Article Review 2

docx

School

Liberty University *

*We aren’t endorsed by this school

Course

506

Subject

Religion

Date

Feb 20, 2024

Type

docx

Pages

Uploaded by axes1977

Running head: REVIEW: DEVELOPING A SPIRITUAL ASSESSMENT TOOLBOX 1 Article Review of: "Developing a Spiritual Assessment Toolbox: A discussion of the Strengths and Limitations of Five Different Assessment Methods" Richard J. Dill Liberty University

REVIEW: DEVELOPING A SPIRITUAL ASSESSMENT TOOLBOX 2 Article Review of: "Developing a Spiritual Assessment Toolbox: A discussion of the Strengths and Limitations of Five Different Assessment Methods" For our week five module assignment we were instructed to choose an article to read and review. The article that I chose as my review article is an article by David R. Hodge (2005) titled "Developing a Spiritual Assessment Toolbox: A discussion of the Strengths and Limitations of Five Different Assessment Methods". In this review content will be thoroughly discussed during which a summary of the article would be given, my individual interaction to the content, and an example of how the article contents can be applied in a counseling situation. Client assessments are an important part of counseling methods that allow the counselor to monitor and track certain aspects of a client’s well-being. Monitoring a client’s well-being through such assessments can provide a plethora of important information crucial to proper treatment of a client. Hodge (2005) states that “Assessment provides a method of identifying spiritual assets that can be operationalized in treatment and discharge planning” (p. 314). In his (2005) article Dr. Hodge outlines five different assessment methods and elaborates on both strengths and weaknesses of each. Summary Hodges (2005) article is based on five different assessment models that can be utilized in a way that will help a counselor to understand what kind of spiritual worldview and culture that their client may have. Dr. Hodge notes that “Hindus, evangelical Christians, Muslims, Mormons, Pentecostal Christians, and orthodox Jews are all examples of populations who have developed distinct culture” (2005, p. 314). He further notes that the Joint Commission of Healthcare Organizations recommends spiritual assessment be conducted and that a client’s spirituality should be assessed to determine their denomination.

REVIEW: DEVELOPING A SPIRITUAL ASSESSMENT TOOLBOX 3 The five assessment methods that Hodge (2005) chose to elaborate on in his article are (1) spiritual histories, (2) spiritual life maps, (3) spiritual genograms, (4) spiritual ecomaps, and (5) spiritual ecograms. Hodge (2005) points out two goals of assessments and those are first to identify the effect of client spirituality and second is to establish whether or not a more comprehensive spiritual assessment will be needed. In his article Dr. Hodge also gives both strengths and weaknesses of each of these types of assessments which will be summarized in the following paragraphs. Spiritual Histories Hodge (2005) notes that spiritual histories assessments done orally are the most common type of assessment. This type of assessment is done with two question sets. The purpose of these sets of questions is to first allow the counselor to gain additional knowledge about the client that can be utilized in a manner to help the client tell their story. This first set of questions is referred to as the Initial Narrative Framework. The second set of questions known as the Interpretive Anthropological Frameworks is utilized in a manor to gain perspective on a client’s spirituality. Dr. Hodge points out that strengths to spiritual histories is that it works well with clients who like verbal communicative methods, and that they can be easily conducted in a manner that builds a good relationship with a client. Dr. Hodge also points out limitations of spiritual histories is that the focus may be less on current issues that the client are dealing with and that not all clients are comfortable with being verbal with personal issues. Spiritual Life maps Spiritual life maps, as stated by Hodge (2005) are less verbal and utilize drawings to for a sort of map of a clients’ spiritual life which would also depict their relationship with God. Typically, it is requested that a client include and spiritually significant events in the map, as

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help

REVIEW: DEVELOPING A SPIRITUAL ASSESSMENT TOOLBOX 4 well as various struggles they may have faced. According to Dr. Hodge, some strengths of spiritual life maps are that they are client directed, have less risk in damaging client/counselor relationships, and it also helps the counselor to gain a much better perspective of the client’s worldview. Weaknesses mention by Hodge (2005) are that clients may not like to dray and would like to be more verbal, and the fact that the counselor can feel removed from the assessment process at times. Spiritual Genograms Hodge (2005) makes the point that spiritual genograms provide the counselor with a graphic of client spirituality over as many as three generations giving both the client and counselor an understanding of what role spirituality has played in client family history. Some strengths that are mentioned by Dr. Hodge are that spiritual genograms do a great job of effectively bringing spirituality into a client’s treatment plan and also family problems can often be effectively addressed through this assessment. Two of the weaknesses that Hodge (2005) notes are that these types of assessments can be lengthy and time consuming and not all clients connect with or relate to past family history and struggles so a client may find that there would be better use of their time in other assessment methods. Spiritual Ecomaps Spiritual ecomaps allow the client and counselor to “Focus on clients’ current spiritual relationships” and “focuses on that portion of the clients’ spiritual story that exists in present space” (Hodge, 2005 p. 319). Dr. Hodge also notes that with spiritual ecomaps a line is drawn between family and spiritual systems a client may have in place. Strengths include that a spiritual ecomap can be quickly and easily constructed while focusing on a clients’ spiritual strength and also can serve as the main topic of discussion (Hodge, 2005). Weaknesses that Dr. Hodge

REVIEW: DEVELOPING A SPIRITUAL ASSESSMENT TOOLBOX 5 mentions are that ecomaps focus mainly on client systems and not necessarily on the client themselves. Spiritual ecomaps limit the client speaking to the point where a client may feel that it is less appealing to them. Spiritual Ecograms The final assessment included in Dr. Hodges list of five is spiritual ecograms. Hodge (2005) notes that spiritual ecograms are a collaboration between spiritual ecomaps and genograms which utilizes current space and also information that spans over a period of time and establishes connections between past and present situations. In this type of assessment relationships and their nature are connected with systems by drawing lines (Hodge, 2005). One important strength of a spiritual ecogram is that it is able to “illustrate current and historical resources” (Hodge, 2005 p. 322). Weaknesses include the fact that spiritual ecograms are more complex and more of a simple method is often times preferred by the counselor. Finally Dr. Hodge’s strong conclusion notes that 40% of clients feel that spirituality is an important part of their lives and keeps them going as a coping mechanism so assessment is important. Dr. Hodge also points out that although he has discussed these five assessments that other assessment methods exist and may be more appropriately utilized at times and that no one assessment would be ideal in all cases. Interaction When I first read the title to this article I knew that it would be something that I would find useful. I feel strongly that client assessments are important to establishing where they are and how they feel toward certain aspects of their lives. Assessing their worldview is as important as assessing their spirituality. Upon completing this article I found a significant amount of useful information that I did not know about before.

REVIEW: DEVELOPING A SPIRITUAL ASSESSMENT TOOLBOX 6 First, I would have never have thought that having an adult client draw graphs, or maps would properly assess how they felt about relationships with God, spirituality or past family history. I thought the best assessment would be verbal or having the client answer questions on paper. Second I liked how the article gave strengths and weaknesses to all five assessment types which I would not have established on my own. The author was not biased toward any one particular assessment method. In fact, the author noted that there are other methods not mentioned in his article that could be considered more appropriate. One thing I felt the article lacked was how to get to the point of which assessment to use. For example, should you ask the client which method they would prefer or should the counselor choose the method they feel would be best for the client. The article mentioned that some clients are more verbal than others, some are not as artistic as another, and that some are more time consuming assessments so they are less preferred. So would a counselor determine the exact assessment that can be used most effectively without wasting client time? I know the article was not designed to be a step by step manual on these five assessment methods but I feel that more information could have been provided. I wished there were some sort of statistics included as to rank of methods used. Also some demographic statistics would also be useful. For example which assessment is most useful among certain age groups? Would those with a post-modern worldview prefer a different assessment method than those with a modern worldview? I am sure that this is information that would have to be compiled over time but it would be useful to know for further study on assessment methods. Application

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help

REVIEW: DEVELOPING A SPIRITUAL ASSESSMENT TOOLBOX 7 For the application section of this review I chose a client who is female that I will refer to as Aaliyah. Aaliyah recently converted to Christianity from the Muslim faith. Her family is currently and has always been predominantly Muslim and she is struggling because her family does not condone her newly found relationship with God. She is struggling in her faith because of doctrine that she was taught her whole life which conflicts with her newfound faith. She has requested counseling because at times she feels overwhelmed trying to make sense of it all, feels as though she has let her family down, and sometimes questions whether or not she would be better off without the stresses of religion. In this type of situation I feel a spiritual assessment is not only warranted by extremely important. In her first session it was noted that Aaliyah seems very timid and is a quiet individual who struggles to say what is on her mind and what is bothering her. In most cases she will not speak unless she is asked to do so. For her specific case I would start by utilizing a spiritual life map assessment. I would want to assess what areas are most important to the client at this point in her life but also to understand her worldview and spiritual family history. Aaliyah is not a verbal person in general so one of the weaknesses that Dr. Hodge mentioned would not apply to her. Aaliyah would more than likely feel more comfortable spending more time in a quiet environment where she could take what time she needs to express how she feels. Another weakness that Dr. Hodge mentioned was that counselors at times can feel removed from the process, however in this case it may be best for the counselor to observe and take additional time allowing the session and assessment to be more client directed. I do not feel in this case that it would be making poor use of therapeutic time. Finally this assessment would allow me as the counselor to build rapport and a strong client/counselor relationship with a client whose family faith may consider it a bad thing to seek council from those outside of their faith.

REVIEW: DEVELOPING A SPIRITUAL ASSESSMENT TOOLBOX 8 I did not find anything in the ACA code of ethics that would prohibit such an assessment with a client. If the client came for spiritual based counseling and signed and informed consent the client would be well within their legal and ethical boundaries to perform any of the five assessment that Dr. Hodge wrote about. As long as the counselor recognizes when a different method may be more appropriate and adheres to such a method, they will be keeping the clients well-being as their main priority.

REVIEW: DEVELOPING A SPIRITUAL ASSESSMENT TOOLBOX 9 References Hodge, D. R. (2005). Developing a Spiritual Assessment Toolbox: A Discussion of the Strengths and Limitations of Five Different Assessment Methods. Health & Social Work, 30 (4), 314–323. doi: 10.1093/hsw/30.4.314

Your preview ends here

Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version

Access to all documents
Unlimited textbook solutions
24/7 expert homework help

Article Review 2

Related Documents