.S. government policies for environmental protection has had some level of success, some economists propose
Group of answer choices
a range of policies stipulating set limits governing pollutant emissions.
stringent policies balancing industry profit goals and environmental quality.
stringent policies that will return the environment to its former pristine quality.
a range of more flexible, market-oriented pollution-control policies.
arrow_forward
Public-private partnership ("PPPs") can be an effective way to build and implement new infrastructure or to renovaate, operate, maintain or manage existing transport infrastructure facilities. In both areas PPPs can be a mutually beneficial way to solve critical transportation problems.
1. Evaluate the effectiveness of Public Private Partnership in Namibia with reference to any PPP project/programme of your choice (preferably in the transport sector).
arrow_forward
5) Suppose that an international agreement requires exporters to reduce their carbon emissions. In this context, government subsidies are provided to R&Ds that will enable green-friendly production in exporting industries that produce high-tech.a) Explain what might be the reasons for the implementation of such an activist policy.(Answer this question with the arguments of your main course book, (Krugman; Obstfeld; Melitz; 2015))b) Describe how the Environmental Kuznet curve works. Let's assume that there is a green-friendly technology transfer from developed countries to less developed countries in order to achieve the goal of a decrease in emission, then what will happen to the curve?
arrow_forward
5) Suppose that an international agreement requires exporters to reduce their carbon
emissions. In this context, government subsidies are provided to R&Ds that will enable
green-friendly production in exporting industries that produce high-tech.
a) Explain what might be the reasons for the implementation of such an activist policy.
(Answer this question with the arguments of your main course book, (Krugman;
Obstfeld; Melitz; 2015))
b) Describe how the Environmental Kuznet curve works. Let's assume that there is a
green-friendly technology transfer from developed countries to less developed
countries in order to achieve the goal of a decrease in emission, then what will
happen to the curve?
arrow_forward
Provide a brief introduction around strategic decision making and macro -environmental analysis.
arrow_forward
Identify a newspaper article that illustrates a market failure in the Caribbean country of Dominican republic. Ensure that you provide a screenshot of the article in your submission. The screenshot should include the name of the publication, date of publication and name of the article. NOTE: Only the following market failures should be examined: public good, asymmetric information, positive or negative externality. (i) Identify the type of market failure being discussed in the article and discuss why market failure occurs in this scenario. (ii) Suggest a relevant government policy that would yield the efficient outcome and carefully explain the process through which the implementation of the government policy will lead to the optimal outcome. (Maximum 30 words) (iii) Carefully explain how the imposition of the chosen government policy impact consumer surplus, producer surplus and total surplus in this scenario. (Maximum 30 words)
arrow_forward
Considering the elements in the external environment, it is correct to say that ______.
Question 37 options:
A)
All of these are true.
B)
the socio-cultural environment has become less important in recent years because of the increasing diversity of the population in Canada.
C)
the boundary between a company and the political-legal environment is more porous than the boundary between a company and the socio-cultural environment.
D)
The economic environment will affect the performance of almost every business.
E)
the political-legal environment is something that cannot be influenced by Canadian business firms.
arrow_forward
What do economists call the costs of climate change
imposed on the rest of the world by the production of a
product? tragedy of the commons an externality a carbon
tax a market failure
arrow_forward
In an attempt to bring equity to the climate change agreement, the Framework Convention on Climate Change incorporated the concept of common but differentiated responsibilities, which suggested what? Select all that apply:
a.
developing countries may need to hinder their growth in order to meet emission reduction goals
b.
responsibility for reducing emissions should be placed on large corporations rather than countries
c.
all countries should be responsible for the same percentage of emission reductions
d.
the richest countries of the world should cut emissions prior to developing countries
e.
countries that have contributed more to overall emissions should be responsible for more reductions
arrow_forward
1a) Water filtration removes contaminants that increase the risk of plant diseases from a farmer's water sources. As a result, there is a decreased risk of consumers suffering illnesses from consuming crops grown with filtered water. Due to this, economists might suggest that the use of water filtration systems in agriculture has an associated ________ externality?
1b) Draw the private cost, private benefit, social cost, and social benefit curves in the market for water filtration systems. If any of the curves are the same, label the curve as both.
1c) Is there market failure if the market runs freely? If so, is the socially optimal quantity of farmers using water filtration systems higher or lower than the market outcome?
1d) Provide a policy suggestion that would help to correct any market failures that arise due to this externality. Explain why this would be effective.
2a) Livestock and poultry farming are some of the largest contributors of ammonia emissions. Ammonia has been…
arrow_forward
a) Examine how the values of natural resources influence their management
b) Explain how non-renewable resources may be classified
arrow_forward
The climate policy toolkit has, to-date, mostly focused on demand side policies (i.e. policies that affect the pollution demand curve), some of which are ‘command-andcontrol’ and others are market based (e.g. cap-and-trade schemes, carbon taxes).
(a) Explain what is meant by command-and-control in terms of a demand side climate change policy. What are the pros and cons of this as a policy option? (b) Using a diagram, explain how a carbon tax could help reduce pollution.
arrow_forward
Most proponents of corporate environmental policy argue that the benefits of self-regulation far outweigh the impact of government regulatory frameworks in environmental management, particularly in the context of developing countries. Agree or disagree with this statement and justify your opinion in a four points
arrow_forward
1. Provide three reasons why it is important for environmental economists to adhere to a code of ethics, whether the code of ethics is formal (documented and sanctioned by an established group) or informal (simply a matter of thinking about what is right, possible spillover effects, and what advice would be appropriate)
2. Explain how environmental justice is related to decisions that governments make about how we use and/or protect environmental resources.
arrow_forward
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
![Text book image](https://www.bartleby.com/isbn_cover_images/9781305506893/9781305506893_smallCoverImage.gif)
Microeconomics: Private and Public Choice (MindTa...
Economics
ISBN:9781305506893
Author:James D. Gwartney, Richard L. Stroup, Russell S. Sobel, David A. Macpherson
Publisher:Cengage Learning
![Text book image](https://www.bartleby.com/isbn_cover_images/9781305506725/9781305506725_smallCoverImage.gif)
Economics: Private and Public Choice (MindTap Cou...
Economics
ISBN:9781305506725
Author:James D. Gwartney, Richard L. Stroup, Russell S. Sobel, David A. Macpherson
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Related Questions
- Overview: The US government is reviewing the topic of a cap-and-trade system for carbon emissions, and the Secretary of State (the Secretary) has been asked to weigh in on whether they should support the system or not. The Secretary has asked you to write a recommendation memo on the subject, recommending what side of the argument they should land. Instructions: • Familiarize yourself with what a cap-and-trade emission system is. • Research and locate data points on the subject that will help form your argument. This data point can be environmental, political, and/ or business-centric. • Create a recommendation memo using the assignment template with a recommendation of if the Secretary should be for orarrow_forwardCH9: which of the following statements are true about ecological footprint? The Earth has about 4.2 acres of sustainable productive land area per person, but humans consume 7.1 acres worth of resources. Since the 1970s, our economic growth has supported our increasing planetary population with unsustainable methods. Both A and B ONeither A nor Barrow_forwardDescribe one type of negative market externality with a forest as it relates to climate change. Explain what the negative externality is and what it means for the market with no government intervention. b) Now describe two different ways the government could intervene in the market you described in the previous question. How does each government action change that market and what are those changes c) Identify two important ways that a natural resource economist can support the government interventions you have described in this questionarrow_forward
- "Examine the economic impacts of implementing a carbon tax as a policy measure to combat climate change. Discuss how a carbon tax might influence consumer behavior, energy production, and technological innovation. Additionally, evaluate the potential effects on global trade patterns and the distribution of income. between different socioeconomic groups within a country."arrow_forwardWhat communication strategies would be most effective in conveying findings and recommendations to stakeholders? Select two strategies below and provide an explanation of why these are the best options. Face-to-face interaction communicationPhone communicationWritten communication (letters, posters, memos, charts)Electronic communication (social networking, text messaging, chat websites)Email communicationWeb conferencingarrow_forwardPLEASE HELP, PLEASE A) Read up about the benefits of Global Citizenship Education in resolving environmental issues based on the THREE (3) domains of learning, namely cognitive, socio-emotional and behaviour.arrow_forward
- Describe the example given of the market-based “solution” to climate change thatexacerbated global uneven development. Did this program at least achieve its statedenvironmental goals?arrow_forwardWhat Enviornment and climate change program has been initiated and implemented by the govenment of Pakistan for the fiscal year 2021-22? Explain.arrow_forwardSome economists claim that grinding poverty and impatience impel people to strive for immediate gain, forgetting long-term environmental sustainability. You are an Environmental Economist in the Ministry of the Environment and Beautification in your local country, and you are tasked with holding a team meeting and the Chief Economist has given the following guidelines: II. two critiques (most recent) of the environmental Kuznets Curve. III. the importance of inter-generational equity and optimal depletion with regards to non-renewable resources.arrow_forward
- Identify a newspaper article that illustrates a market failure in your assignedCaribbean country. Ensure that you provide a screenshot of the article in your submission. NOTE: Only the following market failures should be examined: public good, asymmetric information, positive or negative externality. (i) Provide a brief summary of the main points in the article. (Maximum 30 words) (ii)Identify the type of market failure being discussed in the article and discuss why market failure occurs in this scenario. (iii) Suggest a relevant government policy that would yield the efficient outcome andcarefully explain the process through which the implementation of the government policy will lead to the optimal outcome. (Maximum 30 words) (iv) How will the imposition of the chosen government policy impact consumer surplus, producer surplus and total surplus in this scenario? (Maximum 30 words)arrow_forward(a) Explain what is meant by command-and-control in terms of a demand side climate change policy. What are the pros and cons of this as a poliey option? (b) Using a diagram, explain how a carbon tax could help reduce pollution. (c) Using a diagram or diagrams, explain how a cap-and-trade scheme could result in pollution reduction.arrow_forwardQuestion #4: Natural resource policies and management practices often focus on addressing “spillover” effects of one person’s actions on other people. For example, we discussed how logging practices might impact the livelihood of salmon fishermen in the Pacific Northwest of the United States. A situation where logging results in erosion with consequential reduction in water quality and adverse effects on both recreational and commercial fishing. We have considered the issue of how one farmer’s use of water from the Ogallala aquifer effects other users of the aquifer. Property rights arrangements will dictate the extent to which these interactions persist and perhaps continue to degrade the resource, but so will the individual perceptions of the costs associated with the resource use. In many of these situations, the private costs diverge significantly from the social costs of resource use and extraction. In a well-organized essay, using material from class, describe how socially…arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
- Microeconomics: Private and Public Choice (MindTa...EconomicsISBN:9781305506893Author:James D. Gwartney, Richard L. Stroup, Russell S. Sobel, David A. MacphersonPublisher:Cengage LearningEconomics: Private and Public Choice (MindTap Cou...EconomicsISBN:9781305506725Author:James D. Gwartney, Richard L. Stroup, Russell S. Sobel, David A. MacphersonPublisher:Cengage Learning
![Text book image](https://www.bartleby.com/isbn_cover_images/9781305506893/9781305506893_smallCoverImage.gif)
Microeconomics: Private and Public Choice (MindTa...
Economics
ISBN:9781305506893
Author:James D. Gwartney, Richard L. Stroup, Russell S. Sobel, David A. Macpherson
Publisher:Cengage Learning
![Text book image](https://www.bartleby.com/isbn_cover_images/9781305506725/9781305506725_smallCoverImage.gif)
Economics: Private and Public Choice (MindTap Cou...
Economics
ISBN:9781305506725
Author:James D. Gwartney, Richard L. Stroup, Russell S. Sobel, David A. Macpherson
Publisher:Cengage Learning