Case analysis Microsoft's acquisition of Skype
pdf
keyboard_arrow_up
School
San Jose State University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
187
Subject
Finance
Date
Jan 9, 2024
Type
Pages
2
Uploaded by ConstableStarling3854
Case analysis: Microsoft's acquisition of Skype
1.
What were the benefits to Microsoft's shareholders of using cash held overseas to
purchase Skype?
Utilizing foreign funds decreases the impact of the high valuation. It is tax-efficient to use
foreign funds and foreign subsidiaries that hold cash abroad have low corporate tax rates.
Under US Law, Microsoft is exempt from paying taxes on profits that are permanently reinvested
outside of the United States. Given that foreign tax is about 4% and the corporate tax rate in the
nation is 35%, Microsoft saves 31% on taxes.
2.
Microsoft's effective tax rate on foreign earnings retained overseas appears was only 4
percent at the time of the case. How was this possible given that the corporate tax rate
in most developed nations where Microsoft earns profits from foreign sales are
considerably higher?
Microsoft claimed that the 4% decrease to 31% would be the result of foreign tax credits the
business had paid on its foreign earnings. Microsoft does not pay taxes on those who earn
money until they are repatriated to the US, even though the actual tax rate in the United States
is 35%.
3.
Why did Microsoft hold so much cash overseas, rather than returning it to the United
States? What do you think are the opportunity costs of holding tens of billions of
dollars in cash in foreign locations? What potential benefits might accrue to Microsoft
shareholders if it returned some of that cash to the United States?
Microsoft has 3 main reasons for holding so much cash overseas: transactional, preventive, and
tax. The money earned does nothing but sit around and earn very little interest. Since the
management of the corporation has the final say over dividend payments, there won't be as
much money available for reinvestment and business expansion if the company pays out huge
dividends.
4.
Do you think it is ethical for companies like Microsoft to continue to hold cash
overseas in order to avoid paying U.S. corporate income taxes? Is this practice always
in the best interests of the company's shareholders?
Microsoft is avoiding taxes and not evading taxes. It is lawful to retain investment gains abroad
if the condition for investors is better in a foreign country. Ultimately, when Microsoft benefits,
the company’s shareholders benefit as well.
5.
In January 2018, a change in U.S. tax law (a) lowered the top tax rate on U.S. corporate
income from 35 percent to 21 percent, and (b) established a policy that corporate
earnings should only be taxed where they are earned. How do you think this impacted
Microsoft's tax minimization strategies?
The change in US tax law in January 2018 would weaken Microsoft’s tax minimization strategies.
Microsoft would lose its advantage in saving taxes since the corporation would have to pay
foreign taxes as well. Also, the decrease in US tax might motivate Microsoft to return portions of
the cash back to the States.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Related Documents
Related Questions
Tax avoidance vs. tax evasion = Over time, these concepts have become somewhat blurred.
Define tax avoidance
Define tax evasion
Companies like Apple, Starbucks, etc. have enlisted the aid of CPA and law firms to assist them in minimizing their worldwide taxes. Afterwards, it was discovered that such companies had an effective tax rate of 5 - 10% for US tax, well below the 21% tax rate. There are numerous articles detailing what these companies did to achieve such low tax rates. Summarize what one of these companies did to achieve such a low effective federal tax rate.
Were such actions legal?
If so, why did the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) and various countries propose new tax rules?
Please respond to all questions above.
arrow_forward
Because of political instability in North Africa, let’s not disclose specific countries. In addition, we restructured most of our French sales and some of our U.S. sales to occur through our offices in the Cayman Islands.This allows us to avoid paying higher taxes in those countries. The Cayman Islands has a 0% corporate incometax rate. We don’t want to highlight our ability to shift profits to avoid taxes.Required:Do you perceive an ethical dilemma? What would be the likely impact of following the controller’s suggestions?Who would benefit? Who would be injured?
arrow_forward
Suppose InBev Corporation (a non-U.S. MNC) buys Anheuser-Busch Corporation (a U.S. corporation) by paying the U.S. shareholders in cash. Which of the following can be said of the US capital account?
Group of answer choices
The acquisition of cash by US shareholders will decrease foreign ownership, which will be recorded as a debit.
The US federal reserve will increase its currency reserves.
InBev's reduction in cash will be recorded as a debit on the U.S. capital account..
InBev's increased ownership of US assets is recorded as a credit.
U.S. shareholders increased ownership in InBev will be recorded as a credit.
arrow_forward
Multinational corporations are exposed to higher risks that primarily come from two significant sources: (1) exchange rate risk and (2) political or
country risk.
An example of
would be having property expropriated without adequate compensation.
Which of the following are steps a company can take to reduce potential loss from expropriation? Check all that apply.
Finance the subsidiary with local capital which reduces the local government's incentive to expropriate the multinational company's
property.
O Lock in the dollar return by selling currency in the forward market.
Structure operations so that the subsidiary is only valuable as a part of the integrated corporate system. This reduces the risk exposure
for the integrated company.
arrow_forward
Consider a US-based MNC with a wholly owned Italian subsidiary. Following a depreciation of the dollar against the euro, which of the following conclusions are correct?
Group of answer choices
a. The cash flow in euros could be altered due a change in the firm's competitive position in the marketplace.
b. A given operating cash flow in euros will be converted to a higher US dollar cash flow.
c. Both A and B
d. None of the above
arrow_forward
A simple solution to the problem of high corporate tax rates on investment incomewould be to apply a different, lower corporate tax rate directly to this type of income.Instead, the Canadian tax system uses refundable taxes to lower the rate of taxationon investment income of CCPCs.
Why?
Lower rates would provide a significant deferral of taxes on investment income.
refundable taxes encourage early filing of corporate tax returns.
lower rates would create a situation where the payment of dividends to shareholders would result in double taxation
refundable taxes provide a reason to retain funds in the corporation.
arrow_forward
Shera Corporation has extensive liabilities denominated in pounds resulting from imports from UK. However, Shera's revenues are denominated solely in U.S. dollars. Which of the following is probably not true?
A. Shera would benefit from a depreciation of the British pound.
B. Shera has at least some economic exposure.
C. All of the options are true.
D. Shera has at least some transaction exposure.
E. Shera has at least some translation exposure.
arrow_forward
2. "It is not fair that multinational groups can plan their way out of a tax charge in Tanzania whereas Tanzanian
domestic groups have to pay all their taxes. It is not an even playing field." (Anonymous). Using examples of the anti-
avoidance legislation, explain how the Tanzanian tax system tries to make it an even playing field between Tanzanian
domestic and multinational businesses and the extent to which you believe it is successful in this aim.
arrow_forward
From the U.S. standpoint, a capital outflow will occur when a Japanese investor buys a portion of the U.S. government debt.
True
False
arrow_forward
Your company located in the US imports raw materials from Europe. If the European Central Bank announces to lower the Euro exchange rate, what impact do you expect to see in your business?
A.
Your company will pay higher US dollar costs to import from Europe.
B.
Your company will pay lower US dollar costs to import from Europe.
C.
The Euro exchange rate doesn't have any impact on your company.
D.
It should reduce your competitiveness in your home market.
arrow_forward
Global Giant, a multinational corporation, has a producing subsidiary in a low-tax rate country and a marketing subsidiary in a high-tax country. If Global Giant wants to minimize its worldwide tax liability, we would expect Global Giant to ________.
A. stop producing in the low tax rate country
B. stop marketing in the high tax rate country
C. establish a low transfer price when the producing unit sells to the marketing unit
D. establish a high transfer price when the producing unit sells to the marketing unit
arrow_forward
Which of the following is NOT a benefit of investing in ADRs?
The dividends are received in U.S. currency.
Currency risk is minimized.
ADRs are subject to anti-fraud rules.
The transactions are done in U.S. currency.
arrow_forward
Determine the key reasons why a multinational corporation might decide to borrow in a country such as Brazil, where interest rates are high, rather than in a country like Switzerland, where interest rates are low. Provide support for your rationale.
What impact does foreign investment have on the weighted average cost of capital calculations?
arrow_forward
5. Agencies that facilitate international trade
Which of the following is true about the Overseas Private Investment Corporation (OPIC)?
OPIC does not provide services to exporters.
OPIC insures direct U.S. investments in foreign countries against various types of risks.
OPIC was formed in the later 1800's.
Most OPIC loans are short-term.
arrow_forward
IBM creates and sells additional stock to the investment banker Morgan Stanley. Morgan Stanley then
resells the issue to the U.S. public.
This transaction is an example of a(n)
asset transformation by Morgan Stanley.
primary market transaction.
foreign exchange transaction.
money market transaction.
forward transaction.
arrow_forward
i need the answer quickly
arrow_forward
Following an unanticipated dollar appreciation, would you recommend that a domestic manufacturing company such as Cummins Engine sell foreign assets? Yes or No
arrow_forward
In Chapter 14 we learned about
foreign income exclusion. Find
a person/company that uses it,
and do the following:
1. Name the person/company
2. Give a link to the financial
report/article
3. Explain what country taxes
were paid in and how that
translated to US income
arrow_forward
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Business/Professional Ethics Directors/Executives...
Accounting
ISBN:9781337485913
Author:BROOKS
Publisher:Cengage
Related Questions
- Tax avoidance vs. tax evasion = Over time, these concepts have become somewhat blurred. Define tax avoidance Define tax evasion Companies like Apple, Starbucks, etc. have enlisted the aid of CPA and law firms to assist them in minimizing their worldwide taxes. Afterwards, it was discovered that such companies had an effective tax rate of 5 - 10% for US tax, well below the 21% tax rate. There are numerous articles detailing what these companies did to achieve such low tax rates. Summarize what one of these companies did to achieve such a low effective federal tax rate. Were such actions legal? If so, why did the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) and various countries propose new tax rules? Please respond to all questions above.arrow_forwardBecause of political instability in North Africa, let’s not disclose specific countries. In addition, we restructured most of our French sales and some of our U.S. sales to occur through our offices in the Cayman Islands.This allows us to avoid paying higher taxes in those countries. The Cayman Islands has a 0% corporate incometax rate. We don’t want to highlight our ability to shift profits to avoid taxes.Required:Do you perceive an ethical dilemma? What would be the likely impact of following the controller’s suggestions?Who would benefit? Who would be injured?arrow_forwardSuppose InBev Corporation (a non-U.S. MNC) buys Anheuser-Busch Corporation (a U.S. corporation) by paying the U.S. shareholders in cash. Which of the following can be said of the US capital account? Group of answer choices The acquisition of cash by US shareholders will decrease foreign ownership, which will be recorded as a debit. The US federal reserve will increase its currency reserves. InBev's reduction in cash will be recorded as a debit on the U.S. capital account.. InBev's increased ownership of US assets is recorded as a credit. U.S. shareholders increased ownership in InBev will be recorded as a credit.arrow_forward
- Multinational corporations are exposed to higher risks that primarily come from two significant sources: (1) exchange rate risk and (2) political or country risk. An example of would be having property expropriated without adequate compensation. Which of the following are steps a company can take to reduce potential loss from expropriation? Check all that apply. Finance the subsidiary with local capital which reduces the local government's incentive to expropriate the multinational company's property. O Lock in the dollar return by selling currency in the forward market. Structure operations so that the subsidiary is only valuable as a part of the integrated corporate system. This reduces the risk exposure for the integrated company.arrow_forwardConsider a US-based MNC with a wholly owned Italian subsidiary. Following a depreciation of the dollar against the euro, which of the following conclusions are correct? Group of answer choices a. The cash flow in euros could be altered due a change in the firm's competitive position in the marketplace. b. A given operating cash flow in euros will be converted to a higher US dollar cash flow. c. Both A and B d. None of the abovearrow_forwardA simple solution to the problem of high corporate tax rates on investment incomewould be to apply a different, lower corporate tax rate directly to this type of income.Instead, the Canadian tax system uses refundable taxes to lower the rate of taxationon investment income of CCPCs. Why? Lower rates would provide a significant deferral of taxes on investment income. refundable taxes encourage early filing of corporate tax returns. lower rates would create a situation where the payment of dividends to shareholders would result in double taxation refundable taxes provide a reason to retain funds in the corporation.arrow_forward
- Shera Corporation has extensive liabilities denominated in pounds resulting from imports from UK. However, Shera's revenues are denominated solely in U.S. dollars. Which of the following is probably not true? A. Shera would benefit from a depreciation of the British pound. B. Shera has at least some economic exposure. C. All of the options are true. D. Shera has at least some transaction exposure. E. Shera has at least some translation exposure.arrow_forward2. "It is not fair that multinational groups can plan their way out of a tax charge in Tanzania whereas Tanzanian domestic groups have to pay all their taxes. It is not an even playing field." (Anonymous). Using examples of the anti- avoidance legislation, explain how the Tanzanian tax system tries to make it an even playing field between Tanzanian domestic and multinational businesses and the extent to which you believe it is successful in this aim.arrow_forwardFrom the U.S. standpoint, a capital outflow will occur when a Japanese investor buys a portion of the U.S. government debt. True Falsearrow_forward
- Your company located in the US imports raw materials from Europe. If the European Central Bank announces to lower the Euro exchange rate, what impact do you expect to see in your business? A. Your company will pay higher US dollar costs to import from Europe. B. Your company will pay lower US dollar costs to import from Europe. C. The Euro exchange rate doesn't have any impact on your company. D. It should reduce your competitiveness in your home market.arrow_forwardGlobal Giant, a multinational corporation, has a producing subsidiary in a low-tax rate country and a marketing subsidiary in a high-tax country. If Global Giant wants to minimize its worldwide tax liability, we would expect Global Giant to ________. A. stop producing in the low tax rate country B. stop marketing in the high tax rate country C. establish a low transfer price when the producing unit sells to the marketing unit D. establish a high transfer price when the producing unit sells to the marketing unitarrow_forwardWhich of the following is NOT a benefit of investing in ADRs? The dividends are received in U.S. currency. Currency risk is minimized. ADRs are subject to anti-fraud rules. The transactions are done in U.S. currency.arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
- Business/Professional Ethics Directors/Executives...AccountingISBN:9781337485913Author:BROOKSPublisher:Cengage
Business/Professional Ethics Directors/Executives...
Accounting
ISBN:9781337485913
Author:BROOKS
Publisher:Cengage