NATS W 1525 Tutorial II
pdf
keyboard_arrow_up
School
York University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
1525
Subject
Astronomy
Date
Apr 3, 2024
Type
Pages
6
Uploaded by BrigadierUniverse25768
The History of Extraterrestrial Life Debate
In-Class Tutorial II
January 24th, 2024
Group Member Names and Student IDs
Name:
...........................................
ID:
...........................................
Name:
...........................................
ID:
...........................................
Name:
...........................................
ID:
...........................................
Name:
...........................................
ID:
...........................................
Name:
...........................................
ID:
...........................................
1
Getting to know the Solar System
As discussed during the lecture, for many centuries, it was assumed that the Earth is
at the centre of the Universe and the Sun along with other planets orbit it in circular
orbits. The purpose of this tutorial is to help you get familiarized with some general
properties of the solar system. It is essential to keep this information in the back of
your mind when we speak of people’s thoughts on the existence of life elsewhere in
the solar system. In order to complete this tutorial, you will need to learn about a
particular unit of distance used when talking about distances between the Sun and
the planets. This unit of distance is known as the Astronomical Unit (AU) and is
equal to the average distance between the Earth and the Sun, roughly equal to 150
million kilometres. Instead of using annoyingly large numbers, expressing the values
in AU allows us to work with small numbers.
For instance, we say that Venus is
located at 0.7 AU (70% of the average distance between the Earth and the Sun)
instead of 108,208,000 km and Jupiter is at 5.2 AU (5.2 times the average distance
between Earth and the Sun) instead of 778,479,000. Now take a look at the table
1
given in this tutorial. You will notice that some of the values are missing. In partic-
ular, the
average distances
of some of the bodies in the solar system are not given.
Use the following formula, to fill in the values for the
predicted average dis-
tance
from the Sun (in AU) in the table:
a
= 0
.
4 + (0
.
3
×
2
n
)
where
n
=
-∞
,
0
,
1
,
2
, ...
(1)
In the above equation, each value of the “n” provides the distance of a planet from
the Sun, with distances getting larger as n takes up larger values. After filling in the
predicted values, try googling the actual distances between Sun and the bodies and
complete the column right beside the predicted values (actual values). For the case
of the moons of planets, take them to have the same distance as their parent planet.
After completing the table, answer the following questions based on the information
in the table.
1. Is there a distance at which the law predicts the existence of a planet for which
there is no planet listed in the table? Describe.
2. Google the distance of Ceres, the first dwarf planet discovered. Can you now
explain the significance of the value of the number obtained in the previous
question? Hint: look up the average distance of the Asteroid Belt, a band of
rocks of a variety of sizes between Mars and Jupiter.
3. For which planet, do you see big variations between the distance predicted by
the law and the actual distance?
4. So, by now, you should have noticed that the law works pretty well for planets
all the way to Saturn and Uranus. This law was known as the Titius-Bode law,
named after Johann Titius and Johann Bode (we will disucss Bode’s position
2
on the existence of extraterrestrial life later in this course). In fact, this law
motivated the search for a planet orbiting the Sun between Mars and Jupiter.
It also suggested that Uranus (which was sometimes incorrectly classified as a
star) was a planet. Following the prediction of Titius-Bode law for the exis-
tence of a planet between Mars and Jupiter, a new planet was discovered in
the predicted location, the dwarf planet Ceres. Google Ceres and dig out some
basic properties of it (mass, radius, distance and surface temperature). Why
is it called a dwarf planet (hint: find out how we define dwarf planets)?
As a note aside, the argument for the existence of a planet between Mars
and Jupiter was more of a religious one rather than a scientific one.
It was
argued that the beauty and elegance of the placement of the planets by God
must not break suddenly break. This motivated much search for a planet in
between Mars and Jupiter. Finally, note that Titius-Bode law is not considered
a scientific law anymore even though people are still trying to find a rationale
behind it and investigate whether it works for other planetary systems or not.
3
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Table 1: The Bodies in the Solar System
Planet/Moon
Average Dist.
Mass
Radius
Surface
No. of
Rotational
Orbital
from the Sun (AU)
(
×
M
♁
)
(
×
R
♁
)
Temp.
◦
C
Moons
Period
Period
Water
predicted
actual
Mercury
0.055
0.3829
430
0
58.646 d.
87.96 days
Yes
Venus
0.815
0.9499
464
0
-243.025 d.
224.701 days
No
Earth
1
1
1
1
15
1
23h&56m
365.25 days
Yes
Moon
1
0.012
0.273
53
N/A
27.32 days
27.32 days
Yes
Mars
0.107
0.533
-63
2
24h&37mins
668.6 days
Yes
Jupiter
317.8
11.2
-108
67
9h&55mins
11.86 years
Yes
Europa
5.2
0.008
0.245
-171
N/A
3.55 days
3.55 days
Yes
(Jupiter’s Moon)
Saturn
95.1
9.45
-139
62
10h&33 mins
29.451 years
Yes
Titan
0.0225
0.4
-179.5
N/A
15.945 days
15.945 days
Yes
(Saturn’s Moon)
Uranus
14.5
4
-197
27
17h&14mins
84 years
Yes
Neptune
17.14
3.8
-201
14
16h&6mins
164.8 years
Yes
4
Complete the table in the previous page by filling the missing values. Take the
moons of different planets to be at the same distance as their planet from the Sun.
Then answer the following questions.
Note: You will need to remember the answers to the questions below that appear
in bold for your exam.
1. Which planet has the biggest radius?
2. Which planet is the most massive?
3.
Which planet is the hottest planet (surprise)?
4. Which planet has the longest orbital period (this means the longest year)?
5. Which planet has the longest rotational period (this means the longest day)?
6. Which planet has the shortest orbital period (this means the shortest year)?
7. Which planet has the shortest rotational period (this means the shortest day)?
8.
Which planet’s day is longer than its year (imagine all the festivities
the inhabitants of these planets would have at sunset!!!)?
9.
Which planet has the closest length of day to that of the Earth?
10.
Which planet is completely devoid of water?
11. Which two planets have very similar orbital periods (your answer could be “no
two planets!”)?
5
12.
Which two planets have very similar rotational periods?
13.
Which planet has the biggest number of moons?
14.
Which planets do not have moons?
15.
What is special about the rotation and revolution of the moons de-
scribed in the table
?
16.
Which two planets have the closest mass?
Earth and Venus
17.
Which two planets have the closest radii (at the end of this, you must
be saying”oh my, these two planets are twins and yet so different”)?
18.
List the gaseous planets in order of increasing mass.
19.
List the rocky planets in order of increasing mass.
6
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help