Briefly explain ONE specific historical difference between Richards’s and Nunn and Qian’s interpretations

icon
Related questions
Question

a. Briefly explain ONE specific historical difference between Richards’s and Nunn and Qian’s interpretations. 

"The Columbian connection had a devastating effect
on the indigenous human societies of the Americas....
New disease vectors suddenly introduced into the
vulnerable populations of the New World began a
sequence of horrific pandemics. Rapidly spreading
infectious disease devastated indigenous peoples of
the New World. It thinned their numbers, destroyed
their institutions, and broke their resistance to Spanish
aggression.... Demographic recovery after major
pandemics was hindered by reduced fertility,
stillbirths, and other physical effects, as well as by
cultural depression, hopelessness, and malaise
resulting from Spanish colonial domination."
- John R. Richards, The Unending Frontier, 2006
"The New World provided soils that were very
suitable for the cultivation of a variety of Old World
products, . . . The increased supply lowered the prices
of these products significantly, making them
affordable to the general population for the first time
in history. The production of these products also
resulted in large in flows of profits back to Europe,
which some have argued fueled the Industrial
Revolution and the rise of Europe. The Old World
gained access to new crops that were widely
adopted.... The improvement in agricultural
productivity... had significant effects on historic
population growth and urbanization."
- Nathan Nunn and Nancy Qian, "The Columbian
Exchange," 2010
Transcribed Image Text:"The Columbian connection had a devastating effect on the indigenous human societies of the Americas.... New disease vectors suddenly introduced into the vulnerable populations of the New World began a sequence of horrific pandemics. Rapidly spreading infectious disease devastated indigenous peoples of the New World. It thinned their numbers, destroyed their institutions, and broke their resistance to Spanish aggression.... Demographic recovery after major pandemics was hindered by reduced fertility, stillbirths, and other physical effects, as well as by cultural depression, hopelessness, and malaise resulting from Spanish colonial domination." - John R. Richards, The Unending Frontier, 2006 "The New World provided soils that were very suitable for the cultivation of a variety of Old World products, . . . The increased supply lowered the prices of these products significantly, making them affordable to the general population for the first time in history. The production of these products also resulted in large in flows of profits back to Europe, which some have argued fueled the Industrial Revolution and the rise of Europe. The Old World gained access to new crops that were widely adopted.... The improvement in agricultural productivity... had significant effects on historic population growth and urbanization." - Nathan Nunn and Nancy Qian, "The Columbian Exchange," 2010
Expert Solution
steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer