Solution_PS6_BEPP 250_S16

docx

School

University of Pennsylvania *

*We aren’t endorsed by this school

Course

250

Subject

Economics

Date

Nov 24, 2024

Type

docx

Pages

6

Uploaded by blochjacob

Report
MANAGERIAL ECONOMICS - BEPP 250 SPRING 2016 PROBLEM SET 6 SOLUTIONS 1. Bruce has $100,000 in money. There is a 10% probability that Bruce will become ill, in which case, Bruce has to pay $50,000 for treatment. Bruce’s utility over wealth is given by U ( w ) = log ( w ) where log ( w ) is the natural logarithm function. a. Determine whether Bruce is risk averse, risk neutral, or risk loving. Answer: Note that U ' ( w ) = 1 w > 0 and U ' ' ( w ) = 1 w 2 < 0 The second order derivative is strictly negative. Bruce is risk averse. b. Without health insurance, what’s Bruce expected utility. Answer: Without health insurance, Bruce’s expected utility is EU No Ins = 0.9 log ( 100,000 ) + 0.1 log ( 50,000 ) = 11.4436 c. What is the most that Bruce is willing to pay for full coverage health insurance? Answer: If fully insured, Bruce’s expected utility is EU Ins = log ( 100,000 P ) where P is the insurance premium. We can determine Bruce’s willingness to pay by calculating the premium that would make Bruce indifferent between insurance and no insurance. log ( 100,000 P ) = 11.4436 Thus P = $ 6696.7 d. What is the actuarially fair insurance premium for full coverage insurance? 1
Answer: The actuarially fair premium is the amount of coverage multiplied by the probability of a loss, i.e. 0.1 50,000 = $ 5000 Suppose the only insurance available is for partial coverage with a $10,000 deductible and a $5,000 premium. e. How much profit does the insurer earn per policy? (Assume no administrative costs of providing coverage.) Answer: The insurer’s profit is given by 5000 ( 50000 10000 ) 0.1 = $ 1000 f. Should Bruce buy the partial coverage insurance? Answer: Bruce’s expected utility under the partial coverage insurance is EU = 0.9 log ( 100000 5000 ) + 0.1 log ( 100000 5000 10000 ) = 11.4505 This is still greater than the expected utility under no insurance, which we found in part (b). Thus, Bruce should buy the partial coverage insurance. 2. Jim owns a property in Minot, North Dakota. He is considering drilling and selling natural gas. However, he is uncertain about the amount of natural gas
under his property. With 50% chance, the land only conserves limited amount of natural gas, in which case, he can drill and sell for 2 years. With 50% chance, the amount of natural gas is good for 10 years. The revenue of selling natural gas is $2,000,000 per year. There is a fixed cost of $1,000,000 per year for labor. If Jim shuts down the business, he doesn’t need to pay the labor cost. In the first year, Jim needs to purchase drilling equipment that would cost him an additional $5,000,000. The following table summarizes the information. Year 1 Year 2 Year 3-10 Cost Revenue Cost Revenue Cost Revenue Low amount $6M $2M $1M $2M $1M 0 High amount $2M $2M $2M Assume Jim is risk-neutral and his discount factor is 1. a. Would Jim invest in the business of drilling and selling natural gas? Answer: Suppose Jim invests. If the land conserves high amount of natural gas, Jim’s revenue is $ 2 M 10 = $ 20 M and the cost is $ 1 M 10 + $ 5 M = $ 15 M . Then Jim’s profit is $ 20 M $ 15 M = $ 5 M . If the land conserves low amount of natural gas, Jim has the option to shut down the business starting from Year 3. His revenue is $ 2 M 2 = $ 4 M and his cost is $ 1 M 2 + $ 5 M = $ 7 M . Then Jim’s net profit is - $ 3 M . Since there is 50% chance of high amount and 50% chance of low amount, Jim’s expected profit is 0.5 $ 5 M + 0.5 ( $ 3 M ) = $ 1 M . Jim’s profit is positive if he invested in the first place. Thus, Jim would invest in the business of drilling and selling natural gas. Note that if Jim didn’t have the option to shut down if he learnt that the land conserves only low amount, he would have lost $ 4 M $ 15 M =− $ 11 M . In this case, investing in the first place would not be appealing as the expected profit is negative. For part (b)-(c), suppose the union requires that the labor contracts must last at least 5 years. In other words, if Jim hires workers for the project in the first year, he needs to pay the labor cost of $1,000,000 for at least 5 years. To be clear, in the event that his land conserves low amount of natural gas, Jim can only drill and sell for 2 years, but he still needs to pay the labor cost for Years 3-5.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
  • Access to all documents
  • Unlimited textbook solutions
  • 24/7 expert homework help
b. Would Jim invest? Answer: In this scenario, Jim’s profit is unchanged if the land has high amount of natural gas. But if the land only conserve low amount of natural gas, Jim would still need to pay the labor cost for Year 3-5, then, Jim’s cost is $ 1 M 5 + $ 5 M = $ 10 M and his profit would be $ 4 M $ 10 M =− $ 6 M . Jim’s expected profit is 0.5 $ 5 M + 0.5 ( $ 6 M ) =− $ 0.5 M . Thus, Jim would not invest as it yields a negative profit. c. Suppose that the North Dakota government is considering offering incentives to natural gas producers, which would boost Jim’s revenue by $ x in the year that Jim produces natural gas. What is the minimum x such that Jim would invest in this case? Answer: In this scenario, if the land has high amount of natural gas, Jim’s profit is $ 5 M + 10 x ; if the land only has low amount, Jim’s profit is $ 6 M + 2 x . Jim’s expected profit is 0.5 ( $ 5 M + 10 x ) + 0.5 ( $ 6 M + 2 x ) =− $ 0.5 M + 6 x . Solving $ 0.5 M + 6 x ≥ 0 , we get x≥$ 83,333 . The government needs to subsidize natural gas producers at least $83,333 such that Jim would invest.
3. The typical policyholder of Geiko auto insurance has a wealth of $100,000, of which $30,000 represents the value of his or her car. There are two risk types in the market for auto insurance: low-risk customers have a 1% chance that their car will be totaled; high-risk customers have a 3% chance that their car will be totaled. Assume that there is one customer of each type -- called the low-risk customer Larry and Henry for the high-risk customer. Suppose the risk of car being totaled is the only risk that Larry and Henry are concerned about. Each policyholder maximizes expected utility given by the following utility function U ( W ) = W 1 3 . As a monopoly in auto insurance, Geiko offers a full coverage insurance contract at a premium of P . a. What is Larry’s expected utility if he does NOT buy insurance? Answer: Larry’s expected utility if he does not buy insurance is EU Larry No Ins = 0.99 ( 100000 ) 1 3 + 0.01 ( 70000 ) 1 3 = 46.3639 b. What is Henry’s expected utility if he does NOT buy insurance? Answer: Henry’s expected utility if he does not buy insurance is EU Henry No Ins = 0.97 ( 100000 ) 1 3 + 0.03 ( 70000 ) 1 3 = 46.2598 c. If P = 1000 , who will buy the insurance? Answer: We can find Larry’s willingness to pay for the full coverage insurance by solving EU Larry No Ins =( 100000 P Larry ) 1 3 Thus, Larry’s willingness to pay is P Larry = 335.91 . Similarly, solving EU Henry No Ins =( 100000 P Henry ) 1 3 We obtain Henry’s willingness to pay for the full coverage insurance is P Henry = 1005.5 . Since only Henry’s willingness to pay exceeds the current insurance premium, Henry would buy the insurance and Larry would not. d. What is Geiko’s profit/loss by setting the premium at $1,000?
Answer: Since Geiko’s insurance can only attract high risk customers, there is a 3% chance that a car will be totaled. Geiko’s profit is $ 1,000 0.03 30,000 = $ 100 e. Find the price P that maximizes Geiko’s expected profit. Answer: If P≤ 335.91 , then both customers would buy the insurance. Geiko’s profit is 2 P ( 0.01 + 0.03 ) 30000 = 2 P 1200 528.18 < 0. If 335.91 < P≤ 1005.5 , then only high risk customer would buy the insurance. Geiko’s profit is P 0.03 30000 = P 900. If 1005.5 < P , no one would buy and Geiko’s profit is 0. Therefore, Geiko would set P = 1005.5 to maximize expected profit.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
  • Access to all documents
  • Unlimited textbook solutions
  • 24/7 expert homework help