Wk07-HR_Diagram_Intro_Worksheet
pdf
keyboard_arrow_up
School
University of Notre Dame *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
1107
Subject
Astronomy
Date
Jan 9, 2024
Type
Pages
8
Uploaded by savirkris
Astronomy 1101
The Hertzsprung-Russell Diagram
Laboratory Worksheet
One of the most fundamental physical properties of a star is its
luminosity
, the rate at
which it radiates energy into space as light.
Unfortunately, we cannot directly observe the luminosity of a star. What we can observe
is the
apparent brightness
(or just
brightness
for short) of the star, which is a
measurement of how bright it
appears
to us as seen from a distance here on the Earth.
The brightness of a star depends on its luminosity and its
distance
: if two stars have the
same luminosity, the more distant one appears fainter.
This is the same effect as seeing
two 100-watt light bulbs (which have same luminosity) at different distances — the one
across the street appears fainter than the one on the table next to you because light from
the distant bulb gets spread out over a much larger area before it reaches you.
To
estimate the luminosity of a star we must measure its brightness and its distance.
Distances to nearby stars are measured using their
parallaxes
.
The other fundamental observable property of a star is its
color
.
The color of a star
depends on the
temperature
of its surface.
Hotter stars have bluer colors and cooler
stars have redder colors.
The Sun has a surface temperature of ~6,000 Kelvin, and it
emits primarily pale-yellow light.
Astronomers typically describe color quantitatively as a
color index
, which gives the
ratio of the star’s brightness seen two different wavelengths (e.g., the ratio of red light to
blue light).
For purposes of this lab, you just need to know that the color index is a
number that lies between
−
0.5 and
+
2.5, and that red stars have a positive color index and
blue stars have a negative color index.
In other words, color index is a quantitative
measure of “redness.”
In this lab, you will first compute the luminosities of a few stars using their observed
brightness and distance.
You will then make and examine a Hertzsprung-Russell (or H-
R) Diagram, a plot of luminosity vs. color index. The H-R diagram is one of the primary
tools that astronomers use to understand the properties of stars.
The first versions of the
such diagrams were made by the Danish astronomer Ejnar Hertzsprung and the American
astronomer Henry Norris Russell around 1910.
Part 1: Distance, Brightness, and Luminosity
The relation between Distance (d), Brightness, and Luminosity is
Brightness = Luminosity ÷ (4
π
×
d
2
)
where
d
is the distance.
If you move a star 2 times farther away from you it will appear
to be 2
2
= 4 times fainter than before, but its total energy output (luminosity) stays the
same.
If we measure a star’s brightness and its distance, we can determine its luminosity
by reordering this equation:
Luminosity = Brightness
×
(4
π
×
d
2
)
The star Alpha Centauri (
α
Cen) is one of the closest stars to the Sun, at a distance of
d
= 4.37 light years = 4.13
×
10
16
meters.
The apparent brightness of
α
Cen is
Brightness = 2.71
×
10
−
8
watts/m
2
(watts per square meter).
1.
From the above equation, what is the luminosity of
α
Cen, in watts?
Luminosity of
α
Cen = 5.8 x 10^34
2.
What is the ratio of the luminosity of
α
Cen to the luminosity of the Sun, 3.828
×
10
26
watts?
(Luminosity of
α
Cen / Luminosity of Sun) =
1.5 x 10^8
If you did everything right, your answer to the last question should be about 1.5.
Now do the same calculation for:
Betelgeuse, the red star that is the left shoulder of the constellation Orion:
Brightness = 9.90
×
10
−
8
watts/m
2
Distance = 6.08
×
10
18
m
3.
(Luminosity of Betelgeuse / Luminosity of Sun) =
1.19 x 10^25
Rigel, the blue star that is the right knee of the constellation Orion:
Brightness = 5.68
×
10
−
8
watts/m
2
Distance = 8.02
×
10
18
m
4.
(Luminosity of Rigel / Luminosity of Sun) =
119931981
Sirius b, a faint blue star that is a binary companion to the bright star Sirius:
Brightness = 1.20
×
10
−
10
watts/m
2
Distance = 8.14
×
10
16
m
5.
(Luminosity of Sirius b / Luminosity of Sun) =
0.0211016517
Part 2: Making an H-R diagram
The table below lists the color index and luminosity of 50 stars, whose distances were
determined via parallax measurements using the Hipparcos satellite.
Luminosities are all
expressed in units of the Sun’s luminosity, i.e., an entry of 0.01 means that the star is
(1/100) of the solar luminosity (100 times less luminous than the Sun).
6.
Plot the positions of these 50 stars on the graph on the next page.
The stars with
the * next to them in the table have been plotted for you; check that you understand
their locations on the plot.
After you have finished the first ten stars, check your plot
with your lab partner to see that you agree.
Plotting these points will take some time
but watch for patterns as they emerge.
Color Index
Luminosity
Color Index
Luminosity
0.89
0.2*
−
0.08
77
1.02
8*
0.45
5
0.55
0.0002*
1.04
34
1.04
0.1*
1.36
0.05
1.02
0.15
0.80
18
0.74
0.3
0.61
4.6
1.10
0.1
1.14
0.1
0.50
8
0.89
27
1.42
0.08
1.62
0.0009
0.32
7.6
1.12
0.07
0.20
14
1.08
21
0.39
8.7
0.96
0.1
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
0.24
8.8
0.52
3.7
1.41
0.03
1.47
0.004
0.72
2.4
0.97
0.2
0.31
13
0.77
0.3
1.08
29
0.65
1
1.02
0.2
0.69
3
0.08
58
0.86
0.6
−
0.07
58
1.07
0.2
0.50
2
0.93
29
1.03
31
0.53
9.4
0.72
0.7
0.13
27
0.36
0.0003
0.96
0.2
0.18
0.0006
0.26
0.0006
7.
The color index of
α
Cen is 0.69.
Plot it on your graph and label it.
8.
The color index of Sirius b is
−
0.03.
Plot it on your graph and label it.
9.
Where do Rigel and Betelgeuse, from part 1, appear on this diagram?
They will appear at 4.59
10. Write down two things you notice about your handmade graph.
Each of your
observations or inferences should be written as a complete sentence:
A.
B.
Part 3 – Temperature, Area, and Luminosity
The luminosity (L) of a star depends on its temperature (T) and its radius (R) by
L = 4
π
R
2
σ
T
4
•
Where 4
π
and
σ
are numbers, not variables. Think of them like the ‘G’ in the
formula for the force due to gravity.
•
4
π
R
2
is the surface area of a sphere.
•
σ
T
4
is the amount of flux given off by a hot opaque object (a blackbody) per
surface area. You can just take this formula as given, it’s a basic result of
thermodynamics.
This equation tells us:
•
If two stars have the same temperature (same color index), the larger star is more
luminous.
•
If two stars have the same radius, the hotter (bluer) star is more luminous.
11. With this information in mind, label the four corners of the H-R diagram (the one on
which you plotted points by hand) to indicate where you find the stars corresponding
to the list below.
•
hot and large radius -
top left
•
hot and small radius - middle left
•
cool and large radius - top right
•
cool and small radius - middle right
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
12. Based on the H-R diagram, what do you think is the approximate color index of the
Sun?
Explain your answer in a complete sentence.
I think that the sun will be in the middle with t the average
13. On your hand-plotted H-R diagram, mark and label (A, B, C) the location of a
hypothetical star that is
A.
the same luminosity as the Sun but has a cooler surface temperature
B.
the same temperature as the Sun but has a larger radius
C.
the same luminosity as the Sun but has a smaller radius
Part 4: Making sense of the H-R diagram
The next graph has 1500 stars on it instead of 50, so that you can see more details.
Spend
a few minutes discussing this plot with your lab partner.
14. Write down 2 more qualitative observations or inferences about things you and your
partner notice in the H-R diagram. Part 3 may help you make new deductions. Each
of these observations should be expressed as a complete sentence.
A. We can see the shape at the H-R
B. It has an even amount of outliers
Part 5: Spectral Lines
We use light to measure all sorts of things about astronomical objects and the
“spectrum” of an object is a basic way to look at its light. In this part of the lab, you will
draw a spectrum based on more observations of the arc lamps with your spectrometer
tool, your diffraction glasses.
Compare 3 different spectral tubes of the elements Hydrogen, Helium, and Neon wearing
your diffraction glasses.
A.
Describe in a sentence or two what you see when observing Hydrogen.
I see a more red, orange and darker colors involved.
B.
Compare in a sentence or two what you see comparing Hydrogen to the other two
elements.
That the other element, are more compatible since they have more electrons. The more
electrons the more color.
C.
Knowing what you know already from this course, what color(s) would you
expect to see when you look out into the Universe and see hot gasses? In addition,
write 2-3 sentences about why spectra are important to understanding the space
and the objects around us.
Spectra allows us to identify what kinds of elements, exist around us. It allows us to tell if
a planet with a star can Bring about life. The color will be more red and orange and dark
colors as it totals more helium and other elements.