DS-CO1-2301E-PC02.FG=RC+RC+C+RC+RC
xlsx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Quaid-e-Awam University of Engineering, Sciences & Technology, Nawabshah *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
LQB185
Subject
Accounting
Date
Nov 24, 2024
Type
xlsx
Pages
2
Uploaded by dhandeepthiara
Core 1 — Practice Case 2
Ref.
Minimum Proficiency Indicator (MPI) Description
CPA Way
N/P/Y
Feedback
1
Situation
Y
2
Analyze
Y
3
— each party's rights
Analyze
Y
4
— payment terms
Analyze
Y
5
— commercial substance
Analyze
P
6
— collectability
Analyze
Y
7
Concludes as to WHEN the revenue should be recognized, consistent with analysis
Conclude
Y
8
Conclude
P
NA
The candidate does not address this assessment opportunity.
RC
NC
The candidate does not meet the standards for reaching competence.
RC
C
CD
1
Situation
Y
2
Analyzes the criteria regarding distinct performance obligations in relation to case facts
Analyze
Y
3
Analyze
Y
4
Analyzes the allocation of the purchase price between performance obligations
Analyze
Y
5
Analyze
P
6
Concludes as to how the RentPoints should be recorded, consistent with analysis
Conclude
Y
7
Conclude
Y
NA
The candidate does not address this assessment opportunity.
RC
NC
The candidate does not meet the standards for reaching competence.
RC
C
CD
1
Situation
Y
2
Analyze
Y
3
Concludes whether inventory should be written down to NRV, consistent with analysis
Conclude
Y
4
Conclude
P
NA
The candidate does not address this assessment opportunity.
C
NC
The candidate does not meet the standards for reaching competence.
RC
C
CD
1
Analyze
Y
2
— financial statements used by the bank to assess the bank loan
Analyze
Y
3
— new programs initiated during the year
Analyze
N
4
— long-time client with no history of issues
Analyze
N
5
— existing financial reporting errors
Analyze
N
6
— multiple new locations
Analyze
N
7
— other valid financial statement risk
Analyze
N
8
Concludes on risk of material misstatement (RMM) at the overall financial statement level (OFSL)
Conclude
Y
NA
The candidate does not address this assessment opportunity.
RC
NC
The candidate does not meet the standards for reaching competence.
RC
C
CD
1
Analyze
Y
2
Identifies the users objectives
Analyze
Y
3
Determines an appropriate basis for materiality
Analyze
P
4
Analyze
P
5
Analyze
N
6
Calculates materiality on a reasonable basis
Conclude
N
7
Concludes on the approach that will be taken for the audit engagement (supported)
Analyze
P
NA
The candidate does not address this assessment opportunity.
RC
NC
The candidate does not meet the standards for reaching competence.
RC
C
CD
Y
Overall Feedback
AO1 (Financial Reporting —
No Late Fees program
)
Identifies the financial reporting issue
IFRS 15
You were assessed at RC for this assessment opportunity.
Good attempt identifying valid criteria and correctly discussing most of them in relation to the case
facts.
To improve to C on future cases, ensure you are discussing all valid criteria in relation to the case
facts and correctly conclude for each one if it is met or not met that is based on the case facts. For
example, revisit MPI 5 as the steps to reach to the recommendation needs to be more strengthened.
Analyzes the criteria for identifying a contract in relation to case facts:
— parties have approved the contract
Discusses the impact of the adjustments on the financial statements and their impact on the bank and the
bank's concern with profitability
The candidate attempts to discuss the accounting treatment for the revenue related to the No Late Fees program (
Yes
on 3 MPIs OR Partial on 5 MPIs
).
The candidate discusses the accounting treatment for the revenue related to the No Late Fees program, including a
conclusion (
Yes on MPIs 1-7
).
The candidate thoroughly discusses the accounting treatment for the revenue related to the No Late Fees program,
including a conclusion, and the impact of the issue on the financial statements, the bank, and the bank's concern with
profitability (
Yes on all
).
AO2 (Financial Reporting —
RentPoints
)
Identifies the financial reporting issue
IFRS 15
You were assessed at RC for this assessment opportunity. You did a great job of applying IFRS 15 in
your discussion using case facts to show how this applied to this specific situation. Good job including
a useful conclusion on how the RentPoints should be treated. Nice work also discussing how this
would impact the financial statements and the bank.
To improve you response to C, ensure you are correctly calculating the number of points using the
case facts around $0.50 in your analysis.
Analyzes the definition of a performance obligation and whether the RentPoints reward program represents
a distinct obligation
Calculates the number of points still outstanding at year end based on revenue for the year and points
redeemed
Discusses the impact of the issue on the financial statements and its impact on the bank and the bank's
concern with profitability
The candidate attempts to discuss the accounting treatment for the revenue related to the RentPoints reward program
(
Yes on 2 MPIs OR Partial on 4 MPIs
).
The candidate discusses the accounting treatment for the revenue related to the RentPoints reward program,
including a conclusion (
Yes on MPIs 1-6
).
The candidate thoroughly discusses the accounting treatment for the revenue related to the RentPoints reward
program, including a conclusion, and the impact of the issue on the financial statements, the bank, and the bank's
concern with profitability (
Yes on all
).
AO3 (Financial Reporting —
Previously worn costumes
)
Identifies the financial reporting issue
IAS 2
You were assessed at C for this assessment opportunity.
You were not only able to identify that an inventory valuation issue might exists, but you also
assessed whether it should be valued at the lower of cost and NRV.
You also recommended that the
inventory should be written down. Good job a conclusion is imperative to any discussion (tax,
accounting, assurance etc.), after your analysis you must conclude - otherwise no mater how well you
wrote you will not get "C".
To achieve CD on future cases, ensure you are also providing correct calculation using the case facts
as your resulting numbers were slightly off. Please take a look.
Analyzes that inventory must be carried at the lower of cost and NRV criteria,
in relation to case facts
Discusses the impact of the issue on the financial statements and its impact on the bank and the bank's
concern with profitability
The candidate attempts to discuss the accounting treatment of the inventory of previously worn costumes (
Yes on 2
MPIs
OR Partial on 3 MPIs
).
The candidate discusses the accounting treatment of the inventory of previously worn costumes, including a
conclusion (
Yes on MPIs 1-3
).
The candidate thoroughly discusses the accounting treatment of the inventory of previously worn costumes, including
a conclusion, and the impact of the issue on the financial statements, and the bank's concern with profitability (
Yes on
all
).
AO4 (Assurance —
Overall financial statement risk assessment
)
Discusses a valid risk factor:
(
Yes includes what the risk factor is (case fact) and WHY it is a risk.)
— rapid expansion
You were assessed at RC for this assessment opportunity. Good job at providing a risk assessment
noting why each risk was important and if it increased or decreased risk of material misstatement.
This is what your users are looking for, so what?
Good work clearly concluding on the overall RMM.
To improve to C for this type of AO on future cases, ensure you are discussing more factors as they
were many case facts given that can be discussed under this AO to provide a complete discussion.
A review of risks of the Audit and Assurance eBook may be helpful.
The candidate attempts to assess the overall financial statement risk by discussing some of the risks factors (
Yes on
3 MPIs OR Partial on 4 MPIs
).
The candidate assesses the overall financial statement risk by discussing some of the risks factors and concludes
that the RMM is moderate or high (
Yes on 4 MPIs including MPI 8
).
The candidate assesses the overall financial statement risk by discussing several of the risks factors and concludes
that the RMM is moderate or high (
Yes on 6 MPIs including MPI 8
).
AO5 (Assurance —
Materiality and approach
)
Identifies the users of the financial statements
You were assessed at RC for this assessment opportunity.
You identified the users of the F/S and their objectives. Further to this, you needed to correctly identify
the basis for materiality such as net income which is a good indication of cash flow for which the bank
is concerned about debt repayment. Considering there were errors in the statement, you have to see
how this will impact your calculations elsewhere. Integration is very important. You should be able to
connect the dots across the AOs to provide a cohesive analysis. This depth was needed to get to C.
In addition to improve to C for this type of AO and as a future CPA, you also need to add depth in the
discussion of audit approach to give an example of how would you test the controls to your user. This
approach will help you add depth. Remember, technical and case facts go hand in hand.
Determines an appropriate percentage threshold for materiality (3% -
to 7%)
Adjusts pre-tax materiality base for accounting or normalizing adjustments
The candidate attempts to calculate materiality and attempts to discuss the approach for the engagement (
Yes on 3
MPIs OR Partial on 4 MPIs
).
The candidate calculates materiality and discusses the approach for the engagement (
Yes on 4 MPIs, including MPIs
6 + 7
).
The candidate accurately calculates materiality and discusses the approach for the engagement (
Yes on all
).
Communication
— The candidate prepares a response that is logically organized with good use of headings and bullet
points. The response is professional in tone and sufficiently readable in terms of spelling, grammar, punctuation, and
acronyms/abbreviations.
Memo to Engagement Partner
Your response was sufficiently readable in terms of spelling and grammar. Good job using the
headings and sub-headings to separate the issues and bullet points to highlight key areas. This
makes it easy for your user to follow your work. Good that you used memo format to meet your case
required.
You stayed within the limit of 1800 words and I hope you were able to complete your response within exam like condition. If not, no problem as you will get better with each passing week with more practice. However, your discussion of
materiality and approach lacked depth. Please ensure you are very familiar with the technical and case facts to add depth in your analysis.
Continue to write practice cases in the exam like condition. This practice is invaluable.
Continue to write practice cases in the exam like condition. This practice is invaluable.
Continue using the CPA way of analysis i.e. issue ID, analysis (technical + case facts) and recommendation.
Make sure to debrief and make 'take away' notes which are not case specific to help you for the next PC you'll be writing.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Related Documents
Related Questions
Adverse
agreed upon procedures assertion
attestation risk
Consistent measurements
Control criteria
Financial forecast
Quantitative or qualitative
Responsible party
SOC 3
Trust Services
arrow_forward
the financial statements must contain appropriate information for it to be useful to the users. Which term best describes this statement:
A. Relevant, B, Material, C, Complete, D, Neutral
Note:-
Do not provide handwritten solution. Maintain accuracy and quality in your answer. Take care of plagiarism.
Answer completely.
You will get up vote for sure.
arrow_forward
Please answer attached question
thanks
arrow_forward
Typed please and provide a quality solution for better ratings already got so many negative ratings please provide a high quality solution for better ratings and take care kf plagiarism also I will upvite for sure
arrow_forward
Contingency fee based pricing of accounting services is:
a
Always strictly prohibited in public accounting practice.
b
Never restricted in public accounting practice.
c
Prohibited for clients for whom attestation services are provided.
d
Considered an act discreditable to the profession.
arrow_forward
Listed below are selected Rules of Conduct and ethical problems. Match the rule with the problem to which it applies. (One Rule of
Conduct may apply to more than one ethical problem.)
Rules
A. Independence
B. Integrity and objectivity
C. General standards
D. Compliance with standards
E. Accounting principles
F. Contingent fees
G. Acts discreditable
H. Advertising and other forms of solicitation
I. Commissions and referral fees
J. Form or practice and name
Rules
An audit client owes the CPA past-due audit fees.
The auditors fail to qualify their opinion on financial statements that do not properly apply FASB standards.
A CPA who is the controller for a company knowingly issues misleading financial statements.
A CPA performs tax services that the CPA is not competent to perform.
A sole practitioner practices in a partnership name.
A member violates rules issued by the Accounting and Review Services Committee.
A CPA robs a service station.
A CPA accepts a percentage of the client's loan…
arrow_forward
A threat that a CPA will not appropriately evaluate the results of a previous judgment made by, or service performed by, an individual in the CPA's firm is a(n) O advocacy threat familiarity threat O self-review threat O self-interest threat
Note:-
Do not provide handwritten solution. Maintain accuracy and quality in your answer. Take care of plagiarism.
Answer completely.
You will get up vote for sure.
arrow_forward
What is the most important quality for accounting information as identified in the conceptual framework? Explain why it is the most important.
Note:-
Do not provide handwritten solution. Maintain accuracy and quality in your answer. Take care of plagiarism.
Answer completely.
You will get up vote for sure.
arrow_forward
What role does assurance boundary definition play in attestation? a) Standard limits work always b) Boundaries never matter c) All areas need equal coverage d) Engagement scope limits determine verification responsibilities. Want answer to this accounting mcq
arrow_forward
4.Which of the following define lowballing:Single choice.
Offering the client a low fee in the hope that they will tell others and increase the auditors client base.
Offering the audit at an artificially high fee to ensure that a good margin is made on the fee
Offering the audit an artificially low fee in order to get the work before increasing fees later or offering other services to the client.
Offering the client tax services only.
arrow_forward
Hansh
arrow_forward
find out solution q given
arrow_forward
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Auditing: A Risk Based-Approach (MindTap Course L...
Accounting
ISBN:9781337619455
Author:Karla M Johnstone, Audrey A. Gramling, Larry E. Rittenberg
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Auditing: A Risk Based-Approach to Conducting a Q...
Accounting
ISBN:9781305080577
Author:Karla M Johnstone, Audrey A. Gramling, Larry E. Rittenberg
Publisher:South-Western College Pub
Related Questions
- Adverse agreed upon procedures assertion attestation risk Consistent measurements Control criteria Financial forecast Quantitative or qualitative Responsible party SOC 3 Trust Servicesarrow_forwardthe financial statements must contain appropriate information for it to be useful to the users. Which term best describes this statement: A. Relevant, B, Material, C, Complete, D, Neutral Note:- Do not provide handwritten solution. Maintain accuracy and quality in your answer. Take care of plagiarism. Answer completely. You will get up vote for sure.arrow_forwardPlease answer attached question thanksarrow_forward
- Typed please and provide a quality solution for better ratings already got so many negative ratings please provide a high quality solution for better ratings and take care kf plagiarism also I will upvite for surearrow_forwardContingency fee based pricing of accounting services is: a Always strictly prohibited in public accounting practice. b Never restricted in public accounting practice. c Prohibited for clients for whom attestation services are provided. d Considered an act discreditable to the profession.arrow_forwardListed below are selected Rules of Conduct and ethical problems. Match the rule with the problem to which it applies. (One Rule of Conduct may apply to more than one ethical problem.) Rules A. Independence B. Integrity and objectivity C. General standards D. Compliance with standards E. Accounting principles F. Contingent fees G. Acts discreditable H. Advertising and other forms of solicitation I. Commissions and referral fees J. Form or practice and name Rules An audit client owes the CPA past-due audit fees. The auditors fail to qualify their opinion on financial statements that do not properly apply FASB standards. A CPA who is the controller for a company knowingly issues misleading financial statements. A CPA performs tax services that the CPA is not competent to perform. A sole practitioner practices in a partnership name. A member violates rules issued by the Accounting and Review Services Committee. A CPA robs a service station. A CPA accepts a percentage of the client's loan…arrow_forward
- A threat that a CPA will not appropriately evaluate the results of a previous judgment made by, or service performed by, an individual in the CPA's firm is a(n) O advocacy threat familiarity threat O self-review threat O self-interest threat Note:- Do not provide handwritten solution. Maintain accuracy and quality in your answer. Take care of plagiarism. Answer completely. You will get up vote for sure.arrow_forwardWhat is the most important quality for accounting information as identified in the conceptual framework? Explain why it is the most important. Note:- Do not provide handwritten solution. Maintain accuracy and quality in your answer. Take care of plagiarism. Answer completely. You will get up vote for sure.arrow_forwardWhat role does assurance boundary definition play in attestation? a) Standard limits work always b) Boundaries never matter c) All areas need equal coverage d) Engagement scope limits determine verification responsibilities. Want answer to this accounting mcqarrow_forward
- 4.Which of the following define lowballing:Single choice. Offering the client a low fee in the hope that they will tell others and increase the auditors client base. Offering the audit at an artificially high fee to ensure that a good margin is made on the fee Offering the audit an artificially low fee in order to get the work before increasing fees later or offering other services to the client. Offering the client tax services only.arrow_forwardHansharrow_forwardfind out solution q givenarrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
- Auditing: A Risk Based-Approach (MindTap Course L...AccountingISBN:9781337619455Author:Karla M Johnstone, Audrey A. Gramling, Larry E. RittenbergPublisher:Cengage LearningAuditing: A Risk Based-Approach to Conducting a Q...AccountingISBN:9781305080577Author:Karla M Johnstone, Audrey A. Gramling, Larry E. RittenbergPublisher:South-Western College Pub
Auditing: A Risk Based-Approach (MindTap Course L...
Accounting
ISBN:9781337619455
Author:Karla M Johnstone, Audrey A. Gramling, Larry E. Rittenberg
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Auditing: A Risk Based-Approach to Conducting a Q...
Accounting
ISBN:9781305080577
Author:Karla M Johnstone, Audrey A. Gramling, Larry E. Rittenberg
Publisher:South-Western College Pub